Almighty or of the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit by the uncreatedness of His nature has
contact with the Son and Father, but is distinguished from them by His own tokens. His
most peculiar characteristic is that He is neither of those things which we contemplate in
the Father and the Son respectively. He is simply, neither as ungenerate119, nor as only-be-
gotten: this it is that constitutes His chief peculiarity. Joined to the Father by His uncreated-
ness, He is disjoined from Him again by not being ‘Father.’ United to the Son by the bond
of uncreatedness, and of deriving His existence from the Supreme, He is parted again from
Him by the characteristic of not being the Only-begotten of the Father, and of having been
manifested by means of the Son Himself. Again, as the creation was effected by the Only-
begotten, in order to secure that the Spirit should not be considered to have something in
common with this creation because of His having been manifested by means of the Son, He
is distinguished from it by His unchangeableness, and independence of all external goodness.
The creation does not possess in its nature this unchangeableness, as the Scripture says in
the description of the fall of the morning star, the mysteries on which subject are revealed
by our Lord to His disciples: “I saw Satan falling like lightning from heaven120.” But the
very attributes which part Him from the creation constitute His relationship to the Father
and the Son. All that is incapable of degenerating has one and the same definition of “un-
changeable.”
Having stated thus much as a preface we are in a position to discuss the rest of our ad-
versaries’ teaching. “It necessarily follows,” he says in his system of the Son and the Spirit,
“that the Beings are relatively greater and less.” Let us then inquire what is the meaning of
this necessity of difference. Does it arise from a comparison formed from measuring them
one with another in some material way, or from viewing them on the spiritual ground of
more or less of moral excellence, or on that of pure being? But in the case of this last it has
been shown by competent thinkers that it is impossible to conceive of any difference
whatever, if one abstracts being from attributes and properties, and looks at it according to
its bare definition. Again, to conceive of this difference as consisting in the case of the Only-
begotten and the Spirit in the intensity or abatement of moral excellence, and in consequence
to hint that their nature admits of change in either direction, so as to be equally capable of
opposites, and to be placed in a borderland between moral beauty and its opposite—that is
gross profanity. A man who thinks this will be proving that their nature is one thing in itself,
and becomes something else by virtue of its participation in this beauty or its opposite: as
happens with iron for example: if it is approached some time to the fire, it assumes the
quality of heat while remaining iron: if it is put in snow or ice, it changes its quality to the
mastering influence, and lets the snow’s coldness pass into its pores.
119 But He is not begotten. Athanasian Creed.
120 Luke x. 18.
116
He has no right to assert a greater and less in the Divine being. A systematic…