Chapter XV.—Unfairness of Charging the Disciples of the New Prophecy with Harsh-
ness. The Charge Rather to Be Retorted Upon the Psychics.
What harshness, therefore, is here on our part, if we renounce (communion with) such
as do not the will of God? What heresy, if we judge second marriage, as being unlawful,
akin to adultery? For what is adultery but unlawful marriage? The apostle sets a brand
upon those who were wont entirely to forbid marriage, who were wont at the same time to
lay an interdict on meats which God has created. 682 We, however, no more do away with
marriage if we abjure its repetition, than we reprobate meats if we fast oftener (than others).
It is one thing to do away with, another to regulate; it is one thing to lay down a law of not
marrying, it is another to fix a limit to marrying. To speak plainly, if they who reproach us
with harshness, or esteem heresy (to exist) in this (our) cause, foster the “infirmity of the
flesh” to such a degree as to think it must have support accorded to it in frequency of mar-
riage; why do they in another case neither accord it support nor foster it with indul-
gence—when, (namely), torments have reduced it to a denial (of the faith)? For, of course,
that (infirmity) is more capable of excuse which has fallen in battle, than (that) which (has
fallen) in the bed-chamber; (that) which has succumbed on the rack, than (that) which (has
succumbed) on the bridal bed; (that) which has yielded to cruelty, than (that) which (has
yielded) to appetite; that which has been overcome groaning, than (that) which (has been
overcome) in heat. But the former they excommunicate, because it has not “endured unto
the end:” 683 the latter they prop up, as if withal it has “endured unto the end.” Propose
(the question) why each has not “endured unto the end;” and you will find the cause of that
(infirmity) to be more honourable which has been unable to sustain savagery, than (of that)
which (has been unable to sustain) modesty. And yet not even a bloodwrung—not to say
an immodest—defection does the “infirmity of the flesh” excuse!
682 See 1 Tim. iv. 1–3.
683 See Matt. xxiv. 13, and the references there.
Unfairness of Charging the Disciples of the New Prophecy with Harshness. The Charge Rather to Be Retorted Upon the Psychics.
163
Unfairness of Charging the Disciples of the New Prophecy with Harshness. …