SECT. II.
Instances of the second thing mentioned as exceptionable in Mr. W.‘s method of managing
this controversy; viz. His misrepresenting what is said in the writings of others, that he supposes
favour his opinion.
Perhaps instances enough of this have already been taken notice of; yet I would now
mention some others.
In what he says in reply to my answer to the eighth objection, he says, (p. 108.) “Mr.
Stoddard does not say, If sanctifying Grace be necessary to a person’s lawful partaking of
the Lord’s supper, then God would have given some certain rule, whereby those who are to
admit them, may know whether they have such grace or not.” Mr. W. there intimates (as
the reader may see) as if Mr. S. spake so, that it is to be understood disjunctively, meaning,
he would either have given some certain rule to the church who admit them, or else to the
persons themselves: so that by one means or other, the Lord’s supper might be restrained to
converted men. And he exclaims against me for representing as though Mr. Stoddard’s argu-
ment were concerning a certain rule, whereby those who are to admit them, may know
whether they have grace, (see the foregoing page,) and speaks of it as nothing akin to Mr.
S.‘s argument. Now let the reader take notice of Mr. S.‘s words, and see whether his argument
be not something akin to this. He says expressly, (Appeal, p. 75.) “God does not bind his
church to impossibilities. If he had made such an ordinance, he would give gifts to his
church, to distinguish sincere men from hypocrites, whereby the ordinance might have been
attended.—The minor is also evident: he has given no such rule to his church, whereby it
may be restrained to converted men. This appears, because by the rule that they are to go
by, they are allowed to give the Lord’s supper to many unconverted men. For all visible signs
are common to men converted, and unconverted.” So that Mr. S. in fact does say, If sancti-
fying grace be necessary to a person’s lawful partaking of the Lord’s supper, then God would
have given some certain rule, whereby the church [those who are to admit them] may know,”
whether they have grace, or not. Though Mr. W. denies it, and says, this is nothing akin to
Mr. S.‘s argument; contrary to the plainest fact.
In p. 99. Mr. W. replying to my answer to the sixth objection, misrepresents Mr. Hudson,
in the following passage. “This, (i. e. baptism,) says Mr. Hudson, makes them members of
the body of Christ. And as for a particular explicit covenant, besides the general imposed
on churches, I find no mention of it, no example, nor warrant for it, in all the Scrip-
ture.”—Here Mr. W. is still manifestly endeavouring to discredit my doctrine of an explicit
owning the covenant of grace; and he so manages and alters Mr. Hudson’s words, as naturally
leads the reader to suppose, that Mr. Hudson speaks against this: whereas, he says not a
word about it. What Mr. H. speaks of, is not an explicit owning the covenant of grace, or
baptismal covenant; but a particular church-covenant, by which a particular society bind
themselves explicitly, one to another, jointly to carry on the public worship. Mr. Hudson’s
SECTION II. Misrepresentations.
1973
SECTION II. Misrepresentations.