244
General Introduction.
I should consider it a piece of impertinence were I to attempt to add anything to what
has been already said with regard to the Council of Chalcedon. The literature upon the
subject is so great and so bitterly polemical that I think I shall do well in laying before my
readers the Acts, practically complete on all disputed points, and to leave them to draw their
own conclusions. I shall not, however, be liable to the charge of unfairness if I quote at some
length the deductions of the Eagle of Meaux, the famous Bossuet, from these acts; and since
his somewhat isolated position as a Gallican gives him a singular fitness to serve in this and
similar questions as a mediator between Catholics and Protestants, his remarks upon this
Council will, I think, be read with great interest and respect.
(Bossuet. Defensio Dec. Cleri Gallic. Lib. VII., cap. xvij. [Translation by Allies].)
An important point treated in the Council of Chalcedon, that is, the establishing of the
faith, and the approval of Leo’s letter, is as follows: Already almost the whole West, and
most of the Easterns, with Anatolius himself, Bishop of Constantinople, had gone so far as
to confirm by subscription that letter, before the council took place; and in the council itself
the Fathers had often cried out, “We believe, as Leo: Peter hath spoken by Leo: we have all
subscribed the letter: what has been set forth is sufficient for the Faith: no other exposition
may be made.” Things went so far, that they would hardly permit a definition to be made
by the council. But neither subscriptions privately made before the council, nor these
vehement cries of the Fathers in the council, were thought sufficient to tranquillize minds
in so unsettled a state of the Church, for fear that a matter so important might seem determ-
ined rather by outcries than by fair and legitimate discussion. And the clergy of Con-
stantinople exclaimed, “It is a few who cry out, not the whole council which speaks.” So it
was determined, that the letter of Leo should be lawfully examined by the council, and a
definition of faith be written by the synod itself. So the acts of foregoing councils being
previously read, the magistrates proposed concerning Leo’s letter, “As we see the divine
Gospels laid before your Piety, let each one of the assembled bishops declare, whether the
exposition of the 318 Fathers at Nice, and of the 150 who afterwards assembled in the im-
perial city, agrees with the letter of the most reverend Archbishop Leo.”
After the question as to examining the letter of Leo was put in this form, it will be worth
while to weigh the sentences and, as they are called, the votes of the Fathers, in order to
understand from the beginning why they approved of the letter; why they afterwards defended
it with so much zeal; why, finally, it was ratified after so exact an examination of the council.
Anatolius first gives his sentence. “The letter of the most holy and religious Archbishop
Leo agrees with the creed of our 318 Fathers at Nice, and of the 150 who afterwards assembled
at Constantinople, and confirmed the same faith, and with the proceedings at Ephesus under
the most blessed Cyril, who is among the saints, by the Ecumenical and holy Council, when
it condemned Nestorius. I therefore agree to it, and willingly subscribe to it.” These are
General Introduction.
456
General Introduction.