Chapter XI.—The Impostor Theudas and his Followers.
1. Luke, in the Acts, introduces Gamaliel as saying, at the consultation which was held
concerning the apostles, that at the time referred to,347 “rose up Theudas boasting himself
to be somebody; who was slain; and all, as many as obeyed him, were scattered.”348 Let us
therefore add the account of Josephus concerning this man. He records in the work men-
tioned just above, the following circumstances:349
2. “While Fadus was procurator of Judea350 a certain impostor called Theudas351 per-
113
suaded a very great multitude to take their possessions and follow him to the river Jordan.
For he said that he was a prophet, and that the river should be divided at his command, and
afford them an easy passage.
347 κατὰ τὸν δηλούμενον χρόνον, i.e. about the time of Agrippa’s death. But Luke writes πρὸ γὰρ τούτων
τῶν ἡμερῶν, “Before these days.”
348 Acts v. 36.
349 Josephus, Ant. XX. 5. 1.
350 About 44 a.d. See above, chap. 8, note 2.
351 There is a chronological difficulty in connection with this Theudas which has caused much dispute. The
Theudas mentioned by Josephus arose in the time of Claudius; but the Theudas referred to by Gamaliel in the
Acts must have lived many years before that. Various solutions of greater or less plausibility have been offered,
almost any one of which is possible, and abundantly sufficient to account for the alleged discrepancy, though
none can be proved to be true. Compare Wieseler’s Chron. des ap. Zeitalters, p. 138, note 1; Ewald’s Gesch. des
Jüdischen Volkes, Bd. VI. p. 532; Jost’s Gesch. der Israeliten, Bd. II. Anhang, p. 86; and the various commentaries
on the Acts in loco. A question of more importance for us, in the present instance, is as to Eusebius’ conduct in
the case. He identifies the Theudas of Luke with the Theudas of Josephus,—an identification which is impossible,
if both accounts are accepted as trustworthy. Eusebius has consequently been accused of an intentional perversion
of facts for the sake of promoting the credibility of Luke’s accounts. But a protest must again be entered against
such grave imputations upon the honesty of Eusebius. A man with a very small allowance of common sense
would certainly not have been so foolish as consciously to involve himself in such a glaring anachronism—an
anachronism which every reader had the means of exposing—for the sake of making a point in confirmation
of the narrative of Luke. Had he been conscious of the discrepancy, he would certainly have endeavored to re-
concile the two accounts, and it would not have required a great amount of ingenuity or research to discover in
the pages of Josephus himself a sufficiently plausible reconciliation. The only reasonable explanation of Eusebius’
anachronism is his carelessness, which caused him to fall into many blunders as bad as the present, especially
in questions of chronology. He read, in the Acts, of Theudas; he read, in Josephus, of a similar character of the
same name; he identified the two hastily, and without a thought of any chronological difficulty in the case. He
quotes the passage from the Acts very freely, and possibly without recollecting that it occurs several chapters
before the account of the famine and of the other events which happened in the time of Claudius.
The Impostor Theudas and his Followers.
191
The Impostor Theudas and his Followers.