fault. He says, in the forementioned treatise, (p. 14.) Who can blame a person for doing what
he could not help? And, (p. 15.) It being sensibly unjust, to punish any man for doing that
which was never in his power to avoid. And, (p. 341.) to confirm his opinion, he quotes one
of the fathers, saying, Why doth God command, if man hath not free will and power to obey?
And again, in the same and the next page, Who will not cry out, that it is folly to command
him, that hath not liberty to do what is commanded; and that it is unjust to condemn him,
that has it not in his power to do what is required? And, (p. 373.) he cites another saying, A
law is given to him that can turn to both parts; i.e. obey or transgress it; but no law can be
against him who is bound by nature.
And yet the same Dr. Whitby asserts, that fallen man is not able to perform perfect
obedience. In p. 165, he has these words: “The nature of Adam had power to continue inno-
cent, and without sin; whereas, it is certain our nature never had.” But if we have not power
to continue innocent and without sin, then sin is not inconsistent with Necessity, and we
may be sinful in that which we have not power to avoid; and those things cannot be true,
which he asserts elsewhere, namely, “That if we be necessitated, neither sins of omission
nor commission, would deserve that name,” (p. 348.) If we have it not in our power to be
innocent, then we have it not in our power to be blameless; and if so, we are under a Necessity
of being blameworthy. And how does this consist with what he so often asserts, that Necessity
is inconsistent with blame or praise? If we have it not in our power to perform perfect
obedience to all the commands of God, then we are under a Necessity of breaking some
commands, in some degree; having no power to perform so much as is commanded. And
if so, why does he cry out of the unreasonableness and folly of commanding beyond what
men have power to do?
Arminians in general are very inconsistent with themselves, in what they say of the In-
ability of fallen man in this respect. They strenuously maintain, that it would be unjust in
God, to require any thing of us beyond our present power and ability to perform; and also
hold that we are now unable to perform perfect obedience, and that Christ died to satisfy
for the imperfections of our obedience, and has made way, that our imperfect obedience
might be accepted instead of perfect; wherein they seem insensibly to run themselves into
the grossest inconsistence. For (as I have observed elsewhere) “they hold that God, in mercy
to mankind, has abolished that rigorous constitution or law, that they were under originally,
and instead of it, has introduced a more mild constitution, and put us under a new law,
which requires no more than imperfect sincere obedience, in compliance with our poor
infirm impotent circumstances since the fall.”
Now how can these things be made consistent? I would ask, of what law are these im-
perfections of our obedience a breach? If they are a breach of no law that we were ever under,
then they are not sins. And if they be not sins, what need of Christ dying to satisfy for them?
But if they are sins, and the breach of some law, what law is it? They cannot be a breach of
640
SECTION III. The case of such as are given up of God to sin, and of fallen…