AGAINST JOVINIANUS.— BOOK II. 407
we may reach the haven, be crowned, and tri-
umph. But you, with no less adroitness than
perversity, make the life of this world illustrate
that of the world to come, although we know
full well that here unrighteousness prevails,
there, righteousness : l " until we go into the sanctuary of God, and understand the end of
those men." The saint does not die one way, the sinner another. Those who sail the same
sea have the same calm and storm. A violent
death is not one thing to the robber, another
to the martyr. Children are not born one
way of adultery and prostitution, in another of
pure marriage. Certainly our Lord and the
robbers incurred the same penalty of crucifix-
ion. If the judgment of this world and of that
which is to come be the same, it follows that
they who were here crucified side by side, will
also be esteemed of equal rank hereafter.
Paul and they who bound him, sailed together,
endured the same storm, escaped together to
the shore when the ship was broken with the
waves. You cannot deny that the prisoner
and the keepers were of unequal merit. And what were the circumstances of that same
shipwreck of the Apostle and the soldiers ?
The Apostle Paul afterwards3 related a vision, and said that they who were with him in the
ship had been given to him by the Lord. Are
we to suppose that he to whom they were
given, and they who were given to him, were
of one degree of merit? Ten righteous men
can save a sinful city. Lot together with his
daughters was delivered from the fire: his
sons-in-law would also have been saved, had
they been willing to leave the city. Now there
was surely a great difference between Lot and
his sons-in-law. One city out of the five,
:i Zoar, was saved, and a place which lay under the same sentence as Sodom, Gomorrha, Ad-
niah, and /eboiim, was preserved by the
prayers of a holy man. Lot and /ioar were of
different merit, but both of them escaped the
fire. * The robbers who in the absence of
David had laid waste Ziklag, and made a prey of the wives and children of the inhabitants
were slain on the third day in the plain, but
forty men mounted on camels fled. Will you
maintain that there was some difference be-
tween those who were slain and those who
made good their escape ? We read in the
6 Gospel that the tower of Siloam fell upon eighteen men who perished in the ruins. Cer-
tainly our Saviour did not regard them as the
only sinners : but they were punished to ter-
rify the rest : it was like scourging a pestilent fellow to teach fools wisdom. If all sinners
1 Ps. Ixxiii. 17. See Acts xxvii. 23 and the context.
are punished 'alike, it is unjust for one to be slain while another is admonished by his com-
rade's death.
25. You raise the objection that all Israel- ites had the same measure of manna, an homer,
and were alike in respect of dress, and hair,
and beard, and shoes ; as though we did not
all alike partake of the body of Christ. In
the Christian mysteries there is one means of
sanctification for the master and the servant,
the noble and the low-born, for the king and
his soldiers, and yet, that which is one varies
according to the merits of those who receive
it. ' " Whosoever shall eat or drink unwor-
thily shall be guilty of the body and blood of
the Lord." Does it follow that because Judas drank of the same cup as the rest of the
apostles, that he and they are of equal merit ?
But suppose that we do not choose to receive
the sacrament, at all events we all have the
same life, breathe the same air, have the same
blood in our veins, are fed on the same food.
Moreover, if our viands are improved by cu-
linary skill and are made more palatable for
the consumer, food of this kind does not
satisfy nature, but tickles the appetite. We
are all alike subject to hunger, all alike suffer with cold : we alike are shrivelled with the
frost, or melted with the broiling heat. The
sun and the moon, and all the company of the
I stars, the showers, the whole world run their
| course for us all alike, and, as the Gospel tells
' us, the same refreshing rain falls upon all,
good and bad, just and unjust. If the pres- ent is a picture of the future, then the Sun of
i Righteousness will rise upon sinners as well
as upon the righteous, upon the wicked and
i the holy, upon the heathen as well as upon
I Jews and Christians, though the Scripture
says, 3 " Unto you that fear the Lord shall the
Sun of Righteousness arise." If He will rise to those that fear, He will set to the despisers
and the false prophets. The sheep which
stand on the right hand will be brought into
the kingdom of heaven, the goats will be
thrust down to hell. The parable does not
contrast the sheep one with another, or on
the other hand the goats, but merely makes
a difference between sheep and goats. The
whole truth is not taught in a single passage :
we must "always bear in mind the exact point of an illustration. For instance, the ten vir-
gins are not examples of the whole human
race, but of the careful and the slothful : the
former are ever anticipating the advent of
our Lord, the latter abandon themselves to
idle slumber without a thought of future
judgment. And so at the end of the par-
able it is said, ' " Watch, for ye know not the
1 Gen. xix. 18-21.
* S. Lukexiii. 4.
4 i Sam. xxx. t sq. 1 i Cor. xi. 27. 8 S. Malt. xxv. 13. Mai. iv. 2.