VIII.—The Works of
Theodoret.
Of authorities for the works of
Theodoret we may first cite himself. In four of his letters he mentions
his own writings; viz.: in lxxxii, to Eusebius of Ancyra; in cxiii, to
Leo of Rome; in cxvi, to the Presbyter Renatus; and in cxlv, to the
monks at Constantinople. Of these the first was written in 445 and the
last three in 449 and a reference to them will show the works
mentioned. It is to be noticed
103
that no allusion is
made to the refutation of the twelve chapters; to the defence of
Diodorus of Tarsus and Theodorus of Mopsuestia, nor to the Dialogues,
though all are held to have been written before the Latrocinium. It may
have been, as Garnerius conjectures, that Theodoret did not judge it
politic at this time to call attention to these particular works, but
the assumption is not based on strong grounds, and Theodoret never
appears as one unwilling to avow his convictions, which indeed, were
perfectly well known.
Gennadius, presbyter of
Marseilles, who died in 496, writes “Theodoretus, bishop of
Cyrus, is said to have written many works: those, however, which have
come to my knowledge are the following; of the Incarnation of the Lord,
against the presbyter Eutyches, and Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria,
who deny that there was in Christ human flesh,—powerful writings
wherein he proves, as well by argument as by scriptural evidence, that
Christ had very flesh of the substance of His mother, which He took
from the Virgin, and very Godhead, which by eternal generation He
received, in being generated, from God the father begetting Him. There
exist also his books of Ecclesiastical History, which he wrote in
imitation of Eusebius of Cæsarea, beginning from the end of the
books of Eusebius down to his own time, viz.: from the twentieth year
of Constantine down to the reign of Leo I, in whose reign he
died.”
104
Photius, in the ninth century,
says that he has read the Ecclesiastical History; twenty-seven books
against Heresies, among which he reckons the “Eranistes;”
five books “Hæreticarum Fabularum;” five in praise of
Chrysostom; with Commentaries on Daniel, the Octateuch, Kings,
Chronicles, and the Twelve Minor Prophets.
Nicephorus Callistus Xanthopulus
in the fourteenth century, Hist.
Ecc. xiv. 54
, writes:
“Theodoretus, Syrian by birth, was a follower of the great
Chrysostom, whom he set before him as a model of style. His own was
flowing and copious, eloquent and easy, and not destitute of Attic
grace.” He mentions expositions of difficult passages of the Old
Testament; Commentaries on the Prophets and the Psalms; the “de
Providentia;” a volume “On the Apostles;” the
Confutation of heresies, called “the battle between truth and
falsehood;” the refutation of Cyril’s “Twelve
Chapters;” the Ecclesiastical History; the
“Philotheus,” a History of the Lovers of God; three books
on the divine doctrines, and five hundred (?) letters.
The following is the catalogue
of extant works as given by Sirmondus and followed by
Garnerius.
(i.)
Exegetical.
Questions on the Octateuch, the Books of Kings and Chronicles; the
Interpretation of the Psalms, Canticles, the Four Greater, and the
Twelve Lesser Prophets; an exposition of all the Epistles of St. Paul,
including the Hebrews.
(ii.)
Historical.
The
Ecclesiastical History, and the “Philotheus,” or Religious
History.
(iii.)
Controversial.
The
Eranistes, or Dialogues, and the Hæreticarum Fabularum
Compendium.
(iv.)
Theological.
The
Græcarum Affectionum Curatio, the Discourse on Charity, and the De
Providentia.
(v.)
Epistolary.
The
Letters.
(vi.) To these may be added the
Refutation of the Twelve Chapters, and the following given in the
Auctarium of Garnerius.
(1.) Prolegomena and extracts from Commentaries on the
Psalms.
(2.) Part of a Commentary on St.
Luke.
(3.) Sermon on the Nativity of
St. John the Baptist.
(4.) Portions of Sermons on St.
Chrysostom.
(5.) Homily preached at
Chalcedon in 431.
(6.) Fragments of the
Pentalogium, extracted from Marius Mercator,
105
who
attributed the work to the instigation of the devil.
Lost works.
106
(1.) The Pentalogium, of which
fragments are preserved in the Auctarium.
(2.) Opus mysticurn, sive
mysteriorum fidei expositiones, lib. xii.
(3.) Works “de theologia
et Incarnatione,” identified by Garnier with three Dialogues
against the Macedonians, and two against the Apollinarians, erroneously
attributed to Athanasius.
(4.) Adversus
Marcionem.
(5.) Adversus Judæos (? the
Commentary on Daniel).
(6.) Responsiones ad
quæsitus magorum Persarum.
(7.) Five sermons on St.
Chrysostom.
(8.) Two allocutions spoken at
Chalcedon against Cyril in 431.
(9.) Sermon preached at Antioch
on the death of Cyril.
(10.) Works on Sabellius and the
Trinity, of which portions are given by Baluz. Misc. iv.
103
Cf.
Garnerius in Migne’s Theodoret V. 255.
104
The
last record in the History appears to be of
a.d.
440, cf. p. 159. Eusebius ends, and Theodoret begins,
with the defeat of Licinius in 323. Constantine began to reign in
306.
105
A
writer, supposed to be a layman, whose works were discovered in two
mss.
at the end of the seventeenth century.
One is in the Vatican, the other was found in the Cathedral Library of
Beauvais. Marius wrote fully on the Nestorian Controversy, and with
acrimony against Theodoret.
106
As
catalogued by Canon Venables from Cave (Hist. Lit. I. 405 ff.) Dict.
Christ. Biog. iv. 918.