LETTERS XIV.-XV.
sequently I here follow the Egyptian confes-
sors ' who share your faith, and anchor my frail craft under the shadow of their great
argosies. I know nothing of Vitalis; I re-
ject Meletius; I have nothing to do with
Paulinos." He that gathers not with you
scatters;3 he that is not of Christ is of Antichrist.
3. Just now, I am sorry to say, those
Arians, the Campenses,4 are trying to extort from me, a Roman Christian, their unheard-
of formula of three hypostases.6 And this,
too, after the definition of Nicgea6 and the
decree of Alexandria,7 in which the West has joined. Where, I should like to know,
are the apostles of these doctrines? Where
is their Paul, their new doctor of the Gen-
tiles? I ask them what three hypostases are
supposed to mean. They reply three per-
sons subsisting. I rejoin that this is my
belief. They are not satisfied with the mean-
ing, they demand the term. Surely some
secret venom lurks in the words. " If any
man refuse," I cry, "to acknowledge three hypostases in the sense of three things hy-
postatized, that is three persons subsisting,
let him be anathema." Yet, because I do not learn their words, I am counted a heretic.
" But, if any one, understanding by hypostasis
essence,8 deny that in the three persons there
is one hypostasis, he has no part in Christ." Because this is my confession I, like you, am
branded with the stigma of Sabellianism.9 4. If you think fit enact a decree; and
then I shall not hesitate to speak of three
hypostases. Order a new creed to supersede
the Nicene; and then, whether we are Arians
or orthodox, one confession will do for us
all. In the whole range of secular learning
hypostasis never means anything but essence.
And can any one, I ask, be so profane as to
l- Certain bishops banished from their sees by Valens. See Let- ter III. §2.
a The three rival claimants of the see of Antioch. See note on
Letter XVI. §2. 3 Matt. xii. 30.
4 I.e. the field party. The Meletians were so called because,
denied access to the churches of the city, they had to worship in
the open air outside the walls.
6 vTrooTCKTis =substantia. It is the word used in Heb. i. 3,
"The express image of his person [R. V. substance]." Except at Alexandria it was usual to speak of one hypostasis as of one
ousia in the Divine Nature. But at Alexandria from Origen
downwards three hypostases had been ascribed to the Deity. Two
explanations are given of the latter formula : (i) That at Alexan-
dria 07ro'crTa<rcs was taken in the sense of irpocrtaTrov, so that
by " three hypostases " was meant only " three persons."
(2) That " three hypostases" was an inexact expression standing
for "three hypostatic persons" or "a threefold hypostasis." This latter seems to be the true account of the matter. See an
interesting note in Newman, Arians of the Fourth Century, Ap- pendix IV.
6 In the Nicene Creed the Son is declared to be " of one sub-
stance [ovo-ta] with the Father."
* This decree allowed the formula of " three hypostases " to be susceptible of an orthodox interpretation. It did not, however,
encourage its use. 8 o-utria.
8 Cauterio unionis inurimur. Sabellius recognized three "as-
pects" in the Godhead but denied "three persons," at least in the Catholic sense.
speak of three essences or substances in the
Godhead ? There is one nature of God and
one only; and this, and this alone, truly is.
For absolute being is derived from no other
source but is all its own. All things besides,
that is all things created, although they ap-
pear to be, are not. For there was a time
when they were not, and that which once
was not may again cease to be. God alone
who is eternal, that is to say, who has no
beginning, really deserves to be called an
essence. Therefore also He says to Moses
from the bush, " I am that I am," and Moses
says of Him, "I am hath sent me."1 As the angels, the sky, the earth, the seas, all
existed at the time, it must have been as the
absolute being that God claimed for himself
that name of essence, which apparently was
common to all. But because His nature
alone is perfect, and because in the three
persons there subsists but one Godhead,
which truly is and is one nature; whosoever
in the name of religion declares that there
are in the Godhead three elements, three
hypostases, that is, or essences, is striving
really to predicate three natures of God.
And if this is true, why are we severed by
walls from Arius, when in dishonesty we are one with him? Let Ursicinus be made the
colleague of your blessedness; let Auxentius
be associated with Ambrose.2 But may the faith of Rome never come to such a pass!
May the devout hearts of your people never
be infected with such unholy doctrines!
Let us be satisfied to speak of one substance
and of three subsisting persons — perfect,
equal, coeternal. Let us keep to one hypo-
stasis, if such be your pleasure, and say
nothing of three. It is a bad sign when
those who mean the same thing use different
words. Let us be satisfied with the form of
creed which we have hitherto used. Or, if
you think it right that I should speak of
three hypostases, explaining what I mean by
them, I am ready to submit. But, believe
me, there is poison hidden under their
honey; the angel of Satan has transformed
himself into an angel of light.8 They give
a plausible explanation of the term hyposta-
sis; yet when I profess to hold it in the
same sense they count me a heretic. Why
are they so tenacious of a word? Why do
they shelter themselves under ambiguous
language? If their belief corresponds to
their explanation of it, I do not condemn
them for keeping it. On the other hand, if
1 Ex. iii. 14.
2 Ursicinus, at this time anti-pope ; Auxentius, Arian bishop of
Milan. 3 2 Cor. xi. 14.