indeed it was patent to all, whether the persecutions under Macarius1652 fell upon them
while they were within the unity of the Church, or after they had been severed from it by
schism; so that those who wished to see whether they had suffered persecution for righteous-
ness’ sake might turn rather to the prior question, whether they had done rightly in cutting
themselves off from the unity of the whole world. For if they were found in this to have done
wrong, it was manifest that they suffered persecution for unrighteousness’ sake rather than
for righteousness’ sake, and could not therefore be numbered among those of whom it is
said, “Blessed are they which are persecuted for righteousness’ sake.” Thereupon mention
was made of the surrender of the sacred books, a matter about which much more has been
spoken than has ever been proved true. On our side it was said in reply, that their leaders
rather than ours had been traditors; but that if they would not believe the documents with
which we supported this charge, we could not be compelled to accept those which they
brought forward.
287
Chap. III.
5. Having therefore laid aside that question as one on which there was a doubt, I asked
how they could justify their separation of themselves from all other Christians who had
done them no wrong, who throughout the world preserved the order of succession, and
were established in the most ancient churches, but had no knowledge whatever as to who
were traditors in Africa; and who assuredly could not hold communion with others than
those whom they had heard of as occupying the episcopal sees. He answered that the foreign
churches had done them no wrong, up to the time when they had consented to the death
of those who, as he had said, had suffered in the Macarian persecution. Here I might have
said that it was impossible for the innocence of the foreign churches to be affected by the
offence given in the time of Macarius, seeing that it could not be proved that he had done
with their sanction what he did. I preferred, however, to save time by asking whether, sup-
posing that the foreign churches had, through the cruelties of Macarius, lost their innocence
from the time in which they were said to have approved of these, it could even be proved
that up to that time the Donatists had remained in unity with the Eastern churches and
other parts of the world.
6. Thereupon he produced a certain volume, by which he wished to show that a Council
at Sardica had sent a letter to African bishops who belonged to the party of Donatus. When
this was read aloud, I heard the name Donatus among the bishops to whom the writing had
been sent. I therefore insisted upon being told whether this was the Donatus from whom
1652 Macarius was sent in a.d. 348 by the Emperor Constans to Africa, to exhort all to cherish the unity of
the Catholic Church, and at the same time to collect for the relief of the poor. The vehement opposition with
which the Donatists met him led to conflicts and bloodshed, the Donatists claiming the honour of martyrdom
for all of their party who fell in fighting with the imperial soldiers.
649
To Eleusius, Glorius, and the Two Felixes