Against the Greeks,1317 On Truth, a first and second book,1318 and those which he sub-
sequently wrote against the heresy of the Phrygians,1319 which not long afterwards came
controversy had assumed the bitter tone which it took when Victor became bishop of Rome; i.e. it was written,
probably, in the seventies (see, also, Bk. V. chap. 23, note 1). Photius (Cod. 14) mentions three apologetic works
by Apolinarius known to him: πρὸς ῞Ελληνας, περὶ εὐσεβείας, and περὶ ἀληθείας. The first and last are mentioned
by Eusebius, but the second is a work otherwise unknown to us. There is no reason to suppose, as some have
done, that the περὶ εὐσεβείας does not designate a separate work (cf. e.g., Donaldson, Hist. of Christ. Lit. and
Doctrine, III. 243), for Eusebius expressly says that he mentions only a part of Apolinarius’ writings. Theodoret
(Hær. Fab. I. 21) mentions Apolinarius, together with Musanus and Clement, as having written against the
Severians (see chap. 29, below). But, as Harnack justly remarks (p. 235), the most we can conclude from this is
that Apolinarius in his Anti-Montanistic work, had mentioned the Severians with disapproval. Five mss. of
Eusebius, and the Church Hist. of Nicephorus, mention just after the work On Truth, a work Against the Jews,
in two books (καὶ πρὸς ᾽Ιουδαίους πρῶτον καὶ δεύτερον). The words are found in many of our editions, but are
omitted by the majority of the best Greek mss., and also by Rufinus and Jerome, and therefore must be regarded
as an interpolation; and so they are viewed by Heinichen, Laemmer, Otto, Harnack, and others. Harnack suggests
that they were inserted under the influence of Bk. V. chap. 17, §5, where the works of Miltiades are given. We
thus have knowledge of six, and only six, distinct works of Apolinarius, though, since no writer has pretended
to give a complete list, it is quite probable that he wrote many others.
1316 On the approximate date of this Apology, see the previous note. No fragments of the work are now extant,
unless the account of the thundering legion mentioned by Eusebius in Bk. V. chap. 5 belong to it (see the previous
note). Jerome speaks of the work as an insigne volumen pro fide Christianorum, and in chap. 26, §1, Eusebius
speaks of it as λόγος ὑπερ τῆς πίστεως. This has given rise to the idea that the περὶ εὐσεβείας mentioned by
Photius may be identical with this Apology (see the previous note). But such an important work would certainly
not have been mentioned with such an ambiguous title by Photius. We may conclude, in fact, that Photius had
not seen the Apology. The Chron. Paschale mentions the Apology in connection with those of “Melito and many
others,” as addressed to the Emperor Marcus Aurelius.
1317 No fragments of this work are known to us. Nicephorus (H. E. IV. 11) says that it was in the form of a
dialogue, and it is quite possible that he speaks in this case from personal knowledge, for the work was still extant
in the time of Photius, who mentions it in Cod. 14 (see Harnack, p. 236).
1318 No fragments of this work are extant, and its nature is unknown to us. It may have resembled the work
of Melito upon the same subject (see the previous chapter). The work is mentioned by Photius as one of three,
which he had himself seen.
1319 Eusebius states here that the works against the Montanists were written later than the other works
mentioned. Where he got this information we do not know; it is possible, as Harnack suggests, that he saw from
the writings themselves that Marcus Aurelius was no longer alive when they were composed. Eusebius speaks
very highly of these Anti-Montanistic works, and in Bk. V. chap. 16, §1, he speaks of Apolinarius as a “powerful
weapon and antagonist” of the Montanists. And yet it is a remarkable fact that he does not take his account of
the Montanists from the works of Apolinarius, but from later writings. This fact can be explained only as Harnack
478
Apolinarius, Bishop of the Church of Hierapolis.