below in the notes upon the respective passages, and to those the reader is referred (compare
especially pp. 88, 98, 100, 111, 112, 114, 127, 194).
Eusebius’ critics are wont to condemn him severely for what they are pleased to call the
dishonesty displayed by him in his Vita Constantini. Such critics forget, apparently, that
that work pretends to be, not a history, but a panegyric. Judging it as such, I am unable to
find anything in it which leads me to entertain for a moment a suspicion of the author’s
honesty. It is true that Eusebius emphasizes the Emperor’s good qualities, and fails to mention
the darker spots in his character; but so far as I am aware he misstates no facts, and does
only what those who eulogize deceased friends are accustomed to do the world over. For a
discussion of this matter the reader is referred to the prolegomena of Dr. Richardson, pp.
467 sq. of this volume. I am pleased to learn from him that his study of the Vita has shown
him nothing which justifies the charge of dishonesty brought against Eusebius.
One of the most decisive marks of veracity upon the part of our author is the frankness
with which he confesses his lack of knowledge upon any subject (cf. IV. 5), and the care
with which he distinguishes between the different kinds of evidence upon which he bases
his statements. How frequently the phrases λόγος žχει, φασί, λέγεται, &c., occur in connec-
tion with accounts which a less scrupulous historian would not hesitate to record as un-
doubted fact. How particular he is to mention his sources for any unusual or startling event.
If the authorities seem to him quite inadequate, he simply omits all reference to an occurrence
which most of his contemporaries and successors would have related with the greatest gusto;
if the testimony seems to him strong, he records the circumstance and expressly mentions
50
his authority, whether oral tradition, the testimony of eye-witnesses, or written accounts,
and we are thus furnished the material from which to form our own judgments.
He is often blamed by modern writers for what they are pleased to call his excessive
credulity. Those who accuse him thus seem to forget that he lived in the fourth, not in the
nineteenth century. That he believed many things which we now declare to be incredible is
perfectly true, but that he believed things that other Christians of his day pronounced in-
credible is not true. Judged, in fact, according to the standard of his age—and indeed of el-
even succeeding centuries—he must be pronounced remarkably free from the fault of over-
credulity, in truth uncommonly skeptical in his attitude toward the marvelous. Not that he
denies the occurrence of prodigies and wonders in his own and other ages, but that he always
demands the strongest testimony before he allows himself to be convinced of their truth.
Compare, e.g., the care with which he gives his authorities for the anecdote in regard to the
Thundering Legion (V. 5), and his final suspension of judgment in the matter; compare also
the emphasis which he lays upon the personal testimony of the Emperor in the matter of
the appearance of the sign of the cross in the sky (Vita Const. I. 28 sq.), a phenomenon which
he himself tells us that he would have believed upon no ordinary evidence. His conduct in
this matter is a sign rather of a skepticism uncommon in his age than of an excessive and
75
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.