19. Now compare the words
of Origen, which I have translated word for word above, with these
which by him have been turned into Latin, or rather overturned; and you
will see clearly how great a discrepancy between them there is, not
only of word but of meaning. I beg you not to consider my translation
wearisome because it is longer; for the object I had in translating the
whole passage was to exhibit the purpose which he had in suppressing
the earlier part. There exists in Greek a dialogue between Origen and
Candidus the defender of the heresy of Valentinian, in which I confess
it seems to me when I read it that I am looking on at a fight between
two Andabatian gladiators. Candidus maintains that the Son is of the
substance of the Father, falling into the error of asserting a
Probolé or Production.
3125
On the other
side, Origen, like Arius and Eunomius, refuses to admit that He is
produced or born, lest God the Father should thus be divided into
parts; but he says that He was a sublime and most excellent creation
who came into being by the will of the Father like other creatures.
They then come to a second question. Candidus asserts that the devil is
of a nature wholly evil which can never be saved. Against this Origen
rightly asserts that he is not of perishable substance, but that it is
by his own will that he fell and can be saved. This Candidus falsely
turns into a reproach against Origen, as if he had said that the
diabolical nature could be saved. What therefore Candidus had falsely
accused him of, Origen refutes. But we see that in this Dialogue alone
Origen accuses the heretics of having falsified his writings, not in
the other books about which no question was ever raised. Otherwise, if
we are to believe that all which is heretical is not due to Origen but
to the heretics, while almost all his books are full of these errors,
nothing of Origen’s will remain, but everything must be the work
of those of whose names we are ignorant.
It is not enough for him to
calumniate the Greeks and the men of old time, about whom the distance
either of time or space gives him the power to tell any falsehood he
pleases. He comes to the Latins, and first takes the case of Hilary the
Confessor, whose book, he states, was falsified by the heretics after
the Council of Ariminum. A question arose about him on this account in
a council of bishops, and he then ordered the book to be brought from
his own house. The book in its heretical shape was in his desk, though
he did not know it; and when it was produced, the author of the book
was condemned as a heretic and excommunicated, and left the council
room. This is the story, a mere dream of his own, which he tells to his
intimates; and he imagines his authority to be so great that no one
will dare to contradict him when he says such things. I will ask him a
few questions. In what city was the synod held by which Hilary was
excommunicated? What were the names of the Bishops present? Who
subscribed the sentence? Who were content, and who non-content? Who
were the consuls of the year? and who was the emperor
who ordered the assembly
of the council? Were the Bishops present those of Gaul alone, or of
Italy and Spain as well? and for what purpose was the council called
together? You tell us none of these things; yet, in order to defend
Origen, you treat as a criminal and as excommunicated a man of the
highest eloquence, the very clarion of the Latin tongue against the
Arians. But we are in the presence of a confessor, and even his
calumnies must be borne with patience. He next passes to Cyprian the
illustrious martyr, and he tells us that a book by Tertullian entitled
“On the Trinity” is read as one of his works by the
partisans of the Macedonian heresy at Constantinople. In this charge of
his he tells two falsehoods. The book in question is not
Tertullian’s, nor does it pass under the name of Cyprian. It is
by Novatian and is called by his name; the peculiarity of the style
proves the authorship of the work.
3125
A
bringing forth of one thing from another, that is, according to
Valentinian, of Christ as a production from another
Æon.