as a phantom, and not a substantial form. These scars would indeed have been mere illusive
appearances if no wounds had gone before; yet even the scars would not have remained if
416
He had willed it otherwise. But it pleased Him to retain them with a definite purpose, namely,
that to those whom He was building up in faith unfeigned He might show that one body
had not been substituted for another, but that the body which they had seen nailed to the
cross had risen again. What reason is there, then, for saying, “If He did this to convince the
doubting, He practised a deception”? Suppose that a brave man, who had received many
wounds in confronting the enemy when fighting for his country, were to say to a physician
of extraordinary skill, who was able so to heal these wounds as to leave not a scar visible,
that he would prefer to be healed in such a way that the traces of the wounds should remain
on his body as tokens of the honours he had won, would you, in such a case, say that the
physician practised deception, because, though he might by his art make the scars wholly
disappear, he did by the same art, for a definite reason, rather cause them to continue as
they were? The only ground upon which the scars could be proved to be a deception would
be, as I have already said, if no wounds had been healed in the places where they were seen.
8. Question II. Concerning the epoch of the Christian religion, they have advanced,
moreover, some other things, which they might call a selection of the more weighty arguments
of Porphyry against the Christians: “If Christ,” they say, “declares Himself to be the Way of
salvation, the Grace and the Truth, and affirms that in Him alone, and only to souls believing
in Him, is the way of return to God,2340 what has become of men who lived in the many
centuries before Christ came? To pass over the time,” he adds, “which preceded the founding
of the kingdom of Latium, let us take the beginning of that power as if it were the beginning
of the human race. In Latium itself gods were worshipped before Alba was built; in Alba,
also, religious rites and forms of worship in the temples were maintained. Rome itself was
for a period of not less duration, even for a long succession of centuries, unacquainted with
Christian doctrine. What, then, has become of such an innumerable multitude of souls, who
were in no wise blameworthy, seeing that He in whom alone saving faith can be exercised
had not yet favoured men with His advent? The whole world, moreover, was not less zealous
than Rome itself in the worship practised in the temples of the gods. Why, then,” he asks,
“did He who is called the Saviour withhold Himself for so many centuries of the world?
And let it not be said,” he adds, “that provision had been made for the human race by the
old Jewish law. It was only after a long time that the Jewish law appeared and flourished
within the narrow limits of Syria, and after that, it gradually crept onwards to the coasts of
Italy; but this was not earlier than the end of the reign of Caius, or, at the earliest, while he
was on the throne. What, then, became of the souls of men in Rome and Latium who lived
2340 John xiv. 6.
910
To Deogratias