not be judged.34 He revised in chronological order the numerous works he had written before
and during his episcopate, and retracted or corrected whatever in them seemed to his riper
knowledge false or obscure, or not fully agreed with the orthodox catholic faith. Some of
his changes were reactionary and no improvements, especially those on the freedom of the
will, and on religious toleration. In all essential points, nevertheless, his theological system
remained the same from his conversion to this time. The Retractationsgive beautiful evidence
of his love of truth, his conscientiousness, and his humility.35
To this same class should be added the Letters of Augustin, of which the Benedictine
editors, in their second volume, give two hundred and seventy (including letters to Augustin)
in chronological order from A.D. 386 to A.D. 429. These letters treat, sometimes very
13
minutely, of all the important questions of his time, and give us an insight of his cares, his
official fidelity, his large heart, and his effort to become, like Paul, all things to all men.
When the questions of friends and pupils accumulated, he answered them in special
works; and in this way he produced various collections of Quæstiones and Responsiones,
dogmatical, exegetical, and miscellaneous (A.D. 390, 397, &c.).
II. Philosophical treatises, in dialogue; almost all composed in his earlier life; either
during his residence on the country-seat Cassiciacum in the vicinity of Milan, where he
spent half a year before his baptism in instructive and stimulating conversation, in a sort of
academy or Christian Platonic banquet with Monnica, his son Adeodatus, his brother
Navigius, his friend Alypius, and some cousins and pupils; or during his second residence
in Rome; or soon after his return to Africa.36
To this class belong the works; Contra Academicos libri très (386), in which he combats
the skepticism and probabilism of the New Academy,—the doctrine that man can never
reach the truth, but can at best attain only probability; De vita beata (386), in which he
makes true blessedness to consist in the perfect knowledge of God; De ordine,—on the relation
34 1 Cor. xi. 31. Comp. his Prologus to the two books of Retractationes.
35 J. Morell Mackenzie (in W Smith’s Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology, vol. i. p.
422) happily calls the Retractations of Augustin “one of the noblest sacrifices ever laid upon the altar of truth
by a majestic intellect acting in obedience to the purest conscientiousness.”
36 In tom. i. of the ed. Bened., immediately after the Retractationes and Confessiones, and at the close of the
volume. On these philosophical writings, see Brucker: Historia critica philosophiæ, Lips. 1766, tom. iii. pp.
485–507: H Ritter: Geschichte der Philosphie, vol. vi. p. 153 sqq.; Ueberweg, History of Philosophy, I. 333–346
(Am. ed.): Erdmann, Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie, I. 231–240; Bindemann, l. c. I. 282 sqq. Huber,
l. c. I. 242 sqq.; Gangauf, l. c. p. 25 sqq., and Nouerisson, l. c. ch. i. and ii. Nourrisson makes the just remark (i.
p. 53): “Si la philosophie est la recherché de la verité, jamais sans douse il ne s’est rencontre une ame plus philosophe
que celle de saint Augustin. Car jamais ame n’a supporté avec plus d’ impatience les anxiétés du doute et n’a fait
plus d’ efforts pour dissiper les fantomes de l’erreur.”
29
The Writings of St. Augustin