it is the same thing, to be perfectly innocent, as to be perfectly righteous. It must be the same,
because there can no more be any medium between sin and righteousness, or between being
right and being wrong, in a moral sense, than there can be a medium between straight and
crooked, in a natural sense. Adam was brought into existence capable of acting immediately,
as a moral agent; and therefore he was immediately under a rule of right action. He was
obliged as soon as he existed to act aright. And if he was obliged to act aright as soon as he
existed, he was obliged even then to be inclined to act right. Dr. T. says, (p. 166. S.) “Adam
could not sin without a sinful inclination:” 34 and, just for the same reason, he could not do
aright, without an inclination to right action. And as he was obliged to act rightly from the
first moment of his existence, and did so, till he sinned in reference to the forbidden fruit,
he must have had a disposition of heart to do rightly the first moment of his existence; and
that is the same as to be created, or brought into existence, with an inclination to right action,
or, which is the same thing, a virtuous and holy disposition of heart.
Here it will be in vain to say, “It is true, that it was Adam’s duty to have a good disposition
or inclination, as soon as it was possible to be obtained, in the nature of things; but as it
could not be without time to establish such a habit, which requires antecedent thought, re-
flection, and repeated right action; therefore all that Adam could be obliged to, in the first
place, was to reflect, and consider things in a right manner, and apply himself to right action,
in order to obtain a right disposition:” for this supposes, that even the reflection and consid-
eration to which he was obliged, was right action. Surely he was obliged to it no otherwise
than as a thing that was right: and therefore he must have an inclination to this right action
immediately, before he could perform those first right actions. And as the inclination to
them should be right, the principle, or disposition from which he performed even those
179
actions, must be good: otherwise the actions would not be right in the sight of him who
looks at the heart; nor would they answer his obligations, if he had done them for some
sinister end, and not from a regard to God and his duty. Therefore there must have been a
regard to God and his duty implanted in him at his first existence: otherwise it is certain,
he would have done nothing from a regard to God and his duty; no, not so much as to reflect
and consider, and try to obtain such a disposition. The very supposition of a disposition to
right action being first obtained by repeated right action, is grossly inconsistent with itself:
for it supposes a course of right action, before there is a disposition to perform any right
action.
These are no invented quibbles or sophisms. If God expected from Adam any obedience,
or duty to him at all, when he first made him—whether it was in reflecting, considering, or
34 This is doubtless true: for although there was no natural sinful inclination in Adam, yet an inclination to
that sin of eating the forbidden fruit, was begotten in him by the delusion and error he was led into; and this
inclination to eat the forbidden fruit, must precede his actual eating.
1025
SECTION I. Concerning Adam's original righteousness.