New Testament, are prohibited by an even more emphatic precept: instead of, “Thou shalt
not commit adultery,” “Whoever shall have seen with a view to concupiscence, hath already
committed adultery in his own heart;” 762 and instead of, “Thou shalt not kill,” “Whoever
shall have said to his brother, Racha, shall be in danger of hell.” 763 Ask (yourself) whether
the law of not committing adultery be still in force, to which has been added that of not in-
dulging concupiscence. Besides, if any precedents (taken from the Old Dispensation) shall
favour you in (the secrecy of) your bosom, they shall not be set in opposition to this discipline
which we are maintaining. For it is in vain that an additional law has been reared, con-
demning the origin even of sins—that is, concupiscences and wills—no less than the actual
deeds; if the fact that pardon was of old in some cases conceded to adultery is to be a reason
why it shall be conceded at the present day. “What will be the reward attaching to the re-
strictions imposed upon the more fully developed discipline of the present day, except that
the elder (discipline) may be made the agent for granting indulgence to your prostitution?”
In that case, you will grant pardon to the idolater too, and to every apostate, because we
find the People itself, so often guilty of these crimes, as often reinstated in their former
privileges. You will maintain communion, too, with the murderer: because Ahab, by de-
precation, washed away (the guilt of) Naboth’s blood; 764 and David, by confession, purged
Uriah’s slaughter, together with its cause—adultery. 765 That done, you will condone incests,
too, for Lot’s sake; 766 and fornications combined with incest, for Judah’s sake; 767 and base
marriages with prostitutes, for Hosea’s sake; 768 and not only the frequent repetition of
marriage, but its simultaneous plurality, for our fathers’ sakes: for, of course, it is meet that
there should also be a perfect equality of grace in regard of all deeds to which indulgence
was in days bygone granted, if on the ground of some pristine precedent pardon is claimed
for adultery. We, too, indeed have precedents in the self-same antiquity on the side of our
opinion,—(precedents) of judgment not merely not waived, but even summarily executed
upon fornication. And of course it is a sufficient one, that so vast a number—(the number)
of 24,000—of the People, when they committed fornication with the daughters of Madian,
fell in one plague. 769 But, with an eye to the glory of Christ, I prefer to derive (my) discipline
from Christ. Grant that the pristine days may have had—if the Psychics please—even a
762 Matt. v. 27, 28.
763 Matt. v. 21, 22.
764 See 1 Kings xxi. (in LXX. 3 Kings xx).
765 See 2 Sam. xi.; xii. 1–13.
766 See Gen. xix. 30–38.
767 See Gen. xxxviii.
768 See Hos. i. 2, 3; iii. 1–3.
769 See Num. xxv. 1–9; 1 Cor. x. 8.
180
Examples of Such Offences Under the Old Dispensation No Pattern for the…