§3. The Persecution of Diocletian.
In this delightful circle and engaged in such congenial tasks, the time must have passed
very happily for Eusebius, until, in 303, the terrible persecution of Diocletian broke upon
the Church almost like a thunderbolt out of a clear sky. The causes of the sudden change of
policy on Diocletian’s part, and the terrible havoc wrought in the Church, it is not my inten-
tion to discuss here (see below, Bk. VIII. chap. 2, note 3 sq.). We are concerned with the
persecution only in so far as it bears upon the present subject. In the first year of the perse-
cution Procopius, the first martyr of Palestine, was put to death at Cæsarea (Eusebius’
Martyrs of Palestine, Cureton’s ed. p. 4), and from that time on that city, which was an im-
portant Christian center, was the scene of a tempest which raged with greater or less violence,
and with occasional cessations, for seven years. Eusebius himself was an eyewitness of many
martyrdoms there, of which he gives us an account in his Martyrs of Palestine. The little
circle which surrounded Pamphilus did not escape. In the third year of the persecution
(Mart. of Pal. p. 12 sq.) a youth named Apphianus, or Epiphanius (the former is given in
the Greek text, the latter in the Syriac), who “resided in the same house with us, confirming
himself in godly doctrine, and being instructed by that perfect martyr, Pamphilus” (as Eu-
sebius says), committed an act of fanatical daring which caused his arrest and martyrdom.
It seems that without the knowledge of his friends, concealing his design even from those
who dwelt in the same house with him, he laid hold of the hand of the governor, Arbanus,
who was upon the point of sacrificing, and endeavored to dissuade him from offering to
“lifeless idols and wicked devils.” His arrest was of course the natural consequence, and he
had the glory of witnessing a good profession and suffering a triumphant death. Although
Eusebius speaks with such admiration of his conduct, it is quite significant of the attitude
of himself, and of most of the circle of which he was one, that Apphianus felt obliged to
conceal his purpose from them. He doubtless feared that they would not permit him to
perform the rash act which he meditated, and we may conclude from that, that the circle in
the main was governed by the precepts of good common sense, and avoided that fanaticism
which so frequently led men, as in the present case it led Apphianus, to expose themselves
needlessly, and even to court martyrdom. It is plain enough from what we know of Eusebius’
general character that he himself was too sensible to act in that way. It is true that he speaks
with admiration of Apphianus’ conduct, and in H. E. VIII. 5, of the equally rash procedure
of a Nicomedian Christian; but that does not imply that he considered their course the wisest
one, and that he would not rather recommend the employment of all proper and honorable
precautions for the preservation of life. Indeed, in H. E. IV. 15, he speaks with evident ap-
proval of the prudent course pursued by Polycarp in preserving his life so long as he could
without violating his Christian profession, and with manifest disapproval of the rash act of
the Phrygian Quintus, who presumptuously courted martyrdom, only to fail when the test
itself came. Pamphilus also possessed too much sound Christian sense to advocate any such
The Persecution of Diocletian.
14
The Persecution of Diocletian.