Letter LIX.
(a.d. 401.)
To My Most Blessed Lord and Venerable Father Victorinus, My Brother in the Priest-
hood, Augustin Sends Greeting in the Lord.
1. Your summons to the Council reached me on the fifth day before the Ides of
November, in the evening, and found me very much indisposed, so that I could not possibly
attend. However, I submit to your pious and wise judgment whether certain perplexities
which the summons occasioned were due to my own ignorance or to sufficient grounds. I
read in that summons that it was written also to the districts of Mauritania, which, as we
know, have their own primates. Now, if these provinces were to be represented in a Council
held in Numidia, it was by all means proper that the names of some of the more eminent
bishops who are in Mauritania should be attached to the circular letter; and not finding this,
I have been greatly surprised. Moreover, to the bishops of Numidia it has been addressed
in such a confused and careless manner, that my own name I find in the third place, although
I know my proper order to be much further down in the roll of bishops. This wrongs others,
and grieves me. Moreover, our venerable father and colleague, Xantippus of Tagosa, says
that the primacy belongs to him, and by very many he is regarded as the primate, and he
issues such letters as you have sent. Even supposing that this be a mistake, which your
Holiness can easily discover and correct, certainly his name should not have been omitted
in the summons which you have issued. If his name had been placed in the middle of the
list, and not in the first line, I would have wondered much; how much greater, then, is my
surprise, when I find in it no mention whatever made of him who, above all others, behoved
to be present in the Council, that by the bishops of all the Numidian churches this question
of the order of the primacy might be debated before any other!
2. For these reasons, I might even hesitate to come to the Council, lest the summons in
which so many flagrant mistakes are found should be a forgery; even were I not hindered
both by the shortness of the notice, and manifold other important engagements standing
in the way. I therefore beg you, most blessed prelate, to excuse me, and to be pleased to give
attention, in the first instance, to bring about between your Holiness and the aged Xantippus
a cordial mutual understanding as to the question which of you ought to summon the
Council; or at least, as I think would be still better, let both of you, without prejudging the
claim of either, conjointly call together our colleagues, especially those who have been nearly
as long in the episcopate as yourselves, who may easily discover and decide which of you
has truth on his side,1858 that this question may be settled first among a few of you; and
then, when the mistake has been rectified, let the younger bishops be gathered together,
1858 The primacy in Numidia belonged not to the bishop of the most important town, but to the oldest
bishop.
To Victorinus
715
To Victorinus