§27. He falsely imagines that the same energies produce the same works, and that variation
in the works indicates variation in the energies.
Of the same strain is that which he adds in the next paragraph; “the same energies pro-
ducing sameness of works, and different works indicating difference in the energies as well.”
Finely and irresistibly does this noble thinker plead for his doctrine. “The same energies
produce sameness of works.” Let us test this by facts. The energy of fire is always one and
the same; it consists in heating: but what sort of agreement do its results show? Bronze melts
in it; mud hardens; wax vanishes: while all other animals are destroyed by it, the salamander
is preserved alive154; tow burns, asbestos is washed by the flames as if by water; so much
for his ‘sameness of works from one and the same energy.’ How too about the sun? Is not
his power of warming always the same; and yet while he causes one plant to grow, he withers
another, varying the results of his operation in accordance with the latent force of each.
‘That on the rock’ withers; ‘that in deep earth’ yields an hundredfold. Investigate Nature’s
work, and you will learn, in the case of those bodies which she produces artistically, the
amount of accuracy there is in his statement that ‘sameness of energy effects sameness of
result.’ One single operation is the cause of conception, but the composition of that which
is effected internally therein is so varied that it would be difficult for any one even to count
all the various qualities of the body. Again, imbibing the milk is one single operation on the
part of the infant, but the results of its being nourished so are too complex to be all detailed.
While this food passes from the channel of the mouth into the secretory ducts155, the
transforming power of Nature forwards it into the several parts proportionately to their
wants; for by digestion she divides its sum total into the small change of multitudinous dif-
ferences, and into supplies congenial to the subject matter with which she deals; so that the
same milk goes to feed arteries, veins, brain and its membranes, marrow, bones, nerves156,
sinews, tendons, flesh, surface, cartilages, fat, hair, nails, perspiration, vapours, phlegm, bile,
and besides these, all useless superfluities deriving from the same source. You could not
name either an organ, whether of motion or sensation, or anything else making up the
body’s bulk, which was not formed (in spite of startling differences) from this one and self-
same operation of feeding. If one were to compare the mechanic arts too it will be seen what
is the scientific value of his statement; for there we see in them all the same operation, I
mean the movement of the hands; but what have the results in common? What has building
a shrine to do with a coat, though manual labour is employed on both? The house-breaker
154 is preserved alive; ξωογονεῖται. This is the LXX., not the classical use, of the word. Cf. Exod. i. 17; Judges
viii. 19, &c. It is reproduced in the speech of S. Stephen, Acts vii. 19: cf. Luke xvii. 33, “shall preserve (his life).”
155 ἀποκριτικοὺς, activè, so, the Medical writers. The Latin is ‘in meatus destinato descendit’ takes it passivè
(ἀποκριτίκους).
156 νεῦρα. So since Galen’s time: not ‘tendon.’
He falsely imagines that the same energies produce the same works, and that variation in the works indicates variation in the energies.
135
He falsely imagines that the same energies produce the same works, and that…