§5. Thereafter he shows that there are not two Christs or two Lords, but one Christ and
one Lord, and that the Divine nature, after mingling with the Human, preserved the properties
of each nature without confusion, and declares that the operations are, by reason of the union,
predicated of the two natures in common, in the sense that the Lord took upon Himself the
sufferings of the servant, and the humanity is glorified with Him in the honour that is the
Lord’s, and that by the power of the Divine Nature that is made anew, conformably with that
Divine Nature Itself.
His next charge too has its own absurdity of the same sort. For he reproaches us with
180
saying that there are “two Christs,” and “two Lords,” without being able to make good his
charge from our words, but employing falsehood at discretion to suit his fancy. Since, then,
he deems it within his power to say what he likes, why does he utter his falsehood with such
care about detail, and maintain that we speak but of two Christs? Let him say, if he likes,
that we preach ten Christs, or ten times ten, or extend the number to a thousand, that he
may handle his calumny more vigorously. For blasphemy is equally involved in the doctrine
of two Christs, and in that of more, and the character of the two charges is also equally
devoid of proof. When he shows, then, that we do speak of two Christs, let him have a verdict
against us, as much as though he had given proof of ten thousand. But he says that he convicts
us by our own statements. Well, let us look once more at those words of our master by
means of which he thinks to raise his charges against us. He says “he” (he, that is, who says
“Him God made Lord and Christ, this Jesus Whom ye crucified”) “is not setting forth to us
the mode of the Divine existence, but the terms which belong to the Incarnation…laying
stress by the demonstrative word on that in Him which was human and was seen by all.”
This is what he wrote. But whence has Eunomius managed by these words to bring on the
stage his “two Christs”? Does saying that the demonstrative word lays stress on that which
is visible, convey the proof of maintaining “two Christs”? Ought we (to avoid being charged
with speaking of “two Highests”) to deny the fact that by Him the Lord was highly exalted
after His Passion? seeing that God the Word, Who was in the beginning, was Highest, and
was also highly exalted after His Passion when He rose from the dead, as the Apostle says.
We must of necessity choose one of two courses—either say that He was highly exalted after
the Passion (which is just the same as saying that He was made Lord and Christ), and be
impeached by Eunomius, or, if we avoid the accusation, deny the confession of the high
exaltation of Him Who suffered.
Now at this point it seems right to put forward once more our accuser’s statement in
support of our own defence. We shall therefore repeat word for word the statement laid
down by him, which supports our argument as follows:—“The blessed John,” he says,
“teaches us that God the Word, by Whom all things were made, has become incarnate,
saying ‘And the Word was made flesh.’” Does he understand what he is writing when he
adds this to his own argument? I can hardly myself think that the same man can at once be
Thereafter he shows that there are not two Christs or two Lords, but one Christ and one Lord, and that the Divine nature, after mingling with the Human, preserved the properties of each nature without confusion, and declares that the operations are, by reason of the union, predicated of the two natures in common, in the sense that the Lord took upon Himself the sufferings of the servant, and the humanity is glorified with Him in the honour that is the Lord's, and that by the power of the Divine Nature that is made anew, conformably with that Divine Nature Itself.
345
Thereafter he shows that there are not two Christs or two Lords, but one…