alongside his energy of character as peculiarly characteristic and great. “He whose familiar
habit it was to save men’s lives” (V. C. 4. 6), as a young man promised, in the opinion of
425
Diocletian (Lact. c. 18), to be “milder and more merciful than his father.” Even in the
opinion of Julian he was “far more humane (πραότερον), and in very many other respects
superior to others, as I would demonstrate if there were opportunity” (Julian, Orat. p. 15);
and he again (p. 96) speaks of him in laudatory terms as contrasted with the other emperors.
Eusebius, as might be expected, is still stronger in expression, and sets Constantine “in
contrast with tyrants who were stained with blood of countless numbers,” saying that in
Constantine’s reign “the sword of justice lay idle,” and men were “rather constrained by a
paternal authority than governed by the stringent power of the laws” (V. C. 3. 1). This
mercifulness he manifested on every occasion. “When Sigusium was on fire,” he directed
greater effort towards saving it than he had to capturing it (Naz. Paneg. c. 21). At the taking
of Rome he punished a certain few only of those most intimate with Maxentius (Zos.), and
even Zosimus notes the great joy and relief of people at the exchange of Constantine for
Maxentius. It is noticeable that in the inscriptions the epithet “clementissimus,” most rare
of other emperors, is found a considerable number of times of him. So great was this mildness
of conduct that he was “generally blamed for his clemency” (V. C. 4. 31), on the ground that
crimes were not visited with their proper penalties. The testimony to this humaneness of
character is almost unlimited and conclusive, but there is more or less evidence which is
urged in qualification or contradiction. It is rather a common thing to say that he was at
first mild, but later pride of prosperity caused him greatly to depart from this former
agreeable mildness of temper (Eutrop.). Then the execution of the various members of his
own family (cf. discussion below), the exposure of prisoners to the wild beasts (Eumen.
Paneg. c. 12), his severe decree against those who should conceal copies of the works of
Arius (Socr. 1. 9), his treatment of the Jews (Greg. Niceph., or at least his laws), and the
severe penalties of some of his laws are among the points brought against him. But the remark
of Eutropius is to be interpreted by the “former agreeable mildness of temper,” to which he
himself witnesses, and the fact that this latter period was that where the points of view of
the two men had widely diverged. The exposure of prisoners to wild beasts was no evidence
of cruelty in itself; for under the customs then prevailing it might have been cruelty to his
subjects not to have done this, and his treatment of the barbarian enemies is rather to be
interpreted in the light of the testimony of Eutropius that he “left on the minds of the bar-
barians [Goths] a strong remembrance of his kindness” (10. 7). His treatment of his family
is discussed elsewhere, but whatever its bearings may be, there is no just historico-psycho-
logical ground whatever for the use of the word which is so freely bandied,—cruelty. Cruel
he was not in any sense. Even the extreme of the Panegyrist who says to him, “you are such
by inheritance and destiny that you cannot be cruel” (Eumen. Paneg. c. 14), is nearer the
truth. The penalties of his laws lay him open in a degree to a charge of growing severity; but
1066
Moral Characteristics.