for a generation had already grown up that was accustomed to the cultus without images.
An important part was played by the miracles performed by the re-emerging relics and
pictures. But the lower classes had always been really favourable to them; only the army
and the not inconsiderable number of bishops who were of the school of Constantine had
to be carefully handled. Tarasius, the new Patriarch of Constantinople and a supporter of
images, succeeded, after overcoming much difficulty, and especially distrust in Rome and
the East, after also removing the excited army, in bringing together a General Council of
about 350 bishops at Nicæa, a.d. 787, which reversed the decrees of a.d. 754. The proceedings
of the seven sittings are of great value, because very important patristic passages have been
preserved in them which otherwise would have perished; for at this synod also the discussions
turned chiefly on the Fathers. The decision (ὅρος) restored orthodoxy and finally settled
it.
I cannot do better than to cite in conclusion the words of the profoundly learned
Archbishop of Dublin, himself a quasi-Iconoclast.
(Trench. Lect. Medieval Ch. Hist., p. 93.)
It is only fair to state that the most zealous favourers and promoters of this ill-directed
homage always disclaimed with indignation the charge of offering to the images any reverence
which did not differ in kind, and not merely in degree, from the worship which they offered
to Almighty God, designating it as they did by altogether a different name. We shall very
probably feel that in these distinctions which they drew between the one and the other,
between the “honour” which they gave to these icons and the “worship” which they withheld
from these and gave only to God, there lay no slightest justification of that in which they
allowed themselves; but these distinctions acquit them of idolatry, and it is the merest justice
to remember this.
(Trench. Ut supra, p. 99.)
I can close this Lecture with no better or wiser words than those with which Dean Milman
reads to us the lesson of this mournful story: “There was this irremediable weakness in the
cause of iconoclasm; it was a mere negative doctrine, a proscription of those sentiments
which had full possession of the popular mind, without any strong countervailing excitement.
The senses were robbed of their habitual and cherished objects of devotion, but there was
no awakening of an inner life of intense and passionate piety. The cold, naked walls from
whence the Scriptural histories had been effaced, the despoiled shrines, the mutilated images,
could not compel the mind to a more pure and immaterial conception of God and the Sa-
viour. Hatred of images, in the process of the strife, might become, as it did, a fanaticism,
it could never become a religion. Iconoclasm might proscribe idolatry; but it had no power
of kindling a purer faith.”
1019
Excursus on the Conciliabulum Styling Itself the Seventh Ecumenical Council,…