mental faculties; for these exist prior to instruction, and without them there cannot be any
instruction, and consequently no virtue, since virtue is learned. But bodily advantages, such
as swiftness of foot, beauty, or strength, are not essential to virtue, neither is virtue essential
to them, and yet they are good things; and, according to our philosophers, even these ad-
vantages are desired by virtue for its own sake, and are used and enjoyed by it in a becoming
manner.
They say that this happy life is also social, and loves the advantages of its friends as its
own, and for their sake wishes for them what it desires for itself, whether these friends live
401
in the same family, as a wife, children, domestics; or in the locality where one’s home is, as
the citizens of the same town; or in the world at large, as the nations bound in common
human brotherhood; or in the universe itself, comprehended in the heavens and the earth,
as those whom they call gods, and provide as friends for the wise man, and whom we more
familiarly call angels. Moreover, they say that, regarding the supreme good and evil, there
is no room for doubt, and that they therefore differ from the New Academy in this respect,
and they are not concerned whether a philosopher pursues those ends which they think
true in the Cynic dress and manner of life or in some other. And, lastly, in regard to the
three modes of life, the contemplative, the active, and the composite, they declare in favor
of the third. That these were the opinions and doctrines of the Old Academy, Varro asserts
on the authority of Antiochus, Cicero’s master and his own, though Cicero makes him out
to have been more frequently in accordance with the Stoics than with the Old Academy.
But of what importance is this to us, who ought to judge the matter on its own merits, rather
than to understand accurately what different men have thought about it?
905
Which of the Three Leading Opinions Regarding the Chief Good Should Be Preferred,…