11. And in this way is brought about the genesis of evil, arising through the withdrawal
of that which is beautiful and good. Now all is beautiful and good that is closely related to
the First Good; but that which departs from its relation and likeness to this is certainly
devoid of beauty and goodness. If, then, according to the statement we have been considering,
that which is truly good is one, and the mind itself also has its power of being beautiful and
good, in so far as it is in the image of the good and beautiful, and the nature, which is sus-
tained by the mind, has the like power, in so far as it is an image of the image, it is hereby
shown that our material part holds together, and is upheld when it is controlled by nature;
and on the other hand is dissolved and disorganized when it is separated from that which
upholds and sustains it, and is dissevered from its conjunction with beauty and goodness.
12. Now such a condition as this does not arise except when there takes place an over-
turning of nature to the opposite state, in which the desire has no inclination for beauty and
goodness, but for that which is in need of the adorning element; for it must needs be that
that which is made like to matter, destitute as matter is of form of its own, should be assim-
ilated to it in respect of the absence alike of form and of beauty.
13. We have, however, discussed these points in passing, as following on our argument,
since they were introduced by our speculation on the point before us; for the subject of en-
quiry was, whether the intellectual faculty has its seat in any of the parts of us, or extends
equally over them all; for as for those who shut up the mind locally in parts of the body, and
who advance for the establishment of this opinion of theirs the fact that the reason has not
free course in the case of those whose cerebral membranes are in an unnatural condition,
our argument showed that in respect of every part of the compound nature of man, whereby
every man has some natural operation, the power of the soul remains equally ineffective if
the part does not continue in its natural condition. And thus there came into our argument,
following out this line of thought, the view we have just stated, by which we learn that in
the compound nature of man the mind is governed by God, and that by it is governed our
material life, provided the latter remains in its natural state, but if it is perverted from nature
it is alienated also from that operation which is carried on by the mind.
14. Let us return however once more to the point from which we started—that in those
who are not perverted from their natural condition by some affection, the mind exercises
its own power, and is established firmly in those who are in sound health, but on the contrary
is powerless in those who do not admit its operation; for we may confirm our opinion on
these matters by yet other arguments: and if it is not tedious for those to hear who are already
wearied with our discourse, we shall discuss these matters also, so far as we are able, in a
few words.
739
An examination of the question where the ruling principle is to be considered…