men, provided that it were consecrated in the words of the gospel, and received without
deceit on their part with some degree of faith; although it would be of no profit to them for
the salvation of their souls if they were without charity, by which they might be grafted into
the Catholic Church. For "though I have faith," says the apostle, "so that I could remove
mountains, but have not charity, I am nothing."1916 Just as already, from the established
decrees of our predecessors, I have no hesitation in saying that all those have baptism who,
though they receive it deceitfully, yet receive it in the Church, or where the Church is thought
to be by those in whose society it is received, of whom it was said, "They went out from
us."1917 But when there was no society of those who so believed, and when the man who
received it did not himself hold such belief, but the whole thing was done as a farce, or a
comedy, or a jest,—if I were asked whether the baptism which was thus conferred should
be approved, I should declare my opinion that we ought to pray for the declaration of God’s
judgment through the medium of some revelation seeking it with united prayer and earnest
groanings of suppliant devotion, humbly deferring all the time to the decision of those who
were to give their judgment after me, in case they should set forth anything as already known
and determined. And, therefore, how much the more must I be considered to have given
my opinion now without prejudice to the utterance of more diligent research or authority
higher than my own!
1916 1 Cor. xiii. 2.
1917 1 John ii. 19.
976
Chapter 53