if they had prohibited any additional statement not being a contradiction of its truth, then
(as Cardinal Julian acutely argued in the Council of Florence), any one would fall under its
anathema, who held (as all must) anything not expressed in set terms in the Nicene Creed;
such as that God is eternal or incomprehensible.
It may not be amiss to remember that the argument that πίστιν ἑτέραν forbids any ad-
dition to the Creed or any further definition of the faith, was that urged by the heretics at
the Latrocinium, and the orthodox were there condemned on the ground that they had added
to the faith and laid themselves under the Anathema of Ephesus. How far this interpretation
was from being that of the Council of Chalcedon is evinced by the fact that it immediately
declared that St. Flavian and Bishop Eusebius had been unjustly deposed, and proceeded
to depose those who had deposed them. After stating these facts Dr. Pusey remarks, “Prot-
estants may reject consistently the authority of all councils; but on what grounds any who
accept their authority can insist on their own private interpretation of a canon of one
council against the authority of another General Council which rejected that interpretation,
I see not.”269
234
4. The Fifth Ecumenical Council, the Second of Constantinople, received both the
creeds of Nice and that of Constantinople, as well of the definitions of Ephesus and
Chalcedon, and yet at the end of the fourth Session we find in the acts that the fathers cried
out, with respect to the creed of Theodore of Mopsuestia: “This creed Satan composed.
Anathema to him that composed this creed! The First Council of Ephesus anathematized
this creed and its author. We know only one symbol of faith, that which the holy fathers of
Nice set forth and handed down. This also the three holy Synods handed down. Into this
we were baptized, and into this we baptize, etc., etc.”270 From this it is clearer than day that
these fathers looked upon the creed of Constantinople, with its additions, to be yet the same
creed as that of Nice.
(Le Quien, Diss. Dam., n. 37.)
In the Sixth Council also, no one objecting, Peter of Nicomedia, Theodore, and other
bishops, clerks, and monks, who had embraced the Monothelite heresy, openly recited a
Creed longer and fuller than the Nicene.
In the Seventh Synod also, another was read written by Theodore of Jerusalem: and
again, Basil of Ancyra, and the other Bishops, who had embraced the errors of the Iconoclasts,
again offered another, although the Canon of Ephesus pronounced, that “it should not be
lawful to offer to heretics, who wished to be converted to the Church, any other creed than
the Nicene.” In this same Synod, was read another profession of faith, which Tarasius had
sent to the Patriarchs of the Eastern sees. It contains the Nicene, or Constantinopolitan
269 E. B. Pusey, Lib. cit., p. 86.
270 Labbe and Cossart, Tom. v., col. 455.
440
Excursus on the Words .