AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK III. 473
been baptized to have been carried off by
death either immediately, or on the very day
of his baptism, and I will generously con-
cede that he neither thought nor said any-
thing whereby, through error and ignorance,
he fell into sin. Does it follow that he will,
therefore, be without sin, because he appears
not to have overcome, but to have avoided
sin ? Is not the true reason rather that by
the mercy of God he was released from the
prison of sins and departed to the Lord ?
We also say this, that God can do what He
wills ; and that man of himself and by his
own will cannot, as you maintain, be without
sin. If he can, it is idle for you now to add
the word grace, for, with sucht a power, he
has no need of it. If, however, he cannot
avoid sin without the grace of God, it is folly
for you to attribute to him an ability which
he does not possess. For whatever depends
upon another's will, is not in the power of him whose ability you assert, but of him
whose aid is clearly indispensable.
3. C. What do you mean by this perversity,
or, rather, senseless contention ? Will you
not grant me even so much — that when a
man leaves the 'waters of b:u}tism he U fat* from sin ?
A. Either I fail to express my meaning
clearly, or you are slow of aj, prehension. C. How so ?
A. Remember both what \ you maintained
and also what I say. You argued that a man
can be free from sin if he chooses. I reply
that it is an impossibility; not! that we are to
think that a man is not free frqm sin immedi- ately after baptism, but than that time of
sinlessness is by no means to! be referred to
human ability, but to the gracq: of God. Do
not, therefore, claim the poweir for man, and
I will admit the fact. For ho w can a man
:>e able who is not able of himself ? Or
what is that sinlessness which is conditioned
ay the immediate death of the 'body ? Should
;he man's life be prolonged, he will certainly DC liable to sins and to ignorance.
C. Your logic stops my mouth. You do
not sp-iak with Christian simplicity, but en-
:angle me in some fine distinctions between
Deing and ability to be.
A. Is it I who play these tricks witty words ?
The article came from your own workshop.
For you say, not that a man is free fjrom sin, 3Ut that he is able to be ; I, on thle other
land, will grant what you deny, that! a man
s free from sin by the grace of God, land yet will maintain that he is not able of hiriiself.
C. It is useless to give commandmlents if
we cannot keep them. \ A. No one doubts that God comnnanded
:hings possible. But because men c?o not
what they might, therefore the whole world is
subject to the judgment of God, and needs
His mercy. On the other hand, if you can
produce a man who has fulfilled the whole
law, you will certainly be able to show that
there is a man who does not need the mercy
of God. For everything which can happen
must either take place in the past, the present,
or the future. As to your assertion that a man
can be without sin if he chooses, show that
it has happened in the past, or at all events
that it does happen at the present day ; the
future will reveal itself. If, however, you can
point to no one who either is, or has been,
altogether free from sin, it remains for us to
confine our discussion to the future. Mean-
while, you are vanquished and a captive as
regards t\vo out of three periods of time, the
past and the present. If anyone hereafter
shall be greater than patriarchs, prophets,
apostles, inasmuch as he is without sin, then
you may perhaps be able to convince future
generations as to their time.
4. C. Talk as you like, argue as you please,
you will never wrest from me free will, which
-God bestowed once for all, nor will you be
able to deprive me of what God has given,
the ability if I have the will.
A. By way of example let us take one
ptoof : '" I have found David, the Son of Jesse, a wan after Mine own heart, who shall do all
My will." There is no doubt that David was a ho y man, and yet he who was chosen that
he night do all God's will is blamed for certain actions. Of course it was possible
for him who was chosen for the purpose to
do all God's will. Nor is God to blame Who beforehand spoke of his doing all His will as
commanded, but blame does attach to him
who did not what was foretold. For God did
not say that He had found a man who would
unfailingly do His bidding and fulfil His will,
but only one who would do all His will.
And we, too, say that a man can avoid sinning,
if he chooses, according to his local and tem-
poral circumstances and physical weakness, so
long as his mind is set upon righteousness and
the string is well stretched upon the lyre. But
if a man grow a little remiss it is with him as with
the boatman pulling against the stream, who
finds that, if he slackens but for a moment,
the craft glides back and he is carried by the
flowing waters whither he would not. Such
is the state of man ; if we are a little careless
we learn our weakness, and find that our
power is limited. Do you suppose that the
Apostle Paul, when he wrote8 " the coat (or cloak) that I left at Troas with Carpus, bring
when thou comest, and the books, especially
» Acts xiii. 32 : Ps. Ixxxviii. 21.
8 2 Tim. iv. 13.