those who were with him, which he contrary to law had pronounced against those who had
been convicted of no fault. But although most justly and in accordance with law he would
have suffered this punishment yet in the hope that by our patience his temerity might be
conquered, we have reserved this to the decision of your holiness. In the meanwhile, we
have deprived them of communion and have taken from them all priestly power, so that
they may not be able to do any harm by their opinions. For those who thus ferociously, and
cruelly, and uncanonically are wont to rush to such frightful and most wicked things, how
was it not necessary that they should be stripped of the powers which [as a matter of fact]
they did not possess,274 of being able to do harm.
With our brethren and fellow-ministers, both Cyril the bishop and Memnon, who had
endured reproval at their hands, we are all in communion, and after the rashness [of their
accusers] we both have and do perform the liturgy in common, all together celebrating the
Synaxis, having made of none effect their play in writing, and having thus shewn that it
lacked all validity and effect. For it was mere reviling and nothing else. For what kind of a
synod could thirty men hold, some of whom were marked with the stamp of heresy, and
some without sees and ejected [from their dioceses]? Or what strength could it have in op-
position to a synod gathered from all the whole world? For there were sitting with us the
most reverend bishops Arcadius and Projectus, and with them the most holy presbyter
Philip, all of whom were sent by your holiness, who gave to us your presence and filled the
place of the Apostolic See (τῆς ἀποστολικῆς καθέδρας). Let then your holiness be angered
at what took place. But if license were granted to such as wished to pour reproval upon the
greater sees, and thus unlawfully and uncanonically to give sentence or rather to utter revil-
ings against those over whom they have no power, against those who for religion have en-
dured such great conflicts, by reason of which now also piety shines forth through the
prayers of your holiness [if, I say, all this should be tolerated], the affairs of the Church
would fall into the greatest confusion. But when those who dare to do such things shall
have been chastised aright, all disturbance will cease, and the reverence due to the canons
will be observed by all.
When there had been read in the holy Synod what had been done touching the deposition
of the most irreligious Pelagians and Cœlestines, of Cœlestius, and Pelagius, and Julian, and
Præsidius, and Florus, and Marcellian, and Orontius, and those inclined to like errors, we
also deemed it right (ἐδικαιώσαμεν ) that the determinations of your holiness concerning
them should stand strong and firm. And we all were of the same mind, holding them de-
posed. And that you may know in full all things that have been done, we have sent you a
copy of the Acts, and of the subscriptions of the Synod. We pray that you, dearly beloved
and most longed for, may be strong and mindful of us in the Lord.275
274 It seems that ἔχοντας and not ἐκόντας, is the true reading.
275 The Latin adds, “Then all the bishops subscribed their names.”
449
The Letter of the Synod to Pope Celestine.