is become of all this grand dispute about the lawfulness of persons coming to the Lord’s
table, who have not converting grace?
VI. Mr. W. greatly misrepresents me from time to time, as though I had asserted, that
it is impossible for an unsanctified man to enter into covenant with God; and that those who
were sanctified among the Israelites, did not enter into covenant with God; that the pretended
covenanting of such is not covenanting, but only lying, wilful lying; and that no natural man
can own the covenant, but that he, certainly lies, knows he lies, and designedly lies, in all these
things, when he says them. (p. 26. d. 22. d. 24. d. 31. a. b. c. 21. c.) Whereas, I never said nor
supposed any such thing. I never doubted but that multitudes of unsanctified persons, and
in all ages of the christian church, and in this age, and here in New England, have entered
visibly, and in profession, into the covenant of grace, and have owned that covenant, and
promised a compliance with all the duties of it, without known or wilful lying; for this
reason, because they were deceived, and did not know their own hearts: and that they
(however deceived) were under the obligations of the covenant, and bound by their engage-
ments and promises. And that in that sense, they were God’s covenant people, that by their
own binding act they were engaged to God in covenant; though such an act, performed
without habitual holiness, be an unlawful one. If a thing be externally devoted to God, by
doing what ought not to have been done, the thing devoted may, by that act, be the Lord’s:
as it was with the censers of Korah and his company. (Num. xvi. 37, 38.)
509
What I asserted, was, that none could profess a compliance with the covenant of grace,
and avouch jehovah to be their God, and Christ to be their Saviour, i.e. that they are so by
their own act and choice, and yet love the world more than jehovah without lying, or being
deceived. 412 And that he who is wholly under the power of a carnal mind, which is not
subject to the law of God, nor indeed can be, cannot promise to love God with all his heart
and with all his soul, without either great deceit, or the most manifest and palpable absurdity.
Inasmuch as promising supposes the person to be conscious to himself, or persuaded of
himself, that he has such a heart in him; because his lips pretend to declare his heart, and
the nature of a promise implies real intention, will, and compliance of heart. 413 And what
can be more evident than these propositions? Surely they that reject the covenant of grace
in their hearts (as Mr. W. owns all unsanctified men do) cannot own it with their lips, without
either deceiving or being deceived. Words cannot be a true signification of more than is in
the mind. Inward covenanting, as Mr. S. taught, is by an act of saving faith. (Safety of Ap. p.
85. e. 86. a.) And outward covenanting is an expression of inward covenanting; therefore, if
it be not attended with inward covenanting, it is a false expression. And Mr. W. in effect
owns the same thing; for he says, (p. 21. b.) ” That there is no doubt they who are wilful
412 See my Inquiry, p. 33, 34.
413 Ibid. p.37,38.
1964
SECTION IX. Public covenanting.