Book XXXII.
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or reject the New
Testament as a whole, while the Catholics accept or reject the various parts of the Old
Testament at pleasure. Augustin denies that the Catholics treat the Old Testament arbitrarily,
and explains their attitude towards it.
1. Faustus said: You say, that if we believe the Gospel, we must believe everything that
is written in it. Why, then, since you believe the Old Testament, do you not believe all that
is found in any part of it? Instead of that, you cull out only the prophecies telling of a future
King of the Jews, for you suppose this to be Jesus, along with a few precepts of common
morality, such as, Thou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not commit adultery; and all the rest you
pass over, thinking of the other things as Paul thought of the things which he held to be
dung.1029 Why, then, should it seem strange or singular in me that I select from the New
Testament whatever is purest, and helpful for my salvation, while I set aside the interpolations
of your predecessors, which impair its dignity and grace?
333
2. If there are parts of the Testament of the Father which we are not bound to observe
(for you attribute the Jewish law to the Father, and it is well known that many things in it
shock you, and make you ashamed, so that in heart you no longer regard it as free from
corruption, though, as you believe, the Father Himself partly wrote it for you with His own
finger while part was written by Moses, who was faithful and trustworthy), the Testament
of the Son must be equally liable to corruption, and may equally well contain objectionable
things; especially as it is allowed not to have been written by the Son Himself, nor by His
apostles, but long after, by some unknown men, who, lest they should be suspected of writing
of things they knew nothing of, gave to their books the names of the apostles, or of those
who were thought to have followed the apostles, declaring the contents to be according to
these originals. In this, I think, they do grievous wrong to the disciples of Christ, by quoting
their authority for the discordant and contradictory statements in these writings, saying
that it was according to them that they wrote the Gospels, which are so full of errors and
discrepancies, both in facts and in opinions, that they can be harmonized neither with
themselves nor with one another. This is nothing else than to slander good men, and to
bring the charge of dissension on the brotherhood of the disciples. In reading the Gospels,
the clear intention of our heart perceives the errors, and, to avoid all injustice, we accept
whatever is useful, in the way of building up our faith, and promoting the glory of the Lord
Christ, and of the Almighty God, His Father, while we reject the rest as unbecoming the
majesty of God and Christ, and inconsistent with our belief.
3. To return to what I said of your not accepting everything in the Old Testament. You
do not admit carnal circumcision, though that is what is written;1030 nor resting from all
1029 Phil. iii. 8.
1030 Gen. xvii. 9-14.
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or reject the New Testament as a whole, while the Catholics accept or reject the various parts of the Old Testament at pleasure. Augustin denies that the Catholics treat the Old Testament arbitrarily, and explains their attitude towards it.
568
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or…