not distinguishing between punishment and discipline, is he not better than the god who
spares not his own members though innocent, if necessity is no crime, or guilty from their
obedience to him, if necessity itself is criminal; so that they are condemned eternally by him,
along with whom they should have been released, if any liberty was recovered by the victory,
while he should have been condemned along with them if the victory reduced the force of
necessity even so far as to give this small amount of force to justice? Thus the god whom
you represent us as worshipping, though he is not the one true God whom we really worship,
is far better than your god. Neither, indeed, has any existence; but both are the creatures
of your imaginations. But, according to your own representations, the one whom you call
ours, and find fault with, is better than the one whom you call your own, and whom you
worship. 829
23. So also the patriarchs and prophets whom you cry out against are not the men
whom we honor, but men whose characters are drawn from your fancy, prompted by ill-
will. And yet even thus as you paint them, I will not be content with showing them to be
superior to your elect, who keep all the precepts of Manichæus, but will prove their superi-
ority to your god himself. Before proving this, however, I must, with the help of God, defend
our holy fathers the patriarchs and prophets against your accusations, by a clear exposition
of the truth as opposed to the carnality of your hearts. As for you Manichæans, it would be
enough to say that the faults you impute to our fathers are preferable to what you praise in
your own, and to complete your shame by adding that your god can be proved far inferior
to our fathers as you describe them. This would be a sufficient reply for you. But as, even
apart from your perversities, some minds are of themselves disturbed when comparing the
life of the prophets in the Old Testament with that of the apostles in the New,—not discerning
between the manner of the time when the promise was under a veil, and that of the time
when the promise is revealed,—I must first of all reply to those who either have the boldness
to pride themselves as superior in temperance to the prophets, or quote the prophets in
defence of their own bad conduct.
24. First of all, then, not only the speech of these men, but their life also, was prophetic;
and the whole kingdom of the Hebrews was like a great prophet, corresponding to the
greatness of the Person prophesied. So, as regards those Hebrews who were made wise in
heart by divine instruction, we may discover a prophecy of the coming of Christ and of the
Church, both in what they said and in what they did; and the same is true as regards the
divine procedure towards the whole nation as a body. For, as the apostle says, "all these
things were our examples."
829 [Augustin certainly makes it appear that the God in the Old Testament is not so bad as the God of the
Manichæans, yet he cannot be said to reach a complete theodicy.—A.H.N.]
481
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…