exegetical of the first. “Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by
sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that (or unto which) all have sinned.” Here sin
and death are so spoken of in the former and in the latter part that the same things are clearly
meant by the terms in both parts. Besides, to interpret sinning, here, by falling under the
suffering of death, is yet the more violent and unreasonable, because the apostle in this very
place once and again distinguishes between sin and death; plainly speaking of one as the effect,
and the other the cause. So in the 21st verse, “that as sin hath reigned unto death;” and in
the 12th verse, ”sin entered into the world, and death by sin.’’ And this plain distinction
holds through all the discourse, as between death and the offence, ver. 15. and ver. 17. .
and between the offence and condemnation, ver. 18. .
4. Though we should omit the consideration of the manner in which the apostle uses
the words, sin, sinned, &c. in other places, and in other parts of this discourse, yet Dr. T.‘s
interpretation of them would be very absurd.
The case stands thus: according to his exposition, we are said to have sinned by an active
verb, as though we had actively sinned; yet this is not spoken truly and properly, but it is
put figuratively for our becoming sinners passively, our being made or constituted sinners.
Yet again, not that we do truly become sinners passively, or are really made sinners, by any
thing that God does; this also is only a figurative or tropical representation; and the meaning
is only, we are condemned, and treated as if we were sinners. Not indeed that we are properly
condemned, for God never truly condemns the innocent; but this also is only a figurative
representation of the thing. It is but as it were condemning; because it is appointing to death,
a terrible evil, as if it were a punishment. But then, in reality, here is no appointment to a
terrible evil, or any evil at all; but truly to a benefit, a great benefit; and so in representing
death as a punishment, another figure is used, and an exceeding bold one; for, as we are
appointed to it, it is so far from being an evil or punishment, that it is really a favour, and
that of the highest nature, appointed by mere grace and love, though it seems to be a
calamity.
Thus we have tropes and figures multiplied, one upon another; and all in that one word,
sinned; according to the manner, as it is supposed, in which the apostle uses it. We have a
figurative representation, not of a reality, but of a figurative representation. Neither is this a
representation of a reality, but of another thing that still is but a figurative representation of
something else: yea, even this something else is still but a figure, and one that is very harsh
and far-fetched. So that here we have a figure to represent a figure, even a figure of a figure,
representing some very remote figure, which most obscurely represents the thing intended;
if the most terrible evil can indeed be said at all to represent the contrary good of the highest
kind. And now, what cannot be made of any place of Scripture, in such a way as this? And
is there any hope of ever deciding any controversy by the Scripture, in the way of using such
a licence in order to force it to a compliance with our own schemes? If the apostle indeed
1105
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.