IV. The Chief Cause of Trouble a Logomachy.
Now from all this one thing is abundantly clear, that the great point set forth with such
learning and perspicuity by the Seventh Synod, to wit, the distinction between λατρεία and
προσκύνεσις was wholly lost upon these Frankish writers; and that their translation of both
words by “adoro” gave rise to nine-tenths of the trouble that followed. The student of eccle-
siastical history will remember how a similar logomachy followed nearly every one of the
Ecumenical Synods, and will not therefore be astonished to find it likewise here. The
“homousion,” the “theotocos,” the “two natures,” “the two wills,” each one gave rise to
heated discussion in different sections of the Church, even after it had been accepted and
approved by a Synod which no one now for an instant disputes to have been ecumenical.
Moreover, that after this serious error and bungling on the part of the Caroline divines
and of the French and Allemanic Churches, the Pope did not proceed to enforce the accept-
ance of the council will not cause astonishment to any who are familiar with what St. Ath-
anasius said with regard to the Semi-Arians, who even after I. Nice refused to use the word
“homousios;” or with the extreme gentleness and moderation of St. Cyril of Alexandria in
his treatment of John of Antioch.
Perhaps before leaving the subject I should give here the chief strictures which Hefele
makes upon these books (§ 400).
(1) The Caroline Books condemn passages which they quote (without saying so) from
Pope Hadrian’s own letter to the Empress.
583
(2) They blame St. Basil for teaching that the reverence done to the image passes on to
the prototype.
(3) They treat St. Gregory Nyssen with contempt, and refuse to listen to him (Lib. II.,
c. xvij.).
(4) They are full of most careless and inexcusable blunders.
(a) They attribute to the Emperors a phrase which belongs to the Synod (I. j.).
(b) They confound Leontius with John (I. xxj.).
(c) They confound Tarasius with Theodore of Jerusalem (III. v.).
(d) They impute to the Council the opinions of the Iconoclastic Conciliabulum (IV.,
xiv. and xx. ).
(e) They attribute to Epiphanius the deacon the propositions of others when he merely
read (IV., xv.)
It had usually been supposed that these Four Books were the “quædam capitula” which
Charlemagne had sent by Angelbert to Pope Hadrian “to be corrected by his judgment (ut
illius judicio corrigerentur). Considering the nature of the contents of the Caroline Books
as we now have them, such would seem à priori highly improbable, but this matter has been
practically settled, as we have already pointed out, by Bishop Hefele, who has shown from
Pope Hadrian’s answer “correcting” those “capitula,” that they must have been entirely
The Chief Cause of Trouble a Logomachy.
1073
The Chief Cause of Trouble a Logomachy.