MINUCIUS FELIX. 467
accordingto your sectto believethatmen will,not of then-
own accord,but as electedto will. Therefore you feign an
iniquitousjudge,who punishesin men, not theirwill,but
theirdestiny. Yet I should be glad to be informed whether
or no you riseagainwith bodies;1 and ifso,with what bodies
— whether with the same or with renewed bodies? Without
a body ? Then, as faras I know, therewillneitherbe mind,
nor soul,nor life.With the same body? But this has
already been previouslydestroyed. With another body?
Then it is a new man who is born,not the former one re
stored; and yet so long a time has passedaway, innumerable
ages have flowedby, and what singleindividualhas returned
from the dead eitherby the fateof Protesilaus,with permis
sionto sojourneven fora few hours,or thatwe might believe
itfor an example ? All such figmentsof an unhealthybelief,
and vain sourcesof comfort,with which deceivingpoetshave
trifledin the sweetnessof theirverse,have been disgracefully
remoulded by you, believingundoubtingly1 on your God.
CHAPTER XII.
Argument. — Moreover,what willhappen to the Christians
themselvesafterdeath,may be anticipatedfrom thefact
thateven now they are destituteof all means, and are
afflictedwiththeheaviestcalamitiesand miseries.
" Neither do you at leasttake experiencefrom thingspre
sent,how the fruitlessexpectationsof vain promise deceive
you. Consider,wretched creatures,[from your lot]while
you are yet living,what is threateningyou afterdeath.3
Behold, a portionof you— and,as you declare,the largerand
better portion— are in want, are cold,are labouringin hard
work and hunger; and God suffersit,He feigns;He either
1 Otherwise," withouta bodyorwith."
2 Otherwise," toocredulous."
8 Otherwise,"whileyou consider,whileyou are yet alive,poor
-wretches,whatisthreateningafterdeath."