Chapter 23.—31. Cyprian writes also to Pompeius1542 about this selfsame matter, and
475
clearly shows in that letter that Stephen, who, as we learn, was then bishop of the Roman
Church, not only did not agree with him upon the points before us, but even wrote and
taught the opposite views. But Stephen certainly did not "communicate with heretics,"1543
merely because he did not dare to impugn the baptism of Christ, which he knew remained
perfect in the midst of their perversity. For if none have baptism who entertain false views
about God, it has been proved sufficiently, in my opinion, that this may happen even within
the Church. "The apostles," indeed, "gave no injunctions on the point;"1544 but the custom,
which is opposed to Cyprian, may be supposed to have had its origin in apostolic tradition,
just as there are many things which are observed by the whole Church, and therefore are
fairly held to have been enjoined by the apostles, which yet are not mentioned in their
writings.
32. But it will be urged that it is written of heretics that "they are condemned of them-
selves."1545 What then? are they not also condemned of themselves to whom it was said,
"For wherein thou judgest another, thou condemnest thyself?"1546 But to these the apostle
says, "Thou that preachest a man should not steal, dost thou steal?"1547 and so forth. And
such truly were they who, being bishops and established in Catholic unity with Cyprian
himself, used to plunder estates by treacherous frauds, preaching all the time to the people
the words of the apostle, who says, "Nor shall extortioners inherit the kingdom of God."1548
33. Wherefore I will do no more than run shortly through the other sentiments founded
on the same rules, which are in the aforesaid letter written to Pompeius. By what authority
of holy Scripture is it shown that "it is against the commandment of God that persons
coming from the society of heretics, if they have already there received the baptism of Christ,
are not baptized again?"1549 But it is clearly shown that many pretended Christians, though
they are not joined in the same bond of charity with the saints, without which anything holy
that they may have been able to possess is of no profit to them, yet have baptism in common
with the saints, as has been already sufficiently proved with the greatest fullness. He says
"that the Church, and the Spirit, and baptism, are mutually incapable of separation from
each other, and therefore" he wishes that "those who are separated from the Church and the
1542 Cypr. Ep. lxxiv., which is examined by Augustin in the remaining chapters of this book.
1543 Cypr. Ep.lxxiv. 2.
1544 Cypr. Ep.lxxiv. 2.
1545 Tit. iii. 11.
1546 Rom. ii. 1.
1547 Rom. ii. 21.
1548 1 Cor. vi. 10.
1549 Cypr. Ep. lxxiv. 4.
Chapter 23
852
Chapter 23