CHAP. IV.
WHEREIN SEVERAL OTHER OBJECTIONS ARE CONSIDERED.
Dr. T. objects against Adam’s posterity being supposed to come into the world under a
forfeiture
of God’s
blessing,
and subject to his curse through his sin,—That at the restoration of the world after the flood,
God pronounced equivalent or greater
blessings on Noah and his sons, than he did on Adam at his creation, when he said,
be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth, and have dominion over the fish of the sea, &c.*
—To this
I answer, in the following remarks.
1. As has been already shown, that in the
threatening
denounced for Adam’s sin, there was nothing which appears
inconsistent
with the
continuance
of this
present
life for a season, or with
propagating
his kind; so for the like reason, there appears nothing in that threatening, upon the supposition that it reached Adam’s posterity,
inconsistent
with enjoying the
temporal blessings
of the present life, as long as this is
continued; even those temporal blessings which God pronounced on Adam at his first creation. For it must be observed, that the blessings which God pronounced on Adam when he created him, and
before the trial of his obedience,
were not the same with the blessings which were
suspended on his obedience.
The blessings thus suspended, were the blessings of
eternal life
; which, if he had maintained his integrity through his trial, would have been pronounced upon him
afterwards
; when God, as his judge, should have given him his reward. God might indeed, if he had pleased,
immediately
have deprived him of
life,
and of all
temporal blessings,
given him before. But those blessings pronounced on him before-hand, were not the things for the obtaining of which his
trial
was appointed. These were
reserved
till the
issue
of his trial should be seen, and
then
to be pronounced in the blessed sentence,
which would have been passed upon him by his judge, when God came to decree to him his reward for his approved fidelity. The pronouncing of these latter blessings on a degenerate race, that had fallen under the
threatening
denounced, would indeed (without a redemption) have been inconsistent with the
constitution
which had been established. But giving them the
former
kind of blessings, which were not the things suspended on the trial, or dependent on his fidelity, (and
these to be continued for a season,) was not at all inconsistent therewith.
2. It is no more an evidence of
Adam’s
posterity being not included in the threatening denounced for his eating the forbidden fruit, That they still have the
temporal
blessings of fruitfulness, and a dominion over the creatures,
continued
to them; than it is an evidence of Adam being not included in that threatening himself, That
he
had these blessings
continued
to him, was fruitful, and had dominion over the creatures,
after his
fall,
equally with his posterity.
3. There is good evidence, that the benedictions God pronounced on Noah and his posterity, were granted on a
new foundation
; a dispensation
diverse
from any grant, promise, or revelation, which God gave to
Adam,
antecedently to his fall; even on the foundation of the
covenant of grace,
established in
Christ Jesus
; a dispensation, the design of which is to deliver men from the
curse
that came upon them by Adam’s
sin, and to bring them to
greater
blessings than ever
he
had. These blessings were pronounced on Noah and his seed, on the same foundation whereon afterwards the blessing was pronounced on
Abraham
and his seed, which included both spiritual and temporal benefits.—
Noah
had his name prophetically given him by his father
Lamech,
because by him and his seed deliverance should be obtained from the
curse,
which came by
Adam’s
fall.
Gen. v.
29.
“And he called his name
Noah, (i. e. rest,)
saying, This name shall comfort us concerning our work, and toil of our hands, because of the ground which the Lord hath cursed.” Pursuant to the scope and intent of this
prophecy
(which indeed seems to respect the same thing with the prophecy in
Gen. iii. 15.
) are the blessings pronounced on
Noah
after the flood. There is this evidence of these blessings being conveyed through the channel of
the covenant of grace, and by the redemption through Jesus Christ, that they were obtained by
sacrifice
; or were bestowed as the effect of
God’s favour
to mankind, which was in consequence of
smelling a sweet savour
in the sacrifice which Noah offered. And it is very evident by the epistle to the
Hebrews,
that the ancient sacrifices never obtained the favour of God, but only by virtue of the
relation
they had to the sacrifice of
Christ.
—
Now that
Noah
and his family had been so wonderfully saved from the wrath of God, which had destroyed the rest of the world, and the world was as it were restored from a ruined state, there was a proper occasion to point to the
great salvation
to come by Christ: as it was a common thing for God, on occasion of some great
temporal
salvation of his people, or restoration from a low and miserable state, to renew the intimations of the great
spiritual
restoration of the
world by
Christ’s redemption
.
388
God deals with the generality of mankind, in their present state, far differently, on occasion of the redemption by Jesus Christ, from what he otherwise would do; for, being capable subjects of saving mercy, they have a day of patience and grace, and innumerable temporal blessings bestowed on them; which, as the apostle signifies, (
Acts xiv. 17.
) are testimonies of God’s reconcilableness to sinful men, to put them upon
seeking after God.
But beside the sense in which the posterity of
Noah
in general partake of these blessings of
dominion over the creatures,
&c.
Noah
himself, and all such of his posterity as have obtained like precious
faith
with that exercised by him in offering his
sacrifice,
which made it a
sweet savour,
and by which it procured these blessings, have
dominion
over the creatures, through Christ, in a more excellent sense than Adam
in innocency; as they are
made kings and priests unto God, and reign with Christ,
and
all things are theirs,
by a covenant of
grace.
They partake with Christ in that
dominion over the beasts of the earth, the fowls of the air, and fishes of the sea,
spoken of in
the 8th Psalm
; which is by the apostle interpreted of
Christ’s
dominion over the world, (
1 Cor. xv. 27.
and
Heb.
ii. 7.
) And the time is coming, when the greater part of the posterity of
Noah,
and each of his sons, shall partake of this more honourable and excellent dominion over the creatures, through him
in whom all the families of the earth shall be blessed.
Neither is there any need of supposing that these blessings have their most complete accomplishment, till many ages after they were granted, any more than the blessing on Japhet, expressed in those words,
God shall
enlarge Japhet, and he shall dwell in the tents of Shem.
But that Noah’s posterity have such
blessings
given them through the great
Redeemer,
who suspends and removes the
curse
which came through Adam’s sin, surely is no argument, that they originally, as in their natural state, are not under the
curse.
That men have blessings
through grace,
is no evidence of their being not justly exposed to the curse
by nature
; but it rather argues the contrary. For if they did not deserve
the
curse,
they would not depend on
grace and redemption
for the removal of it, and for bringing them into a state of favour with God.
Another
objection,
which our author strenuously urges against the doctrine of original sin, is, that it
disparages
the divine
goodness
in giving us our
being
; which we ought to receive with
thankfulness,
as a great gift of
God’s
beneficence, and look upon as the first, original, and fundamental fruit of the divine liberality.
389
To this I answer, in the following observations:
1. This argument is built on the supposed
truth
of a thing in
dispute
; and so is a
begging of the question.
It is built on this supposition, that we are not properly looked upon as
one
with our
first father,
in the state wherein God at first created him, and in his fall from that state. If we
are
so, it becomes the whole race to acknowledge God’s great
goodness
to them, in the state wherein mankind was made
at
first
; in the
happy
state they were then in, and the fair
opportunity they then had of obtaining
confirmed and eternal happiness
; and to acknowledge it as an aggravation of their apostacy; and to humble themselves, that they were so ungrateful as to rebel against their good Creator. Certainly, we may all do this with as much reason, as the people of Israel in Daniel’s and Nehemiah’s times who did with thankfulness acknowledge God’s great goodness to
their fathers,
many ages before; and in their confessions they bewailed, and took shame to themselves, for the sins committed by their
fathers,
notwithstanding such great goodness. (See
the 9th chapter of Daniel,
and
the 9th of Nehemiah.
)
2. If Dr. T. would imply in his objection, that it doth not consist with the
goodness
of God, to give mankind being in a state of
misery,
what ever was done before by Adam, whether he sinned or did not sin. I reply, if it be justly so ordered, that there should be a posterity of Adam, which must be looked upon as
one with him
; then it is no more contrary to God’s attribute of goodness to give being to his posterity in a state of punishment,
than to
continue
the being of the
same
wicked and guilty person, who has made himself guilty, in a state of punishment. The
giving
of being, and the continuing of being, are both
alike
the work of God’s power and will, and both are alike fundamental to all blessings of man’s present and future existence. And if it be said, it cannot be justly so ordered, that there should be a posterity of Adam, which should be looked upon as
one
with him, this is
begging
the question.
3. If our author would have us to suppose, that it is contrary to the attribute of goodness for God, in
any case
, by an immediate act of his power, to cause
evidence,
and to cause
new
existence, which shall be an exceeding
miserable
existence, by reason of exposedness to eternal ruin; then
his own
scheme must be supposed
contrary
to the attribute of God’s goodness: for he supposes that God will raise multitudes from the dead at
the last day (which will be giving new existence to their bodies, and to bodily life and sense) in order only to their suffering eternal destruction.
4. Notwithstanding we are so sinful and miserable, as we are by nature, yet we may have great reason to bless God, that he has given us our being under so glorious a dispensation of
grace
through Jesus Christ: by which we have a happy opportunity to be
delivered
from this sin and misery, and to obtain unspeakable eternal
happiness.
And because, through our own wicked inclinations, we are disposed so to neglect and abuse this mercy, as to fail of
final benefit by it, this is no reason why we ought not to be
thankful
for it, even according to our author’s own sentiments. What (says he
390
) if
the whole world lies in wickedness,
and few therefore shall be saved? Have men no
reason
to be
thankful,
because they are wicked and ungrateful, and abuse their being and God’s bounty? Suppose our own
evil inclinations
do withhold us,
viz.
from seeking after happiness, of which under the light of the gospel we are placed within the nearer and easier reach, “suppose, the whole Christian world should lie in wickedness, and but few Christians
should be saved, is it therefore certainly true, that we cannot reasonably
thank
God for the gospel?” Well, and though the
evil inclinations,
which hinder our seeking and obtaining happiness by so glorious an advantage, are what we are
born
with, yet if those inclinations are
our fault or sin,
that alters not the case: and to say, they are
not
our sin, is still begging the question. Yea, it will follow from several things asserted by our author, that
notwithstanding men are
born
in such circumstances, as that they are under a very great
improbability
of ever becoming
righteous,
yet they may have
reason to be thankful
for their being. Thus particularly, Dr. T. asserts, that all men have reason of thankfulness for their being; and yet he supposes, that the
heathen
world, taken as a collective body, were
dead in sin,
and could not deliver or help themselves, and therefore stood in necessity of the
christian dispensation. And not only so, but he supposes, that the
christian
world is now at length brought to the
like
deplorable and helpless circumstances, and needs a
new
dispensation for its relief. According to these things, the world in general, not only formerly but even at this day, are
dead in sin
, and helpless as to their salvation; and therefore the generality of them that are born into it, are much more
likely
to perish, than otherwise, till the
new
dispensation comes: and yet he supposes, we all have reason to be thankful for our being. Yea, further still, I think, according to our author’s doctrine, men may have great reason to be
thankful
to God for bringing them into a state, which yet, as the case is, is attended with
misery,
as its
certain
consequence. As, with respect to God’s
raising
the wicked to life, at the last day; which, he supposes, is in itself a great
benefit,
procured by
Christ, and the wonderful
grace
of God through him: and if it be the fruit of God’s wonderful grace, surely men ought to be
thankful
for that grace, and praise God for it. Our doctrine of original sin, therefore, no more disparages God’s goodness in man’s
formation
in the womb, than
his
doctrine disparages God’s goodness in their
resurrection
from the grave.
Another argument, which Dr. T. makes use of, against the doctrine of original sin, is what the Scripture reveals of the process of the day of
judgment
; which represents the judge as dealing with men
singly and separately,
rendering to
every
man according to
his
deeds, and according to the improvement he has made of the particular powers and talents God has given
him
personally.
391
But this objection will vanish, if we consider what is the
end
or
design
of that public judgment. Now this will not be, that God may
find out
what men are, or what punishment or reward is proper for them, or in order to the passing of a right judgment of these things within himself, which is the end of human trials; but it is to
manifest
what men are to their own consciences, and to the world. As the day of judgment is called
the day of
the
revelation
of the righteous judgment of God
; in order to this, God will make use of
evidences,
or
proofs.
But the proper evidences of the wickedness of men’s
hearts
(the true seat of all wickedness) both as to corruption of nature, and additional pollution and guilt, are men’s
works.
The special end of God’s public judgment will be, to make a proper, perfect, open
distinction
among men, rightly to state and manifest their
difference
one from another, in order to that separation and difference in the eternal retribution that is to follow: and this difference will be made to appear, by their
personal works.
There are two things, with regard to which men will be tried, and openly
distinguished,
by the perfect judgment of God at the last day; according to the twofold
real distinction
subsisting among mankind:
viz.
(1.)
The difference of
state; that
primary
and grand distinction, whereby all mankind are divided into two sorts, the righteous and the wicked. (2.) That
secondary distinction,
whereby both sorts differ from others in the
same
general state, in degrees of additional fruits of righteousness and wickedness. Now the Judge, in order to
manifest
both these, will judge men
according to their
personal
works.
But to inquire at the day of judgment, whether
Adam
sinned or no, or whether men are to be looked upon as one with him, and so partakers in his sin, is what in no respect tends to manifest either of these distinctions.
1.
The first
thing; to be manifest, will be the
state,
that each man is in, with respect to the
grand distinction
of the whole world of mankind into
righteous
and
wicked
; or, in metaphorical language,
wheat
and
tares
; or, the
children of the kingdom
of Christ, and the
children of the wicked one
; the latter, the head of the apostacy; but the former, the head of the restoration and
recovery. The Judge, in manifesting this, will prove men’s hearts by
their works,
in such as have had opportunity to perform any works in the body. The
evil works
of the children of the
wicked one
will be the proper
manifestation
and evidence or proof of whatever belongs to the general state of such; and particularly they will prove, that they belong to the kingdom of the great deceiver, and head of the apostacy, as they will demonstrate the exceeding corruption of
their nature, and full consent of their hearts to the common apostacy; and also that their hearts never relinquished the apostacy, by a cordial adherence to Christ, the great restorer.
The Judge will also make use of the
good works
of the
righteous
to show their interest in the redemption of Christ; as thereby will be manifested the sincerity of their hearts in their acceptance of, and adherence to, the Redeemer and his righteousness. And in thus proving the state of
men’s hearts by their actions, the
circumstances
of those actions must necessarily come into consideration, to manifest the true
quality
of their actions; as, each one’s talents, opportunities, advantages, light, motives, &c.
2. The other thing to be manifested, will be that
secondary distinction,
, wherein particular persons, both righteous and wicked, differ from one another, in the
degree
of secondary good or evil; the
degree
of evil fruit, which is additional to the guilt and corruption of the whole body of apostates and enemies; and the
degree
of personal goodness and good fruit, which is a secondary goodness, with respect to the righteousness and merits of
Christ, which belong to all by that sincere faith manifested in all. Of this also each one’s
works,
with their circumstances, opportunities, talents, &c. will be the proper evidence.
As to the nature and aggravations of the general apostacy by
Adam’s
sin, and also the nature and sufficiency of the redemption by
Jesus Christ,
the great restorer, though both these will have vast
influence
on the eternal state, which men shall be adjudged to, yet neither of them will properly belong to the
trial
men will be the subjects of at that day, in order to the
manifestation
of their
state,
wherein they are
distinguished one
from another.
They will belong to the business of that day no otherwise, than the manifestation of the great
truths
of religion in general; as the nature and perfections of God, the dependence of mankind on
God,
as their creator and preserver, &c. Such truths as these will also have great influence on the eternal state, to which men will then be adjudged, as they aggravate the guilt of man’s wickedness, and must be considered in order to a due
estimate of Christ’s righteousness, and men’s personal virtue; yet being of general and equal concernment, will not properly belong to the trial of particular persons.
Another thing urged by our author particularly against the
imputation
of Adam’s sin, is this: “Though, in Scripture, action is frequently said to be
imputed, reckoned, accounted
to a person, it is no other than
his own
act and deed.”
392
In the same place he cites a number of places of Scripture, where these words are used, which he says are all that he can find in the Bible.
But we are no way concerned with this argument at present, any further than it relates to
imputation of sin,
or
sinful action.
Therefore all that is in the argument, which relates to the present purpose, is this: that the word is
so often
applied in Scripture to signify God’s imputing of personal sin, but never once to his imputing of
Adam’s
sin.—
So often
!—How often?—But
twice.
There are but two of all those places which he
reckons up, that have any reference to God
imputing
sin to any person, where there is any evidence that only
personal
sin is meant; (
Levit. xvii. 3, 4.
and
2 Tim. iv. 16.
) All therefore that the argument comes to, is this: that the word
impute,
is applied
twice
in Scripture to the case of God imputing sin, and neither of those times to signify the imputing of Adam’s sin, but both times it has reference to
personal
sin;
therefore Adam’s sin is not imputed to his posterity. And this is to be noted, that one of these two places, even that in
Levit. xvii. 3, 4.
does not speak of imputing the
act
committed, but another
not
committed. The words are, “what man soever there be of the house of Israel, that killeth an ox or lamb or goat in the camp, or that killeth it out of the camp, and bringeth it not unto the door of the tabernacle of the congregation, to offer an offering unto
the Lord, before the tabernacle of the Lord, blood shall be
imputed
unto that man; he hath shed blood; that man shall be cut off from among his people,”
i
.
e.
plainly,
murder
shall be imputed to him: he shall be put to death for it, and therein punished with the same severity as if he had
slain a man.
It is plain by
Isa. lxvi. 3.
that, in some cases, shedding the blood of
beasts,
in an unlawful manner, was
imputed
to them,
as if they slew a man.
But whether it be so or not, although in both these places the word
impute,
be applied to personal sin, and to the very act, or although this could be said of all the places which our author reckons up; yet that the word
impute,
is never expressly applied to Adam’s sin, does no more argue, that it is not imputed to his posterity, than it argues, that pride, unbelief, lying, theft, oppression, persecution, fornication, adultery, sodomy, perjury, idolatry,
and innumerable other particular moral evils, are never
imputed
to the persons that committed them, or in whom they are; because the word
impute,
though so often used in Scripture, is never applied to any of these kinds of wickedness.
I know not what can be said here, except one of these two things: that though these sins are not expressly said to be
imputed,
yet
other
words are used that do as plainly and certainly
imply
that they are imputed, as if it were said so expressly. Very well, and so I say with respect to the imputation of Adam’s sin. The thing meant by the word
impute,
may be as plainly and certainly expressed by using other words, as if
that
word were
expressly used; and
more certainly,
because the words used instead of it, may amount to an
explanation
of this word. And this, I think, is the very case here. Though the word,
impute,
is not used with respect to Adam’s sin, yet it is said,
all have sinned
; which, respecting infants, can be true only of their sinning by his sin. And, it is said,
by his disobedience many were made sinners
; and,
judgment and condemnation came upon all by that
sin
; and that by this means
death,
the wages of sin,
passed on all men, &c.
Which phrases amount to full and precise explanations of the word,
impute
; and therefore do more certainly determine the point really insisted on.
Or, perhaps it will be said, with respect to those personal sins before-mentioned,
pride, unbelief,
&c. it is no argument they are not
imputed
to those who are guilty of them, that the very word
impute,
is not applied to them; for the
word
itself is
rarely
used; not one time in a hundred, and perhaps five hundred, of those wherein the
thing
meant is plainly implied, or may be certainly inferred. Well, and the same also may
be applied likewise, with respect to
Adam’s
sin.
It is probable, Dr. T. intends an argument against original sin, by that which he says in opposition to what R. R. suggests of
children discovering the principles of iniquity, and seeds of sin, before they are capable of moral action
,
393
viz. That
little children are mad
e patterns
of humility, meekness, and innocence,
(
Matt. xviii. 3.
1 Cor. xiv. 20.
and
Psal. cxxxi. 2.
)
But when the utmost is made of this, there can be no shadow of reason, to understand more by these texts, than that little children are recommended as patterns in regard of a
negative
virtue, innocence with respect to the
exercises
and
fruits
of sin,
harmlessness
as to the hurtful effects of it; and that
image
of meekness and humility arising from this, in conjunction with a natural tenderness of mind, fear, self-diffidence,
yieldableness, and confidence in parents and others older than themselves. And so, they are recommended as patterns of virtue no more than
doves,
which are an harmless sort of creatures, and have an
image
of the virtues of meekness and love. Even according to Dr. T.‘s own doctrine, no more can be made of it than this: for his
scheme
will not admit of any such thing as
positive
virtue, or virtuous disposition, in infants; he insisting (as was observed before) that
virtue must be the fruit of
thought
and
reflection.
But there can be no thought and reflection, that produces positive virtue, in children not yet capable of
moral action
; and it is
such
children he speaks of. And that little children have a
negative
virtue or innocence, in relation to the
positive
acts and hurtful effects of vice, is no argument that they have not a
corrupt nature
within them: for let their nature be ever so corrupt, yet
surely it is no wonder that they be not guilty of
positive
wicked action, before they are capable of any
moral
action at all. A young viper has a malignant
nature,
though incapable of doing a malignant action, and at present appearing a harmless creature.
Another objection, which Dr. T. and some others offer against this doctrine, is,
That it pours contempt upon the human nature
.
394
But their declaiming on this topic is like addressing the affections and conceits of
children,
rather than rational arguing with
men.
It seems this doctrine is not
complaisant
enough. I am sensible, it is not suited to the taste of some, who are so very
delicate
(to say no worse) that they can bear nothing but compliment and flattery. No
contempt
is by this doctrine cast upon the noble faculties and capacities of
man’s
nature,
or the exalted business, and divine and immortal happiness, of which he is made capable. And as to speaking ill of man’s present
moral state,
I presume, it will not be denied, that
shame
belongs to them who are truly
sinful
; and to suppose, that this is not the
native
character of mankind, is still but meanly begging the question. If we, as we come into the world, are truly sinful, and consequently miserable, he acts but a
friendly
part to
us, who endeavours fully to discover and manifest our disease. Whereas, on the contrary, he acts an
unfriendly
part, who to his utmost hides it from us: and so, in effect, does what in him lies to prevent our seeking a remedy from that, which if not remedied in time, must bring us finally to shame and
everlasting contempt,
and end in perfect and remediless destruction hereafter.
Another
objection,
which some have made against this doctrine, much like the former, is, that it tends to
beget in us an ill opinion of our fellow-creatures, and so to promote ill-nature and mutual hatred.
To which I would say, if it be truly so, that we all come
sinful
into the world, then our heartily
acknowledging
it, tends to promote
humility
: but
our disowning
that sin and guilt which truly belongs to us, and endeavouring to persuade ourselves that we are vastly
better
than in truth we are, tends to a foolish
self-exaltation
and
pride.
And it is manifest, by reason, experience, and the word of God, that
pride
is the chief source of all the
contention,
mutual
hatred,
and
ill-will
which are so prevalent in the world; and that nothing so effectually promotes the
contrary
tempers and deportments, as
humility.
This doctrine teaches us to think no worse of others, than of ourselves: it teaches us, that we are
all,
as we are by nature,
companions
in a miserable helpless condition; which under a revelation of the divine mercy, tends to promote
mutual
compassion.
And nothing has a greater tendency to promote those amiable dispositions of mercy, forbearance, long-suffering, gentleness, and forgiveness, than a sense of our own extreme unworthiness and misery, and the infinite need we have of the divine pity, forbearance, and forgiveness, together with a hope of obtaining mercy. If the doctrine which teaches that mankind are corrupt by nature, tends to promote
ill-will,
why should not Dr. T.‘s doctrine tend to it as much?
For he teaches us, that the generality of mankind are
very wicked,
having
made themselves so
by their own free choice, without any necessity: which is a way of becoming wicked, that renders men truly
worthy of resentment
; but the other,
not at all,
even according to his own doctrine.
Another
exclamation
against this doctrine is, that it tends to
hinder comfort and joy,
and to
promote melancholy
and
gloominess
of mind.
395
To which I shall briefly say, doubtless, supposing men are really become sinful, and so exposed to the displeasure of God,
by whatever means,
if they once come to have their eyes opened, and are not very stupid, the reflection on their case will tend to make them
sorrowful
; and it is
fit
it should. Men, with whom this is the case, may well be filled with sorrow, till they are sincerely willing to forsake their sins, and turn to God. But
there is nothing in this doctrine, that in the least stands in the way of comfort and exceeding joy, to such as find in their hearts a sincere willingness wholly to forsake all sin, and give their hearts and whole selves to Christ, and comply with the gospel-method of salvation by him.
Another thing
objected,
is, that to make men believe that wickedness belongs to their very
nature,
tends to
encourage
them in
sin,
and plainly to
lead
them to all manner of iniquity; because they are taught, that sin is
natural,
and therefore
necessary and unavoidable
.
396
But if this doctrine, which teaches that
sin
is natural to us, does also at the same time teach us, that it is
never the
better, or less to be condemned,
for its being natural, then it does not at all encourage sin, any more than Dr. T.‘s doctrine encourages wickedness when it is become
inveterate
; who teaches that such as by custom have contracted strong habits of sin, are
unable to help themselves.
397
And is it reasonable, to represent it as encouraging a man in boldly neglecting and wilfully continuing in his
disease,
without seeking a
cure,
to tell him of his disease, to show him that it is real and very fatal, and what
he
can never cure himself of; yet withal directing him to a great
Physician,
who is sufficient for his restoration? But for a more particular answer to what is objected against the doctrine of our natural
impotence and
inability,
as being an encouragement to go on in sin, and a discouragement to the use of all means for our help, I must for brevity refer the reader to what has been largely written on this head in my discourse on the
Freedom of the Will.
Our author is pleased to advance another notion, among others, by way of
objection
against the doctrine of original sin: that if this doctrine be true,
it would be unlawful to beget children.
He says,
398
“If natural
generation
be the means of unavoidably
conveying
all sin and wickedness into the world, it must
itself
be a
sinful and unlawful
thing.” Now, if there be any force of argument here, it lies in this proposition,
whatsoever is a means or occasion of the certain infallible existence of sin and wickedness, must itself be sinful.
But I imagine Dr. T. had not thoroughly weighed this proposition, nor considered where it would carry him. For,
God
continuing in being
the devil, and others that are finally given up to wickedness, will be attended, most certainly and infallibly, with an eternal series of the most hateful and horrid wickedness. But will any be guilty of such vile blasphemy, as to say, therefore God’s upholding of them in being is itself a
sinful
thing? In the same place our author says, “so far as we are
generated in sin,
it must be a
sin
to generate.” But there is no appearance of evidence
in that position, any more than in this: “So far as any is
upheld in existence
in sin, it is a
sin
to uphold them in existence.” Yea, if there were any reason in the case, it would be strongest in the latter position: for parents, as Dr. T. himself observes, are not the
authors
of the
beginning
of existence: whereas, God is truly the author of the
continuance
of existence. As it is the known will of God, to continue
Satan
and millions of others
in
being,
though the most sure
consequence
is the continuance of a vast infernal world, full of everlasting hellish
wickedness
: so it is part of the revealed will of God, that this world of mankind should be
continued,
and the species
propagated,
for his own wise and holy purposes; which
will is complied with
by the parents joined in lawful
marriage.
Their children, though they come into the world in sin, yet are capable subjects of eternal
holiness and happiness: which infinite benefits for their children, parents have great reason to expect, in the way of giving up their children to God in faith, through a Redeemer, and bringing them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord. I think, this may be answer enough to such a cavil.
Another
objection
is, That the doctrine of original sin is no
oftener,
and no more
plainly,
spoken of in
Scripture
; it being, if true, a very
important
doctrine. Dr. T. in many parts of his book suggests to his readers, that there are very
few texts,
in the whole Bible, wherein there is the least appearance of their teaching any such doctrine.
Of this I took notice before, but would here say further: That the reader who has perused the preceding defence of this doctrine, must now be left to judge for himself, whether there be any
ground
for such an allegation; whether there be not texts in
sufficient
number, both in the Old Testament and New, that exhibit undeniable
evidence
of this great article of christian divinity; and whether it be not a doctrine taught in the Scripture with great
plainness.
I think, there are few, if any, doctrines of revelation, taught more plainly and expressly. Indeed it is taught in an explicit manner more in the
New Testament
than in the
Old.
Which is not to be wondered at; it being thus with respect to all the most important doctrines of revealed religion.
But if it had been so, that this doctrine were but
rarely
taught in Scripture; yet if we find that it is
indeed
declared to us by God, if held forth to us by
any
word of his; then what belongs to us, is, to
believe
his word, and
receive
the doctrine which he teaches us; and not to prescribe to him how
often
he shall speak of it, and to insist upon knowing what
reasons
he has for speaking of it
no oftener,
before we will receive what he teaches us; or to pretend that he should give us an account, why he did not speak of it so
plainly
as we think he ought to have done,
sooner
than he did. In this way of proceeding, if it be reasonable, the
Sadducees
of old, who denied any resurrection or future state, might have maintained their cause against Christ, when he blamed them for
not knowing the Scriptures, nor the power of God
; and for not understanding by the
Scripture, that there would be a resurrection to spiritual enjoyment, and not to animal life, and sensual gratifications; and they might have insisted, that these doctrines, if true, were very
important,
and therefore ought to have been spoken of in the Scriptures
oftener
and more
explicitly,
and not that the church of God should be left, till that time, with only a
few obscure
intimations of that which so infinitely concerned them. And they might with disdain have
rejected Christ’s argument, by way of
inference
from God calling himself in the books of
Moses,
the god of
Abraham, Isaac,
and
Jacob.
For answer, they might have said, that Moses was sent on purpose to teach the people the mind and will of God; and therefore, if these doctrines were true, he
ought in reason and in truth
to have taught them plainly and frequently, and not have left the people to spell out so important a doctrine, only from God’s saying, that he
was the God of
Abraham,
&c.
One great
end
of the
Scripture
is; to teach the world
what manner of being
GOD is; about which the world, without revelation, has been so wofully in the dark: and that
God is an infinite being,
is a doctrine of great
importance,
and a doctrine sufficiently taught in the Scripture. But yet, it appears to me, this doctrine is not taught there, in any measure, with such
explicitness
and
precision,
as the doctrine of
original sin: and the
Socinians,
who denied God’s omnipresence and omniscience, had as much room left them for cavil, as the
Pelagians
who deny original sin.
Dr. T. particularly urges, that
Christ
says
not one word
of this doctrine throughout the
four Gospels
; which doctrine, if true, being so important, and what so nearly concerned the great work of redemption, which he came to work out, (as is supposed,) one would think,
it should have been emphatically spoken of in every page, of the Gosp
els.
399
In reply to this, it may be observed, that by the account given in the four Gospels, Christ was continually saying,
those things
which plainly
implied,
that all men in their original state are sinful and miserable. As, when he declared, that
they which are whole, need not a physician, but they which are sick
;
400
That
he came to seek and to save that which was lost
.
401
That it was necessary for all to be
born again,
and to be
converted,
and that otherwise they could not
enter into the kingdom of heaven
;
402
—
and, that all were
sinners,
as well as those whose blood
Pilate
mingled with their sacrifices, &c. and that
every one who did not repent, should perish
;
403
—
Withal directing everyone to
pray
to God
for forgiveness of sin
;
404
—Using our necessity of forgiveness from God, as an argument with all to forgive the injuries of their neighbours;
405
—Teaching, that earthly
parents,
though kind to their children, are in themselves evil;
406
—And signifying, that things
carnal
and
corrupt
are properly
the things of men
;
407
—Warning his disciples rather to beware of
men,
than of wild beasts;
408
—Often representing the world as
evil,
as
wicked
in its works, at
enmity
with
truth
and
holiness,
and
hating him
;
409
—Yea, and teaching plainly, that all men are extremely and inexpressibly sinful, owing
ten thousand talents
to their divine creditor.
410
And whether Christ did not plainly teach
Nicodemus
the doctrine of original total depravity, when he came to him to know what his doctrine was, must be left to the reader to judge, from what has been already observed on
John iii. 1-11
. And besides, Christ in the course of his preaching took the most proper method to convince men of the corruption of their nature, and to give them an effectual and practical knowledge of it, in application to
themselves in particular, by teaching and urging the holy and strict
law
of God, in its extent, and spirituality, and dreadful threatenings: which, above all things, tends to search the hearts of men, and to teach them their inbred exceeding depravity; not merely as a matter of speculation, but by proper conviction of conscience; which is the only knowledge of original sin, that can avail to prepare the mind for receiving Christ’s redemption; as a man’s sense of his own sickness prepares
him to apply in good earnest to the physician.
And as to Christ being no more frequent and particular in mentioning and inculcating this point in a
doctrinal
manner, it is probable, one reason to be given for it, is the same that is to be given for his speaking no oftener of God’s
creating of the world
: which, though so important a doctrine, is scarce ever spoken of in any of Christ’s discourses; and no wonder, seeing this was a matter which the
Jews,
to whom he confined his personal
ministry, had all been instructed in from their forefathers, and never was called in question among them. And there is a great deal of reason, from the ancient
Jewish
writers, to suppose, that the doctrine of original sin had ever been allowed in the open profession of that people;
411
though they were generally, in that corrupt time, very far from a practical
conviction of it; and many notions were then prevalent, especially among the
Pharisees,
which were indeed inconsistent with it. And though on account of these prejudices they might need to have this doctrine explained and applied to them, yet it is well known, by all acquainted with their Bibles, that Christ, for wise reasons, spake more sparingly and obscurely of several of the
most important doctrines of revealed religion, relating to the necessity, grounds, nature, and way of his redemption, and the method of the justification of sinners, while he lived here in the flesh; and left these doctrines to be more plainly and fully opened and inculcated by the Holy Spirit after his ascension.
But if, after all, Christ did not speak of this doctrine often enough to suit Dr. T. he might be asked, Why he supposes Christ did no
oftener
and no more
plainly teach
some of
his,
Dr. T.‘s, doctrines, which he so much insists on? As, that temporal
death
comes on all mankind by Adam; and that it comes on them by him, not as a punishment or calamity, but as a great
favour,
being made a rich benefit, and a fruit of God’s abundant grace,
by Christ’s
redemption,
who came into the world as a second Adam for this end. Surely, if this were so, it was of vast
importance,
that it should be
known
to the church of God in all ages, who saw
death
reigning over
infants,
as well as others. If infants were indeed perfectly
innocent,
was it not needful, that the
design
of that which was such a melancholy and awful dispensation towards so many millions of innocent creatures, should be
known,
in order to prevent the worst thoughts of God from arising in the minds of the constant spectators of so mysterious and gloomy a dispensation? But why then such a
total silence
about it, for four thousand years together, and not one word of it in all the
Old Testament
; nor one word of it in all the
four Gospels
: and indeed not one word of it in the
whole Bible,
but only as forced and wrung out by Dr. T.‘s arts of criticism and deduction, against the
plainest and strongest evidence?
As to the arguments, made use of by many late writers, from the universal
moral sense,
and the reasons they offer from experience, and observation of the
nature
of mankind, to show that we are
born
into the world with principles of
virtue
; with a natural prevailing relish, approbation, and love of righteousness, truth, and goodness, and of whatever tends to the public welfare; with a prevailing natural disposition to dislike, to
resent, and condemn what is selfish, unjust, and immoral; and a native bent in mankind to mutual benevolence, tender compassion, &c. those who have had such objections against the doctrine of original sin thrown in their way, and desire to see them particularly considered, I ask leave to refer them to a
treatise on the
nature
of true
virtue, lying by me prepared for the press, which may ere long be exhibited to public view.
412
CONCLUSION.
On the whole, I observe, there are some
other
things, besides arguments, in Dr. T.‘s book, which are calculated to influence the minds, and bias the judgment, of some sorts of readers. Here, not to insist on the profession he makes, in many places, of
sincerity, humility, meekness, modesty, charity,
&c. in searching after truth; and freely proposing his thoughts, with the
reasons
of them, to others;
413
nor on his magisterial
assurance,
appearing on many occasions, and the high
contempt
he sometimes expresses of the opinions and arguments of very excellent divines and fathers in the church of God, who have thought
differently
from him
414
—
both
of which, it is not unlikely, may have a degree of influence on some of his readers—I would take some notice of another thing, observable in the writings of Dr. T. and many of the late opposers of the more peculiar doctrines of Christianity, tending (especially with
juvenile
and
unwary
readers) not a little to abate the force, and prevent the due effect, of the clearest
scripture-evidences
in favour of those important doctrines; and particularly to
make void the arguments taken from the writings of the apostle
Paul,
in which those doctrines are more plainly and fully revealed, than in any other part of the Bible. What I mean, is this: These gentlemen express a
high opinion
of this apostle, and that very justly, for his eminent genius, his admirable sagacity, strong powers of reasoning, acquired learning, &c. They speak of him as a writer of masterly address, of extensive reach, and deep design, every where in his
epistles, almost in every word he says. This looks exceedingly
specious
: it carries a plausible appearance of
christian zeal
and attachment to the
Holy Scriptures,
to bear such a testimony of high veneration for that great apostle, who was not only the principal instrument of propagating Christianity, but with his own hand wrote so considerable a part of the New Testament. And I am far from determining, with respect at least to some of these writers, that they are
not
sincere
in their declarations; or, that all is mere
artifice,
only to make way for the reception of
their own
peculiar sentiments. However, it tends
greatly to subserve such a purpose; as much as if it were designedly contrived, with the utmost subtilty, for that end. Hereby their incautious readers are prepared the more easily to be drawn into a belief, that they, and others in their way of thinking, have not
rightly understood
many of those
things in this apostle’s writings, which before seemed very
plain
to them. Thus they are prepared, by a prepossession in
favour
of these
new writers,
to entertain a favourable thought of the
interpretations
put by them upon the words and phrases of this apostle; and to admit in many passages a meaning which before lay entirely out of sight; quite foreign to all that in the view of a common reader seems to be their obvious sense; and most remote from the expositions
agreed in by those who used to be esteemed the greatest divines, and best commentators. As to this apostle, being a man of no
vulgar
understanding, it is nothing strange if his meaning lies very
deep
; and no wonder then, if the superficial observation of vulgar Christians, or indeed of the herd of common divines, such as the
Westminster Assembly,
&c. falls vastly short of the apostle’s reach, and frequently does not enter into the true spirit and design of his
epistles. They must understand, that the
first reformers,
and indeed preachers and expositors in general, for fifteen or sixteen hundred years past, were too
unlearned
and
short-sighted,
to be capable of penetrating into the sense, or fit to make comments on the writings, of so great a man as this apostle; or else had dwelt in a cave of
bigotry
and
superstition,
too gloomy to allow them to use their own understandings with freedom, in reading the Scripture.
But, at the same time, it must be understood, that there is risen up now at length, in this happy age of light and liberty, a set of men, of a more free and generous turn of mind, of a more inquisitive genius, and of better discernment. By such insinuations, they seek advantage to their cause; and thus the most unreasonable and extravagant interpretations of Scripture are palliated and recommended: so that, if the simple reader is not very much on his guard, if he does not clearly see with his
own eyes, or has too much indolence, or too little leisure, thoroughly to examine for himself, he is in danger of being imposed on with delusive appearances.
But I humbly conceive, that their interpretations—particularly of the apostle Paul’s writings, though in some things ingenious—are in many things extremely absurd, and demonstrably disagreeable, in the highest degree, to
his
real design, to the language he commonly uses, and to the doctrines currently taught in his epistles. Their
criticisms,
when examined, appear far more subtile, than solid; and it seems as if nothing can possibly be strong enough,
nothing perspicuous enough, in any composure whatever, to stand before such
liberties
as these writers indulge. The plainest and most nervous discourse is analyzed and criticized, till it either dissolves into nothing, or becomes a thing of little significance. The Holy Scripture is subtilized into a mere mist; or made to evaporate into a thin cloud, that easily puts on any shape, and is moved in any direction, with a puff of wind, just as the manager pleases. It is not in the nature and
power of language, to afford sufficient defence against such an art, so abused; as, I imagine, a due consideration of some things I have had occasion in the preceding discourse to observe, may abundantly convince us.
But this, with the rest of what I have offered on the subject, must be left with every candid reader’s judgment; and the
success
of the whole must now be left with God, who knows what is agreeable to his own mind, and is able to make his own truths prevail; however mysterious they may seem to the poor, partial, narrow, and extremely imperfect views of mortals, while looking through a cloudy and delusory medium; and however disagreeable they may be to the
innumerable prejudices of men’s hearts:— and who has promised, that the gospel of christ, such as is really
his,
shall finally be victorious; and has assured us, that the
word
which goes out of his mouth,
shall not return to him void, but shall accomplish that which he pleaseth, and shall prosper in the thing whereto he sends it.
—Let god arise, and plead his own cause, and glorify his own great name. amen.
388
It may be noted, that Dr. T himself signifies it as his mind, that these blessings on Noah were on account of the covenant of grace, p. 84, 90, 91. 92. S.
389
Page 256, 357, 260, 71-74. S.
390
Page 72, 73. S.
391
Page 65, 66, 111. S.
392
Page 3, &c. 105.
393
Page 77, 78. S.
394
Page 74, 75. S.
395
Page 231, and some other places.
396
Page 139, and 259.
397
See his exposition on
Rom. vii.
p. 205 -220. But especially in his paraphrase and notes on the epistle.
398
Page 145.
399
Page 242, 243.
400
Matt. ix.12.
401
Matt. xviii.11.
Luke xix.10.
402
Matt. xviii. 3.
403
Luke xiii.1-5.
404
Matt.vi.12.
Luke xi.4.
405
Matt. vi. 14, 15.
406
Matt. vii. 11.
407
Matt. xvi. 23.
408
Matt. x.16, 17.
409
John vii.7,
viii.23,
xiv. 17,
xv. 18, 19.
410
Matt. xviii. 21,
to the end
411
What is found in the more ancient of the Jewish rabbies, who have written since the coming of Christ, is an argument of this. Many things of this sort are taken notice of by Stapferus, in his Theologia Polemica before mentioned. Some of these things which are there cited by him in Latin, I shall here faithfully give in English, for the sake of the English reader. ”—So Manasseh, concerning Human Frailty. p. 129.—
Gen viii. 21.
I will not any
more curse the earth for man’s sake; for the appetite of man is evil from his youth; that is, from the time when he comes forth from his mother’s womb. For at the same time that he sucks the breasts, he follows his lust; and while he is yet an infant, he is under the dominion of anger, envy, hatred, and other vices to which that tender age is obnoxious.”— ”
Prov. xxii. 15.
Solomon says, Foolishness is bound to the mind of a child.” Concerning which place R. Levi Ben Gersom
observes thus, “Foolishness as it were grows to him in his very beginning.” Concerning this sin, which is common and original to all men, David said,
Psal. ii. 5.
Behold I was begotten in iniquity, and in sin did my mother warm me. Upon which place Ebeb-Ezra says thus: “Behold, because of the concupiscence which is innate in the heart of man, it is said, I am begotten in iniquity. And the sense is, that there is implanted in the heart of man, jetzer harang, an evil figment,
from his nativity.” And Manasseh Ben Israel, de Fragil. pag. 2. “Behold, I was formed in iniquity, and in sin hath my mother warmed me. But whether this be understood concerning the common mother, which was Eve, or whether David spake only of his own mother, he would signify, that sin is as it were natural, and inseparable in this life. For it is to be observed, that Eve conceived after the transgression was committed: and as many as were begotten afterwards, were not brought forth in
conformity to the rule of right reason, but in conformity to disordly and lustful affections.” He adds, “One of the wise men of the Jews, namely, R. Aha, rightly observed, David would signify that it is impossible, even for pious men who excel in virtue, never to commit any sin.” “Job also asserts the same thing with David,
chap xiv. 4.
saying, “Who will give a clean thing for an unclean? Truly not one.” Concerning which words Aben-Ezra says thus:
“The sense is the same with that, I was begotten in iniquity, because man is made out of an unclean thing.” Stapferus, Theolog. Polem. tom. iii. p. 36, 37. Id. Ibid. p. 132, &c. So Sal. Jarchi ad Gemaram, Cod. Schabbath, fol. 142. p. 2. “And this is not only to be referred to sinners; because all the posterity of the first man are in like manner subjected to all the curses pronounced on him.” And Manasseh Ben Israel, in his preface to Human Fraility, says, “I had a mind to show by what
means it came to pass, that when the first father of all had lost his righteousness, his posterity are begotten liable to the same punishment with him.” And Munsterus on the Gospel of Matthew cites the following words, from the book called The Bundle of Myrrh:” The blessed Lord said to the first man, when he cursed him, Thorns and thistles shall it bring forth to thee; and thou shalt eat the herb of the field. The thing which he means is, that because of his sin all who should descend from him,
should be wicked and perverse, like thorns and thistles, according to that word of the Lord, speaking to the prophet: Thorns and irritators are with thee, and thou dwellest among scorpions. And all this from the serpent, who was the devil, Sammael, who emitted a mortiferous and corruptive poison into Eve, and became the cause of death to Adam himself, when he eat the the fruit.” Remarkable is the place quoted in Joseph de Voisin, against Martin Raymond, p. 471. of Master Menachem Rakanatensis,
sect. Bereschit, from Midrasch Tehillim: which is cited by Hoerndekius, against the Jews, in these words: “It is no wonder, that the sin of Adam and Eve is written and sealed with the king’s ring, and to be propagated to all following generations; because on the day that Adam was created, all things were finished: so that he stood forth the perfection and completion of the whole workmanship of the world: so when he sinned, the whole world sinned; whose sin we bear and suffer. But the matter is
not thus with respect to the sins of his posterity.” —Thus far Stapferus. Besides these, as Ainsworth on
Gen. viii. 21.
observes, “In Bereshith Rabba, a Hebrew commentary on this place, a rabbin is said to be asked, When is the evil imagination put into man? And he answered, From the hour that he is formed.” And in Pool’s Synopsis it is added, from Grotius, “So Rabbi Salomon interprets
Gen. viii. 21.
The imagination of man’s heart, is evil from his
youth, of its being evil from the time that he is taken out of his mother’s bowels.” Aben-Ezra thus interprets
Psal. li. 5.
“I was shapen in iniquity, and in sin did my mother conceive me; that evil concupiscence is implanted in the heart from childhood, as if he were formed in it; and by my mother, he understands Eve, who did not bear children till she had sinned. And so Kafvenaki says, How shall I avoid sinning? My ORIGINAL is corrupt, and from thence are those sins. So
Manasseh Ben Israel, from this place (
Psal. li. 5.
) concludes, that not only David, but all mankind, ever since sin was introduced into the world, do sin from their original. To this purpose is the answer of Rabbi Hakkadosch which there is an account of in the Talmud. From what time does concupiscence rule over man? From the very moment of his first formation, or from his nativity? Ans. From his formation.”’—Pool’s Synops. in Loc. On these things I observe, there is the
greatest reason to suppose, that these old rabbies of the Jewish nation, who give such heed to the tradition of the elders, would never have received this doctrine of original sin, had it not been delivered down to them from their forefathers. For it is a doctrine very disagreeable to those practical principles and notions, wherein the religion of the unbelieving Jews most fundamentally differs from the religion maintained among Christians: particularly their notion of justification by their
own righteousness, and privileges as the children of Abraham. &c. without standing in need of any satisfaction, by the sufferings of the Messiah. On which account the modern Jews do now universally reject the doctrine of original sin, and corruption of nature: as Stapferus observes. And it is not at all likely, that the ancient Jews, if no such doctrine had been received by tradition from the fathers would have taken it up from the Christians, whom they had in such great contempt and
enmity; especially as it is a doctrine so peculiarly agreeable to the christian notion of the spiritual salvation of Jesus, and so contrary to their carnal notions of the Messiah, and of his salvation and kingdom, and so contrary to their opinion of themselves; and a doctrine, which men in general are so apt to be prejudiced against. And besides, these rabbies do expressly refer to the opinion of their forefathers; as R. Manasseh says, “according to the opinion of the ancients, none are subject
to death, but those which have sinned; for where there is no sin, there is no death.” Stapfer. tom. iii. p. 37, 38. But where we have more direct evidence, that the doctrine of original sin was truly a received doctrine among the ancient Jews, even before the coming of Christ. This appears by ancient Jewish writings, which were written before Christ: as, in the apocrypha,
2 Esdras iii. 21.
“For the first Adam, bearing a wicked heart, transgressed, and was overcome: and so
be all they that are born of him. Thus infirmity was made permanent; and the law also in the heart of the people, with the malignity of the root; so that the good departed away, and the evil abode still.”
2 Esdras iv. 30.
“For the grain of evil seed hath been sown in the heart of Adam, from the beginning; and how much ungodliness hath it brought up unto this time? And how much shall it yet bring forth, till the time of threshing shall come?” And
chap. vii. 46.
“It had been better, not to have given the earth unto Adam; or else, when it was given to him, to have restrained him from sinning; for what profit is it, for men now in this present time, to live in heaviness, and after death to look for punishment? O thou Adam, what hast thou done? For though it was thou that sinned, thou art not fallen alone, but we all that came of thee.” And we read
Eccl. xxv. 24.
“Of the
woman came the beginning of sin, and through her we all die.” As this doctrine of original corruption was constantly maintained in the church of God from the beginning; so from thence, in all probability, as well as from the evidennce of it in universal experience, it was, that the wiser heathens maintained the like doctrine. Particularly Plato, that great philosopher, so distinguished for his veneration of ancient traditions, and diligent inquiries after them. Gale, in his Court of the
Gentiles, observes as follows: “PLATO says, (Gorg. fol. 493.) I have heard from the wise men, that are now dead, and that the body is but our sepulchre. And in his Timaeus Locrus (fol. 103) he says, The cause of vitiosity is from our parents, and first principles, rather than from ourselves. So that we never relinquish those actions, which lead us to follow those primitive blemishes of our first parents. Plato mentions the corruption of the will, and seems to disown free will to true good;
albeit he allows some (NOT ENGLISH), or natural dispositions, to civil good, in some great heroes. Socrates asserted the corruption of human nature, or (NOT ENGLISH) .—Grotius affirms, that the philosophers acknowledged, it was con-natural to men to sin. Seneca (Benef. 5. 14.) says, wickedness has not its first beginning in wicked practice; though by that it is first exercised and made manifest. And Plutarch (de sera vindictis) says man does not first become wicked, when he first manifests
himself so: but he hath wickedness from the beginning; and he shows it as soon as he finds opportunity and ability. As men rightly judge, that the sting is not first engendered in scorpions when they strike, or the poison in vipers when they bite.—Pool’s Synopsis on
Gen. viii. 21.
To which may be subjoined what Juvenal says, —Admores natura recurrit Damnates fixa et mutari nescia. Englished thus, in prose: Nature, a thing fixed and not knowing how to change, returns to its
wicked manners.—WATTS, Ruin and Recovery.
412
See Dissertation concerning the Nature of True Virtue, p. 122.
413
See his Preface, and p. 6. 237, 263, 267, 175. S.
414
Page 110, 125, 150, 151, 159, 161, 183, 188. 77. S.