Chapter III.—An
Argument of Hermogenes. The Answer: While God is a Title
Eternally Applicable to the Divine Being, Lord and Father are Only
Relative Appellations, Not Eternally Applicable. An Inconsistency in
the Argument of Hermogenes Pointed Out.
He adds also another point: that as God was always
God, there was never a time when God was not also Lord.
But
6151
it was in no way possible for Him to be
regarded as always Lord, in the same manner as He had been always God,
if there had not been always, in the previous eternity,
6152
a something of which He could be regarded as
evermore the Lord. So he concludes
6153
that God
always had Matter co-existent with Himself as the Lord thereof. Now,
this tissue
6154
of his I shall at
once hasten to pull abroad. I have been willing to set it out in
form to this length, for the information of those who are unacquainted
with the subject, that they may know that his other arguments likewise
need only be
6155
understood to be
refuted. We affirm, then, that the name of
God
always existed
with Himself and in Himself—but not eternally so the
Lord
. Because the condition of the one is not the same as
that of the other. God is the designation of the substance itself, that
is, of the Divinity; but Lord is (the name) not of substance, but of
power. I
maintain
that the substance existed always with its own
name, which is God;
the title
Lord was afterwards added, as the
indication indeed
6156
of something
accruing. For from the moment when those things began to exist, over
which the power of a Lord was to act,
God
, by the accession of
that power, both became Lord and received the name thereof. Because God
is in like manner a Father, and He is also a Judge; but He has not
always been Father and Judge, merely on the ground of His having always
been God. For He could not have been the Father previous to the
Son, nor a Judge previous to sin. There was, however, a time when
neither sin existed with Him, nor the Son; the former of which was to
constitute the Lord a Judge, and the latter a Father. In this way He
was not Lord previous to those things of which He was to be the
Lord. But He was only to become Lord at some future time: just as
He became the Father by the Son, and a Judge by sin, so also did He
become Lord by means of those things which He had made, in order that
they might serve Him. Do I seem to you to be weaving
arguments,
6157
Hermogenes? How
neatly does Scripture lend us its aid,
6158
when it applies the two titles to Him with a distinction, and reveals
them each at its proper time! For (the title)
God
, indeed,
which
always belonged
to Him, it names at the very first: “In the beginning God created
the heaven and the earth;”
6159
and as long as
He continued making, one after the other, those things of which He was
to be the Lord, it merely mentions God. “And
God
said,” “and
God
made,” “and
God
saw;”
6160
but nowhere do we
yet find the
Lord
. But when He completed the whole creation, and
especially man himself, who was destined to understand His sovereignty
in a way of special propriety, He then is designated
6161
Lord. Then also
the Scripture
added
the name
Lord
: “And the Lord God,
Deus
Dominus
, took the man, whom He had formed;”
6162
“And the Lord God commanded
Adam.”
6163
Thenceforth He, who
was previously God only, is the
Lord
, from the time of His
having something of which He might be the Lord. For to Himself He
was always God, but to all things was He only then God, when He became
also Lord. Therefore, in
as
far as (Hermogenes) shall suppose
that Matter was eternal, on the ground that the Lord was eternal, in
so
far will it be evident that nothing existed, because it is
plain that the Lord
as such
did not always exist. Now I mean
also, on my own part,
6164
to add a remark for
the sake of ignorant persons, of whom Hermogenes is an extreme
instance,
6165
and actually to
retort against him his own arguments.
6166
For when he denies that Matter was born or made, I find that, even on
these terms, the title
Lord
is unsuitable to God in respect of
Matter, because it must have been free,
6167
when by not having a beginning it had not an author. The fact of its
past existence it owed to no one, so that it could be a subject to no
one. Therefore ever since God exercised His power over it, by
creating (all things) out of Matter, although it had all along
experienced God as its Lord, yet Matter does, after all, demonstrate
that God did not exist in the relation of Lord to it,
6168
although all the while He was really
so.
6169
6151
Porro.
6152
Retro.
6153
Itaque.
6154
Conjecturam.
6155
Tam…quam.
6156
Scilicet.
6157
Argumentari: in the
sense of
argutari
.
6158
Naviter nobis
patrocinatur.
6159
Gen. i. 1
.
6160
Gen. i. 3
, etc.
6161
Cognominatur: as
if by way of
surname
, Deus
Dominus
.
6162
Gen. ii. 15
.
6163
Gen. ii. 16
.
6164
Et ego.
6165
Extrema linea.
Rhenanus sees in this phrase a slur against Hermogenes, who was an
artist. Tertullian, I suppose, meant that Hermogenes was
extremely ignorant.
6166
Experimenta.
6167
Libera: and so
not a possible
subject
for the Lordship of God.
6168
Matter having,
by the hypothesis, been
independent of God
, and so incapable of
giving Him any title to Lordship.
6169
Fuit hoc utique. In
Hermogenes’ own opinion, which is thus shown to have been
contradictory to itself, and so absurd.