something repulsive and hideous, with the flesh all wasted in the length of years, the skin
dried up about the bones till it is all in wrinkles, the muscles in a spasmodic state from being
no longer enriched with their natural moisture, and the whole body consequently shrunk,
the hands on either side powerless to perform their natural work, shaken with an involuntary
trembling? What a sight again are the bodies of persons in a long consumption! They differ
from bare bones only in giving the appearance of being covered with a worn-out veil of skin.
What a sight too are those of persons swollen with the disease of dropsy! What words could
describe the unsightly disfigurement of sufferers from leprosy1909? Gradually over all their
limbs and organs of sensation rottenness spreads and devours them. What words could
describe that of persons who have been mutilated in earthquake, battle, or by any other
visitation, and live on in such a plight for a long time before their natural deaths? Or of
those who from an injury have grown up from infancy with their limbs awry! What can one
say of them? What is one to think about the bodies of newborn infants who have been either
exposed, or strangled, or died a natural death, if they are to be brought to life again just such
as they were? Are they to continue in that infantine state? What condition could be more
miserable than that? Or are they to come to the flower of their age? Well, but what sort of
milk has Nature got to suckle them again with? It comes then to this: that, if our bodies are
to live again in every respect the same as before, this thing that we are expecting is simply
a calamity; whereas if they are not the same, the person raised up will be another than he
who died. If, for instance, a little boy was buried, but a grown man rises again, or reversely,
how can we say that the dead in his very self is raised up, when he has had some one substi-
tuted for him by virtue of this difference in age? Instead of the child, one sees a grown-up
man. Instead of the old man, one sees a person in his prime. In fact, instead of the one person
another entirely. The cripple is changed into the able-bodied man; the consumptive sufferer
into a man whose flesh is firm; and so on of all possible cases, not to enumerate them for
fear of being prolix. If, then, the body will not come to life again just such in its attributes
as it was when it mingled with the earth, that dead body will not rise again; but on the con-
trary the earth will be formed into another man. How, then, will the Resurrection affect
myself, when instead of me some one else will come to life? Some one else, I say; for how
could I recognize myself when, instead of what was once myself, I see some one not myself?
It cannot really be I, unless it is in every respect the same as myself. Suppose, for instance,
in this life I had in my memory the traits of some one; say he was bald, had prominent lips,
a somewhat flat nose, a fair complexion, grey eyes, white hair, wrinkled skin; and then went
to look for such an one, and met a young man with a fine head of hair, an aquiline nose, a
dark complexion, and in all other respects quite different in his type of countenance; am I
likely in seeing the latter to think of the former? But why dwell longer on these the less forcible
1909 ἱερᾷ νόσῳ. That these words can mean leprosy, as well as epilepsy, seems clear from Eusebius.
859
On the Soul and the Resurrection.