VIII.
On Fasting.
1001
In Opposition to the
Psychics.
[Translated by the Rev. S.
Thelwall.]
————————————
Chapter I.—Connection of Gluttony
and Lust. Grounds of Psychical Objections Against the
Montanists.
I should wonder at the Psychics, if they were
enthralled to voluptuousness alone, which leads them to repeated
marriages, if they were not likewise bursting with gluttony, which
leads them to hate fasts. Lust without voracity would certainly
be considered a monstrous phenomenon; since these two are so united and
concrete, that, had there been any possibility of disjoining them, the
pudenda would not have been affixed to the belly itself rather than
elsewhere. Look at the body: the region (of these members)
is one and the same. In short, the order of the vices is
proportionate to the arrangement of the members. First, the
belly; and then immediately the materials of all other species of
lasciviousness are laid subordinately to daintiness: through love
of eating, love of impurity finds passage. I recognise,
therefore,
animal
1002
faith by its care
of the flesh (of which it wholly consists)—as prone to manifold
feeding as to manifold marrying—so that it deservedly accuses the
spiritual
discipline, which according to its ability opposes it,
in this species of continence as well; imposing, as it does, reins upon
the appetite, through taking, sometimes no meals, or late meals, or dry
meals, just as upon lust, through allowing but one marriage.
It is really irksome to engage with such:
one is really ashamed to wrangle about subjects the very defence of
which is offensive to modesty. For how am I to protect chastity
and sobriety without taxing their adversaries? What those
adversaries are I will once for all mention: they are the
exterior and interior
botuli
of the Psychics. It is these
which raise controversy with the Paraclete; it is on this account that
the New Prophecies are rejected: not that Montanus and Priscilla
and Maximilla preach another God, nor that they disjoin Jesus Christ
(from God), nor that they overturn any particular rule of faith or
hope, but that they plainly teach more frequent fasting than
marrying. Concerning the limit of marrying, we have already
published a defence of monogamy.
1003
Now our
battle is the battle of the secondary (or rather the primary)
continence, in regard of the chastisement of diet. They charge us
with keeping fasts of our own; with prolonging our Stations generally
into the evening; with observing xerophagies likewise, keeping our food
unmoistened by any flesh, and by any juiciness, and by any kind of
specially succulent fruit; and with not eating or drinking anything
with a winey flavour; also with abstinence from the bath, congruent
with our dry diet. They are therefore constantly reproaching us
with
novelty
; concerning the unlawfulness of
which they lay down a prescriptive rule, that either it must be
adjudged
heresy
, if (the point in dispute) is a human
presumption; or else pronounced
pseudo-prophecy
, if it is a
spiritual declaration; provided that, either way, we who reclaim hear
(sentence of) anathema.
1001
[Written, say,
circa
a.d.
208.]
1002
i.e., Psychic.
1003
[Which is a note of
time, not unimportant.]