he concedes the name of Son, he denies him to be so in reality. For he that is made of nothing
cannot truly be the Son of God, any more than the other things which have been made: but
the true Son of God, forasmuch as he is begotten of the Father, is properly denominated the
only-begotten and beloved of the Father. For this reason also, he himself is God: for what can
the offspring of God be but the perfect resemblance of him who begat him? A sovereign, indeed,
builds a city, but does not beget it; and is said to beget a son, not to build one. An artificer
may be called the framer, but not the father of his work; while he could by no means be styled
the framer of him whom he had begotten. So also the God of the Universe is the father of the
Son; but would be fitly termed the Framer and Maker of the world. And although it is once
said in Scripture, The Lord created me the beginning of his ways on account of his works,
yet it becomes us to consider the import of this phrase, which I shall hereafter explain; and
not, as Marcellus has done, from a single passage to subvert one of the most important doctrines
of the Church.’
“These and many other such expressions are found in the first book of Eusebius
Pamphilus against Marcellus; and in his third book, declaring in what sense the term creature
is to be taken, he says: ‘Accordingly these things being established, it follows that in the same
sense as that which preceded, these words also are to be understood, The Lord created me in
the beginning of his ways on account of his works. For although he says that he was created,
it is not as if he should say that he had arrived at existence from what was not, nor that he
himself also was made of nothing like the rest of the creatures, which some have erroneously
supposed: but as subsisting, living, pre-existing, and being before the constitution of the whole
world; and having been appointed to rule the universe by his Lord and Father: the word created
being here used instead of ordained or constituted. Certainly the apostle expressly called the
rulers and governors among men creature, when he said, Submit yourselves to every human
63
creature for the Lord’s sake; whether to the king as supreme, or to governors as those sent
by him. The prophet also does not use the word žκτισενcreated in the sense of made of that
which had no previous existence, when he says, Prepare, Israel, to invoke thy God. For behold
he who confirms the thunder, creates the Spirit, and announces his Christ unto men. For
God did not then create the Spirit when he declared his Christ to all men, since There is
nothing new under the sun; but the Spirit was, and subsisted before: but he was sent at what
time the apostles were gathered together, when like thunder, There came a sound from
heaven as of a rushing mighty wind: and they were filled with the Holy Spirit. And thus they
declared unto all men the Christ of God in accordance with that prophecy which says, Behold
he who confirms the thunder, creates the spirit, and announces his Christ unto men: the
word creates being used instead of sends down, or appoints; and thunder in a similar way
implying the preaching of the Gospel. Again he that says, Create in me a clean heart, O God,
said not this as if he had no heart; but prayed that his mind might be purified. Thus also it is
said, That he might create the two into one new man, instead of unite. Consider also
94
Testimonies of the Ancients in Favor of Eusebius.