killed, on her producing the staff and necklace and ring, saying that the father of the child
was the man who had given her those pledges, Judah acknowledged them, and said, "She
296
hath been more righteous than I"—not praising her, but condemning himself. He blamed
her desire to have children less than his own unlawful passion, which had led him to one
whom he thought to be an harlot. In a similar sense, it is said of some that they justified
Sodom;885 that is, their sin was so great, that Sodom seemed righteous in comparison. And
even allowing that this woman is not spoken of as comparatively less guilty, but is actually
praised by her father-in-law, while, on account of her not observing the established rites of
marriage, she is a criminal in the eye of the eternal law of right, which forbids the transgres-
sion of natural order, both as regards the body, and first and chiefly as regards the mind,
what wonder though one sinner should praise another?
62. The mistake of Faustus and of Manichæism generally, is in supposing that these
objections prove anything against us, as if our reverence for Scripture, and our profession
of regard for its authority, bound us to approve of all the evil actions mentioned in it;
whereas the greater our homage for the Scripture, the more decided must be our condem-
nation of what the truth of Scripture itself teaches us to condemn. In Scripture, all fornication
and adultery are condemned by the divine law; accordingly, when actions of this kind are
narrated, without being expressly condemned, it is intended not that we should praise them,
but that we should pass judgment on them ourselves. Every one execrates the cruelty of
Herod in the Gospel, when, in his uneasiness on hearing of the birth of Christ, he commanded
the slaughter of so many infants.886 But this is merely narrated without being condemned.
Or if Manichæan absurdity is bold enough to deny the truth of this narrative, since they do
not admit the birth of Christ, which was what troubled Herod, let them read the account of
the blind fury of the Jews, which is related without any expression of reproach, although
the feeling of abhorrence is the same in all.
63. But, it is said, Judah, who lay with his daughter-in-law, is reckoned as one of the
twelve patriarchs. And was not Judas, who betrayed the Lord, reckoned among the twelve
apostles? And was not this one of them, who was a devil, sent along with them to preach
the gospel?887 In reply to this, it will be said that after his crime Judas hanged himself, and
was removed from the number of the apostles; while Judah, after his evil conduct, was not
only blessed along with his brethren, but got special honor and approval from his father,
who is so highly spoken of in Scripture. But the main lesson to be learned from this is, that
this prophecy refers not to Judah, but to Christ, who was foretold as to come in the flesh
from his tribe; and the very reason for the mention of this crime of Judah is to be found in
885 Ezek. xvi. 52.
886 Matt. ii. 16.
887 John vi. 70, 71.
504
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…