of the Catholic Church, being prepared even to meet the hostility of abandoned men; whilst
the greater number, though equally convinced, and though desirous to do the same, yet
dared not make enemies of these men, who were so unbridled in their violence, seeing that
some who had come over to us experienced the greatest cruelty at their hands.
17. To this we may add, that in Carthage itself some of the bishops of the same party,
making a schism among themselves, and dividing the party of Donatus among the lower
orders of the Carthaginian people, ordained as bishop against bishop a certain deacon named
Maximianus, who could not brook the control of his own diocesan. And as this displeased
the greater part of them, they condemned the aforesaid Maximinus, with twelve others who
had been present at his ordination, but gave the rest that were associated in the same schism
a chance of returning to their communion on an appointed day. But afterwards some of
these twelve, and certain others of those who had had the time of grace allowed to them,
but had only returned after the day appointed, were received by them without degradation
from their orders; and they did not venture to baptize a second time those whom the con-
demned ministers had baptized outside the pale of their communion. This action of theirs
at once made strongly against them in favor of the Catholic party, so that their mouths were
wholly closed. And on the matter being diligently spread abroad, as was only right, in order
to cure men’s souls of the evils of schism, and when it was shown in every possible direction
by the sermons and discussions of the Catholic divines, that to maintain the peace of Donatus
they had not only received back those whom they had condemned, with full recognition of
their orders, but had even been afraid to declare that baptism to be void which had been
administered outside their Church by men whom they had condemned or even suspended;
whilst, in violation of the peace of Christ, they cast in the teeth of all the world the stain
conveyed by contact with some sinners, it matters little with whom, and declared baptism
to be consequently void which had been administered even in the very Churches whence
the gospel itself had come to Africa;—seeing all this, very many began to be confounded,
and blushing before what they saw to be mostly manifest truth, they submitted to correction
in greater numbers than was their wont; and men began to breathe with a somewhat freer
640
sense of liberty from their cruelty, and that to a considerably greater extent in every direction.
18. Then indeed they blazed forth with such fury, and were so excited by the goadings
of hatred, that scarcely any churches of our communion could be safe against their treachery
and violence and most undisguised robberies; scarcely any road secure by which men could
travel to preach the peace of the Catholic Church in opposition to their madness, and convict
the rashness of their folly by the clear enunciation of the truth. They went so far, besides,
in proposing hard terms of reconciliation, not only to the laity or to any of the clergy, but
even in a measure to certain of the Catholic bishops. For the only alternative offered was
to hold their tongues about the truth, or to endure their savage fury. But if they did not
speak about the truth, not only was it impossible for any one to be delivered by their silence,
1269
Chapter 4