Book XIX.
Faustus is willing to admit that Christ may have said that He came not to destroy the
law and the prophets, but to fulfill them; but if He did, it was to pacify the Jews and in a
modified sense. Augustin replies, and still further elaborates the Catholic view of prophecy
and its fulfillment.
1. Faustus said: I will grant that Christ said that he came not to destroy the law and the
prophets, but to fulfill them. But why did Jesus say this? Was it to pacify the Jews, who
were enraged at seeing their sacred institutions trampled upon by Christ, and regarded him
as a wild blasphemer, not to be listened to, much less to be followed? Or was it for our in-
struction as Gentile believers, that we might learn meekly and patiently to bear the yoke of
commandment laid on our necks by the law and the prophets of the Jews? You yourself
can hardly suppose that Christ’s words were intended to bring us under the authority of the
law and the prophets of the Hebrews. So that the other explanation which I have given of
the words must be the true one. Every one knows that the Jews were always ready to attack
Christ, both with words and with actual violence. Naturally, then, they would be enraged
at the idea that Christ was destroying their law and their prophets; and, to appease them,
Christ might very well tell them not to think that he came to destroy the law, but that he
came to fulfill it. There was no falsehood or deceit in this, for he used the word law in a
general sense, not of any particular law.
2. There are three laws. One is that of the Hebrews, which the apostle calls the law of
sin and death.661 The second is that of the Gentiles, which he calls the law of nature. "For
the Gentiles," he says, "do by nature the things contained in the law; and, not having the
law, they are a law into themselves; who show the work of the law written on their hearts."662
The third law is the truth of which the apostle speaks when he says, "The law of the spirit
of life in Christ Jesus hath made me free from the law of sin and death."663 Since, then,
there are three laws, we must carefully inquire which of the three Christ spoke of when He
said that He came not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it. In the same way, there are prophets
of the Jews, and prophets of the Gentiles, and prophets of truth. With the prophets of the
Jews, of course, every one is acquainted. If any one is in doubt about the prophets of the
Gentiles, let him hear what Paul says when writing of the Cretans to Titus: "A prophet of
their own has said, The Cretans are always liars, evil beasts, slow bellies."664 This proves
that the Gentiles also had their prophets. The truth also has its prophets, as we learn from
661 Rom. viii. 2.
662 Rom. ii. 14, 15.
663 Rom. viii. 2.
664 Tit. i. 12.
Faustus is willing to admit that Christ may have said that He came not to destroy the law and the prophets, but to fulfill them; but if He did, it was to pacify the Jews and in a modified sense. Augustin replies, and still further elaborates the Catholic view of prophecy and its fulfillment.
409
Faustus is willing to admit that Christ may have said that He came not to…