§5.
Moral
Characteristics.
(a)
In relations with events,
things, or persons.
First of all, Constantine excelled in
Energy,
that fundamental of all developed character. He was
pre-eminent for masculine strength of character (Theoph. p. 29), a man
of energy (
vir ingens,
Eutrop. 10. 1). This was manifested at
every turn, in his successful military activity under Diocletian, in
the decisive acts at the time of leaving him, in the prosecution of
campaigns against Maximian, Maxentius, Licinius, in the wholesale way
in which he pushed internal improvements, the building of
Constantinople, the multiplication of Christian houses of worship, in
his studies, in his law-making; in short, in everything he touched
there was the same teeming, resistless energy of the man. His
Determination
was “bent on effecting whatever he had
settled in his mind” (Eutrop. 10. 5). His
Rapidity of
action
when he rejoined his father is described by Lactantius as
incredible (Lact. c. 24). He showed the same alacrity in his quick
return and surprise of Maximian, in his first entry into Italy, and in
his campaign against Licinius. This energy and activity rose to
positive
Impetuosity,
which led him at Verona, before Rome, and
at Cibalis to plunge into the midst of battle, communicating his own
resistless, indomitable, alert will to do, to his soldiers. Closely
linked with these qualities was that personal
Courage and Valor,
inherited from his father (Paneg. 307, c. 3), mentioned by Eusebius
(
V. C.
1. 11), and explicitly or implicitly by almost every one.
This most indubitable of all his qualities was witnessed to even by the
scoffing Julian as “inexpressibly” great (
Orat.
p.
13), and mentioned even in the work whose chief aim seems, almost, to
detract from Constantine (
Cæs.
p. 23). United with all
these characteristics of greatness was a far-reaching
Ambition
.
This on the one hand is represented to be an ambition for power and
glory. He was “exceedingly ambitious of military glory”
(Eutrop. 10. 7); “aspiring to the sovereignty of the whole
world” (Eutrop. 10. 5). According to Zosimus, at the time of the
appointment of Severus and Maximin, already having his mind set on
attaining royalty he was roused to a greater desire by the honor
conferred on Severus and Maximin, and this eager desire of power was
already well known to many. On the other hand, this ambition is
represented to be a burning zeal for righting wrongs; his
wars against Maxentius
and Licinius real crusades, and his actual objective in all things the
reform to be effected. If the fruit proves the motive, this was so; for
he consistently used or tried to use his power for what he thought
public good. This he did in Gaul, after his victories, in his
legislation, and in his internal improvements.
In view of all this powerfulness
of personality, it may be said of all successes of this “man of
power” (Eutrop. 10. 5) what Eutropius says of his success in war,
that it was great, “but not more than proportioned to his
exertions” (Eutrop.). With all this energy of personality,
however, he was far from being headstrong. On the contrary, he showed
marked
Prudence,
resembling his father in this also (Paneg. 307,
c. 3). Sustaining so long the delicate position at the court of
Diocletian, all his provision for guarding the frontiers, his
long-suffering in waiting to be confirmed Cæsar, in waiting his
opportunity to meet Maxentius, in waiting and getting everything in
hand before meeting Licinius, his wise moderation in demand on the
conquered, and the not pressing forward until he had everything well
arranged, show this, and a high degree of
Patience
withal. This
latter virtue was peculiarly characteristic whether exercised in
respect of things or plans or people, and his great patience in
listening to complaints (Naz. c. 24) is only a part of the whole. As he
was patient, so he was distinguished for
Perseverance,
and
“firm and unshaken” (Theoph. p. 29)
Steadfastness.
So great energy united with these other qualities barely needs
testimony to suggest great
Faithfulness
to his tasks in hand, as
in that “strict attention to his military duties” which
Lactantius says (c. 18) characterized him as a young man. In brief, his
whole personality was a marked example of that balance of power and the
measuring of remote ends which is included under the word
Self-control,
in the use of the philosophy of which he, as well
as his father, was a disciple. In this exercise of his great energy
towards himself he was recognized to be remarkable. This self-control
was manifested especially in his unusual
Chastity.
As a young
man he was marked by correct moral habits (
probis moribus,
Lact.
c. 18). The specific testimony of Eusebius to this (
V. C.
) would
have comparatively little weight on a point like this, and the same
might be said, in a measure, of the testimony of the Panegyrists (Naz.
c. 24; 307, c. 4; 313, c. 4), who mention this virtue. But panegyrical
art would forbid the laudation of what was conspicuously lacking;
rather it would not be mentioned, and the general testimony goes to
show at least a contemporary reputation for extraordinary continence,
considering his time and environment. His relationship with Minervina
hardly touches this reputation, whether she was wife or only legitimate
concubine. The accusations and innuendoes of Julian,
Cæsars,
have, in any fairly critical estimate, hardly more
than the weight of some malignant gossip whose backbiting is from his
own heart. “Honi soit qui mat y pense.” Like Licinius, he
seems to have been unable to understand that purity of heart which
permitted the free companionship of women in social or religious life.
Julian’s general charge of luxuriousness and sensuousness (p. 43,
306, 25, 38, 42, &c.) must be regarded largely in the same light;
for this delight in soft garments, precious gems, games, and
festivities was, if we can judge aright, in no sense “enervating
pleasure and voluptuous indulgence”: for he was indefatigable in
studies and works of all sorts, although it is perhaps to be referred
to the vanity and love of display of which he is accused, and of which
more later.
(b)
In relations with
people.
In general he was
Amiable,
—popular with the
soldiers, popular even with his subdued enemies (Eutrop. 10. 7).
Diocletian reminded Galerius (Lact. c. 18) that he was
“amiable,” and he must have been so; for he was
“loved by soldiers” (Eumen. c. 16), and so “endeared
to the troops” that in the appointment of Cæsar he was
“the choice of every individual” (Lact. c. 18). This
popularity he indeed “sought by every kind of liberality and
obligingness” (Eutr. 10. 7.), but what he sought he
found.
A very large element in this
popularity was the universal
Mildness, Mercifulness,
and
Forbearance
which he showed. In these is found a class of
characteristics which stand alongside his energy of character as
peculiarly characteristic and great. “He whose familiar habit it
was to save men’s lives” (
V. C.
4. 6), as a young
man promised, in the opinion of Diocletian
(Lact. c. 18), to be
“milder and more merciful than his father.” Even in the
opinion of Julian he was “far more humane (
πραότερον
), and in very many other respects superior to others, as I
would demonstrate if there were opportunity” (Julian,
Orat.
p. 15); and he again (p. 96) speaks of him in laudatory
terms as contrasted with the other emperors. Eusebius, as might be
expected, is still stronger in expression, and sets Constantine
“in contrast with tyrants who were stained with blood of
countless numbers,” saying that in Constantine’s reign
“the sword of justice lay idle,” and men were “rather
constrained by a paternal authority than governed by the stringent
power of the laws” (
V. C.
3. 1). This mercifulness he
manifested on every occasion. “When Sigusium was on fire,”
he directed greater effort towards saving it than he had to capturing
it (Naz.
Paneg.
c. 21). At the taking of Rome he punished a
certain few only of those most intimate with Maxentius (Zos.), and even
Zosimus notes the great joy and relief of people at the exchange of
Constantine for Maxentius. It is noticeable that in the inscriptions
the epithet “clementissimus,” most rare of other emperors,
is found a considerable number of times of him. So great was this
mildness of conduct that he was “generally blamed for his
clemency” (
V. C.
4. 31), on the ground that crimes were
not visited with their proper penalties. The testimony to this
humaneness of character is almost unlimited and conclusive, but there
is more or less evidence which is urged in qualification or
contradiction. It is rather a common thing to say that he was at first
mild, but later pride of prosperity caused him greatly to depart from
this former agreeable mildness of temper (Eutrop.). Then the execution
of the various members of his own family (cf. discussion below), the
exposure of prisoners to the wild beasts (Eumen.
Paneg.
c. 12),
his severe decree against those who should conceal copies of the works
of Arius (Socr. 1. 9), his treatment of the Jews (Greg. Niceph., or at
least his laws), and the severe penalties of some of his laws are among
the points brought against him. But the remark of Eutropius is to be
interpreted by the “former agreeable mildness of temper,”
to which he himself witnesses, and the fact that this latter period was
that where the points of view of the two men had widely diverged. The
exposure of prisoners to wild beasts was no evidence of cruelty in
itself; for under the customs then prevailing it might have been
cruelty to his subjects not to have done this, and his treatment of the
barbarian enemies is rather to be interpreted in the light of the
testimony of Eutropius that he “left on the minds of the
barbarians [Goths] a strong remembrance of his kindness” (10. 7).
His treatment of his family is discussed elsewhere, but whatever its
bearings may be, there is no just historico-psychological ground
whatever for the use of the word which is so freely
bandied,—cruelty. Cruel he was not in any sense. Even the extreme
of the Panegyrist who says to him, “you are such by inheritance
and destiny that you cannot be cruel” (Eumen.
Paneg.
c.
14), is nearer the truth. The penalties of his laws lay him open in a
degree to a charge of growing severity; but it was great, if sometimes
mistaken and overzealous, regard for what he deemed the public welfare,
and on quite a different plane from anything which we express as
cruelty. Though with the growing conservatism of a man who finds his
purposes of mercy continually perverted and his indulgences abused, he
yet remained to the end of his life most merciful and mild compared
with those who went before and who followed.
This fact becomes more clear in
seeing how he excelled in kindred virtues. The
Patience
already
mentioned, distinguished forbearance, and undoubted benevolence, or at
least generosity, are traits which group with mercy and have no
fellowship with cruelty. And these he had. He showed distinguished
Forbearance,
and that oftentimes, as in a disturbance at
Antioch, where he “applied with much forbearance the remedy of
persuasion” (
V. C.
3. 59). The outrageous conduct of those
who, in the Arian disturbances, dared “even to insult the statues
of the emperor…had little power to excite his anger, but rather
caused in him sorrow of spirit” (
V. C.
3. 4), “and
he endured with patience men who were exasperated against
himself.” These words are by Eusebius, to be sure; but his
conduct with Donatists, Arians, Maximinianus, and Licinius, in
individual and on the whole, show that in fact he did habitually
exercise great forbearance. To this was added much activity of positive
Kindness.
On first accession he “visited with much
considerate
kindness all those provinces” (
V. C.
p. 23). This kindness
was shown throughout his reign, and brightly illustrated in his
treatment of the persecuted Christians from the beginning,—in his
acts in Gaul, in his famous toleration edict, in his letter to Maximin,
and in his acts throughout. After his victory over Maxentius came the
edict that those wrongfully deprived of their estates should be
permitted to enjoy them again,…unjustly exiled were recalled and
freed from imprisonment (Euseb.
V. C.
1. 41). After the victory
over Licinius he recalled Christian exiles, ordered restitution of
property, released from labor in mines, from the solitude of islands,
from toil in public works, &c., those who had been oppressed in
these ways (
V. C.
p. 70–71). There is strong concensus of
testimony to a very lovable habitual exercise of this trait in his
“readiness to grant hearing,” “patience in
listening,” and “kindness of response” to those whose
complaints he had patiently listened to (Naz. 24). He was most
excellent (
commodissimus
) to hear embassies and complaints of
provinces (Vict.
Epit.
p. 51),—a testimony which is borne
out by the facts. His
Generosity
is equally undoubted. His
magnificent gifts and largesses to the army were still remembered in
the time of Julian (
Orat.
p. 13). His constant and lavish giving
to the Christians is Eusebius’ unending theme: but it was not to
the churches alone; for we read of his munificence to heathen tribes
(
V. C.
2. 22), his liberality to the poor (
V. C.
1. 43)
in giving money for clothing, provision for orphans and widows,
marriage portions for virgins, compensation to losers in law suits
(
V. C.
4. 4). It was “scarcely possible to be near him
without benefit” (
V. C.
1. 43; cf.
V. C.
3. 16; 3.
22; 4. 44).
Though slow to serve some
friends through suspicion (i.e.
dubius
thus explained), he was
“exceedingly generous towards others, neglecting no opportunity
to add to their riches and honors” (Eutrop. 10. 7). “With
royal magnificence he unlocked all his treasures and distributed his
gifts with rich and high-souled liberality” (
V. C.
3. 1).
He seems to have carried it rather to excess, even on the showing of
Eusebius. “No one could request a favor of the emperor, and fail
of obtaining what he sought.…He devised new dignities, that he
might invest a larger number with the tokens of his favor” (
V.
C.
4. 2). It is worth giving the account by Eusebius of this
conduct in full here. He says (
V. C.
4. 54) that this “was
a virtue, however, which subjected him to censure from many, in
consequence of the baseness of wicked men, who ascribed their own
crimes to the emperor’s forbearance. In truth, I can myself bear
testimony to the grievous evils which prevailed during those times: I
mean the violence of rapacious and unprincipled men, who preyed on all
classes of society alike, and the scandalous hypocrisy of those who
crept into the church.…His own benevolence and goodness of heart,
the genuineness of his own faith, and his truthfulness of character
induced the emperor to credit the professions of those reputed
Christians who craftily preserved the semblance of sincere affection
for his person. The confidence he reposed in such men sometimes forced
him into conduct
unworthy of himself,
of which envy took
advantage to cloud in this respect the luster of his character.”
There seems, therefore, some ground for the charge of
Prodigality,
that he “wasted public money in many useless
buildings, some of which he shortly after destroyed because they were
not built to stand” (Zos.), and (Zos. p. 104) “gave great
largesses to ill-deserving persons, mistaking profusion for
munificence” (
τὴν γὰρ
ἀσωτίαν
ἡγεῖτο
φιλοτιμίαν
). Zosimus adds that to do this, he “imposed severe
taxes on all, so severe that fathers were obliged to prostitute their
daughters to raise the money, that tortures were employed, and in
consequence whole villages depopulated.” This testimony is,
however, by one bitterly prejudiced, who regarded money spent on
Christian houses of worship as worse than wasted, and indicates only
what appears from Eusebius as well, that expenditures for cities,
schools, and churches built, and for other matters, must have been
enormous. But so, too, they were enormous under other emperors, and
Constantine, at least, instead of spending on debauchery, seems to have
had something to show for it. As to taxes, Zosimus would undoubtedly
sympathize with the Kentucky moonshiners in their
“oppression” by revenue officers, if he were here now and
Constantine were President, and would fulminate in the daily papers
against the wicked party which by its wicked tariff compels men to
marry
their
daughters to rich husbands in order to get their taxes paid,—and
incidental luxuries supplied. But that does not say that an exorbitant
tariff, to supply “jobs” which shall furnish rich
“spoils” for those who have “pulls” out of the
pockets of the many, is good; yet this, in modern phrase, is about what
Constantine did. Constantine’s trust in his friends and
generosity to the unworthy, with its consequences on the tax-payers,
reminds strikingly of some of our own soldier-presidents, whom we love
and admire without approving all their acts. And yet, on the other
hand, much of the expenditure was for solid improvement, and could only
be criticised by those who now oppose expenditures for navy, for
improved postal service, public buildings, subsidies, &c.; though
yet, again, his wholesale way of doing things also reminds one of the
large generosity of some modern politicians in their race for
popularity, with their Pension, Education, River and Harbor, and what
not liberalities out of the pockets of the people. But whatever
unwisdom may have been mingled, all this profusion shows in him a
generosity of character which was at least amiable, and in the main
genuine. His generosity took also the form of
Hospitality,
as
shown by his entertainings at the Council of Nicæa (
V. C.
4. 49). With all these qualities of amiable popularity there seems to
have been joined a yet more fundamental element, of permanent influence
among men, in a spirit of
Justice
so marked that the claim of
the Panegyrist is hardly too sweeping when he says that “all who
took refuge with him for whatever cause he treated justly and
liberally” (Paneg. 307. 5)—if there is added “up to
his light and ability.” Closely linked with this again is that
“Unbending righteousness” of which Theophanes (p. 29)
speaks. And to all these qualities was added that synthesis of
qualities,—a remarkable
Tact
in his intercourse with men,
a trait typically exemplified in his conduct at the Council of
Nicæa, where “the emperor gave patient audience to all
alike, and reviewed every proposition with steadfast attention, and by
occasionally assisting the arguments of each party in turn, he
gradually disposed even the most vehement disputants to a
reconciliation,…persuading some, convincing others by his
reasonings, praising those who spoke well, and urging all to unity of
sentiment, until at last he succeeded in bringing them to one mind and
judgment respecting every disputed question” (
V. C.
3.
13).
But success with men and
popularity seem to have opened that pitfall of
success,—
Vanity,
—and it is charged that he fell
thereinto, although there is testimony to the exact contrary. According
to Victor (
Epit.
p. 51) he was “immeasurably greedy of
praise.” This agrees with, and is at the same time modified by
Eutropius’ testimony to his ambition for glory and for honorable
popularity (10. 7), and his apparently complacent reception of the
outrageous flattery of Optatian (cf. his letter), seems at least to
show some weakness in this direction. So again his tendency toward
Magnificence,
as shown in his assuming the diadem and his dress
in general (cf. above), in the splendor of banquets as witnessed by his
approving friend (
V. C.
3. 15), his desire to do on a large
scale whatever he did, whether in the building of cities or splendid
houses of worship, or in book-binding ornamentations of pearls and
gems. And yet again it is shown in what seems at this distance his
Conceit,
sublime in its unconsciousness in reckoning himself a
sort of thirteenth, but, it would seem, a facile princeps apostle, in
the disposition for his burial, “anticipating with extraordinary
fervor of faith that his body would share their title with the apostles
themselves.…He accordingly caused twelve coffins to be set up in
this church, like sacred pillars, in honor and memory of the apostolic
number, in the centre of which his own was placed, having six of theirs
on either side of it” (
V. C.
4. 60). One can seem to read
in this a whole history of unblushing flattery, and it reminds that
Eunapius (
Vic. ædes.
p. 41) has spoken of his pleasure in
the stimulant of “intoxicating flattery.” Still it is not
to be supposed that this was a peculiarly weak vanity or an absorbing
one. The testimony to his
Modesty
(
V. C.
3. 10), though
by Eusebius, is too circumstantial to be wholly unreal, and the
testimony to his Humility in his “indignation at excessive
praise” (
V. C.
4. 48), and the records of Eusebius that he
“was not rendered arrogant by these plaudits nor uplifted by the
praises” (Euseb.
V. C.
1. 39), and of the Chronicon
Paschale (p. 521) that “he was not at all puffed up by the
acclamations,” evidently represent a
genuine thing. This mixed
character is too frequently met with to be incomprehensible. Real
power, recognizing its own success, glad of the recognition of others,
not at bottom because of cold vanity, but from warm appreciation of
human friendliness, became through success in carrying out what seemed
to him, and were, divine plans, fired with the thought that he was the
especial and necessary minister of God, that his thoughts and will were
directly touched by the Divine Will and thus that whatever he thought
or willed was infallible. He is not unlike some modern rulers. The
spirit, though one of real vanity, or egotism at least, has an element
of nobleness in it, and in most of its manifestations commands respect
along with the smile. The accusation of Zosimus of
Arrogance
“when he had attained to the sole authority,” and that he
“gave himself up to the unrestrained exercise of his
power,” must be interpreted like those of other un-Christian
witnesses, in the light of the fact that his actions worked relative
hardships to the non-Christians, and that very justice to the
Christians would seem injustice to them, and if Constantine was more
than just, his generosity was at some one’s expense. His energy
of execution and constant success, with his dominating idea of a Divine
mission, would naturally engender this faith in his own infallibility;
for what is arrogance but this vanity joined with power? His action
toward schismatics—Donatists, Arians, or orthodox troublers of
his peace—was such as to suggest some degree of this vice. Yet
his success in keeping the followers of the old religion fairly
mollified, and his generally successful tact, showed that this was in
no sense a dominating and unrelieved characteristic. Two other
weaknesses closely allied with these are also imputed to Constantine:
Jealousy,
as illustrated by the statement that “wishing to
minimize the deeds of his predecessors, he took pains to tarnish their
virtues by giving them jocose epithets” (Dion. Cont. 2
[Müller, p. 199]; cf. Vict.
Epit.
p. 51), and
Suspiciousness
(Eutrop. 10. 7); for which latter, a man who had
survived as many plots as he had, might well be excused. Again and
again and again he trusted men, and they deceived him. His conduct with
Maximian shows that at least in the beginning, before he had had so
much experience of untrustworthiness, he was remarkably free from this.
A much more serious charge is that of
Faithlessness
preferred by
Zosimus, who says (2. 28), “in violation of his oaths (for this
was customary with him)” and twice repeats the charge. Eusebius,
on the other hand, tells what great pains Constantine took not to be
the one to break peace with Licinius (
V. C.
). One is worth as
little as the other. The charge seems to rest mainly or wholly on his
conduct towards Licinius, in beginning war and in putting him to death.
A small boy once held a smaller boy in a firm grip, but agreed to spare
him the cuffing he deserved because he was smaller. The smaller small
boy promptly set his teeth in the leg of the larger small boy, and was
properly cuffed for it. Thereupon the smaller small boy’s big
brother was filled with indignation, which he manifested by seeking and
finding the same fate. The indignation in behalf of Licinius seems to
be in large measure big brother indignation—indignation with the
wrong party. He appears to have been one of those who held a compact to
be binding on the other party only. It wasn’t in the bargain that
he should persecute the Christians, or in the other bargain that he
should plot his benefactor’s overthrow. That king in Scripture
who took back his promise to forgive a debt of ten thousand talents was
not faithless.
(c)
In relations with his
family.
He was a filial
Son,
having the confidence of his
father, as shown in his wish of succession, and showing his mother all
honors when he came to power (cf. coins showing her position as
empress, and
V.C.
). “And well may his character be styled
blessed for his filial piety as well as on other grounds” (
V.
C.
3. 47).
It is in this relation to his
family, however, that the most serious attacks on the character of
Constantine have been made. Eutropius says: “But the pride of
prosperity caused Constantine greatly to depart from his former
agreeable mildness of temper. Falling first upon his own relatives, he
put to death his son, an excellent man; his sister’s son, a youth
of amiable disposition; soon afterwards his wife; and subsequently many
of his friends.” This has been a battle-ground of accusation or
excusation in all the centuries. The testimony is very meagre and
uncertain, but this much may be said: 1. That any jury would regard the
fact of deaths as evidenced. It is
witnessed by Eutrop. (10. 6),
Zos., Vict., Hieron., &c. 2. That he was unjustifiable is not
proven. In respect to the death of Fausta, at least, there was probably
just cause; whether love intrigue or other intrigue, there seems to
have been some real occasion. The death of Crispus, too, was from no
mere suspicions, but on apparently definite grounds of distrust. It is
historical assumption to say that he had no good grounds, whatever
these may have been—illicit relationship with Fausta or more
probably political intrigue. At the worst, he was put to death on false
but, at the time, apparently true accusation: what has been done by
judges and juries of the best intention.
3041
Of Licinius, his sister’s son, it can hardly be said that he had
the same reason, as he was still a boy. But remembering the inherited
character of Licinius, and noticing the curious fact that the
cordiality between Constantia and Constantine was peculiarly great to
the end, it seems as if there must have been some mitigating
circumstance.
3042
In all
historical candor it looks as if there had been some general intrigue
against Constantine which had been met in this way; but the fairest
verdict to enter is “causes unknown.”
In estimating the characteristic
value of the acts it must be noted, 1. That it has in no sense the
character of private execution. The emperor was judge. Even if he
mistook evidence and put to death an innocent man, it was as when a
judge does the same. 2. That the relative moral character of
punishments inflicted is conditioned by the custom of punishment. An
English judge of the past was not as cruel in hanging a man for theft,
as a modern one in applying the extreme penalty of the law to an
offense with mitigating circumstances, would be. 3. That all law of
evidence, all rhyme and reason, says that any man’s any act is to
be interpreted in the light of his
general character.
Where
evidence is lacking or doubtful, such evidence of general character has
actual weight, and may be conclusive. In application to these acts note
(
a
) The peculiar forbearance which Constantine exercised toward
Maximian. (
b
) The conclusive universal testimony to the general
mildness of his character and his habitual mercifulness. In view of
this, it is to be judged that there was some real, or appearing, great
ground of judicial wrath. 4. That Constantine had suffered from plots
on the part of his own relatives over and over again, and spared, and
been plotted against again, as in the cases of Maximian, Bassianus, and
Licinius. 5. That they were not put to death “in a gust of
passion” at once, but in successive acts. In view of these things
it is fair and just to say that they were put to death on grounds which
seemed just and for the welfare of society, and their deaths in no
sense indicate cruelty or unnaturalness on the part of Constantine.
Even the death of Licinius must be interpreted by the political ethics
of the times and its circumstances. So long as sentimentalists continue
to send bouquets to murderers and erect monuments to anarchists, they
will regard execution, even legal execution, as
prima facie
evidence of cruelty, and the killing of a murderer in self-defense, or
the hanging of a traitor, as crime. Constantine’s whole character
ensures that if he thought he could have spared them, or any one, with
safety, he would have done so.
3043
In general he was a faithful
husband
as respects marital virtue, and a good
father.
He
took care that his children should be well educated. Crispus was under
Lactantius (Hieron.), and the others perhaps under Arborius
(“Auson. de Prof. Burdig. 16”); at all events, he had the
most accomplished teachers of secular learning to instruct in the art
of war, and in political and legal science (
V. C.
4. 51), and
both by his own instruction and that of men of approved piety, took
special pains with their religious training. He early appointed them to
offices of authority, and distributed the empire among them.
(d)
In relations with friends.
His general conduct toward
his friends was marked by very great liberality (cf. above). Eutropius
speaks emphatically of this even while he uses the expression which has
been such a puzzle to all, that “toward some of his friends he
was double” (or dangerous), a phrase which is interpreted by
Johannes Ant. as meaning “to some of friends false
(unsound,
ὑπούλως
) and unsafe (unwholesome,
οὐχ ὑγιῶς
)” (ed. Müller 4. p. 602–3). His uniform
effort to please his friends has been discussed above.
(e)
In relations with
society.
1. As
General
he seems to have been popular with
his own soldiers (cf. above), inspiring them with enthusiasm and
energy. Toward hostile soldiers he was merciful (cf. above), not
following up an advantage further than was necessary, and toward
conquered enemies unusually forbearing; e.g. at Sigusium, at Rome, with
Maximian, with Licinius, and with the Goths (cf. above). His
generalship is characterized by careful provision for the guarding of
his rear, and by rapidity of movement and dash in actual conflict. 2.
As
Legislator
he “enacted many laws, some good, but most
of them superfluous, and some severe” (Eutrop. 10. 8). He seems
to have had a weakness for law-making which, at all events, shows a
characteristic respect for law little shared by his early
contemporaries. Of course Eutropius would consider all laws in favor of
Christians superfluous. Laws for the abolition of idolatrous practices,
for the erection of Christian houses of worship, observance of the
Lord’s Day (
V. C.
4. 23), permitting cases to be tried
before bishops (Soz. 1. 9; Euseb.
H. E.
10. 7; Cod. Theod. Tit.
de episc. 2) &c., would surely seem so. But even in other laws
Constantine seems to have had at times an abnormal zeal for law-making,
when his energies were not occupied in war or church-building. The laws
were generally wise and, at the least, benevolently or righteously
meant. Such were the abolition of crucifixion (Vict.
Cæs.
)
and of gladiatorial shows (
V. C.
4. 25; Socr. 1. 8; C. Theod.
15. 12. 1), the law that the families of slaves were not to be
separated (C. Theod. 2.25), that forbidding the scourging of debtors
(C. Theod. 7. 3), and that repressing calumny (Vict.
Epit.
51).
Among the “severe” laws were such as punished certain forms
of illicit intercourse with death. 3. As
Statesman
his policy
was broad and far-reaching. He fully organized and carefully
established one section of his territory before he enlarged. He changed
the whole constitution of the empire, both civil and military (cf.
Wordsworth, in Smith & W.). He inaugurated reforms in finance, and
especially was most assiduous in the matter of internal improvements,
restoring and building from one end of the empire to the other. The
great characteristic consummation of his reign was the union of Church
and State, over which men are still divided as to whether it was a
tremendous blessing or a tremendous curse. Tremendous it surely was in
its shaping power on world history. (Compare numerous titles under
Literature.
) The general statement of Eutropius that “in
the beginning of his reign he might have been compared to the best
princes, in the latter part only to those of a middling
character,” must be interpreted by the fact that during the
latter part of his reign he was so associated with Christianity, in
itself a falling away in the eyes of the old religionists. His reign
was one of order and justice such as few were, and an order out of
chaos, a reign in which it could be peculiarly said that
“chastity was safe and marriage protected” (Naz. c. 38),
where a man’s life and property were secure as under few of the
Roman emperors. It is idle to refuse the title of Great to a man who,
from the beginning, followed a consistent, though developing policy,
organized the interior, and securely guarded the frontier of his empire
at each enlargement, and finally unified the whole on such a basis as
to secure large internal prosperity and development.
3041
It
is hardly necessary to say that the various tales of the remorse of
Constantine for the death of Crispus are mythical. The tale of Sopater
has been mentioned. That of Codinus (
De signo Cp.
p.
62–63), also that, “in regret for death of Crispus, he
erected a statue of pure silver with the inscription, ‘My
unjustly treated son,’ and did penance besides,” falls into
the same category.
3042
Seeck (
Ztschr. f. wiss. Theol.
1890, p. 73) maintains that
it is established (“urkundlich fest”) that Licinius was
still living in 336, in which case he would have been more than twenty
years old. He maintains also that he was not the son of Constantine,
but the illegitimate son of Licinius by a slave woman.
3043
On this question compare especially monographs of Görres and
Seeck. See under
Literature,
where other titles, e.g. Hug and
Wegnerus, will also be found. In general, the remark of Ludermann
(Lipsius,
Theol. Jahrb.
1886, p. 108) is valid, “The
arguments against Constantine’s Christianity, which are drawn
from his moral character, have ever been the weakest.”