( IIAP. V.J CHRISTIAN RELIGION. 28o
by the pretext of having been incapable of acting otherwise,
he is prepared with an answer, which we have elsewhere ad-
vanced, that it aiises not from creation, bat from the corruption
of natm*e, that men, being enslaved by sin, can will nothing but
what is evil. For whence proceeded that impotence, of which
the ungodly would gladly avail themselves, but from Adam
voluntarily devoting himself to the tyranny of the devil ?
Hence, therefore, the corruption with which we are firmly
bound. It originated in the revplt of the first man from bis
Maker. If all men are justly accounted guilty of this rebellion,
let them not suppose themselves excused by necessity, in which
very thingthey have a most evident cause oftheir coildemnation.
And this I have before clearly explained, and have given an
example in the devil himself, which shows, that he who sins
necessarily, sins no less voluntarily ; and also in the elect an-
gels, whose will, though it cannot swerve from what is good,
ceases not to be a will. Bernard also judiciously inculcates
the same doctrine, that we are, therefore, the more miserable
because our necessity is voluntary ; which yet constrains us to
be so devoted to it, that we are, as we have already observed,
the slaves of sin. The second branch of their argument is
erroneous ; because it makes an improper transition from what
j^voluntary to what is free ; but we have before evinced, that
a thing may be done voluntarily, which yet is not the subject
of free choice.
II. They add, that unless both virtues and vices proceed
from the free choice of the will, it is not reasonable either that
punishments should be inflicted, or that rewards should be
conferred on man. This argument, though first advanced by
Ai-istotle, yet I grant is used on some occasions by Chrysostom
and Jerome. That it was familiar to the Pelagians, however,
Jerome himself does not dissemble, but even relates their own
words : "If the grace of God operates in us, then the crown
will be given to grace, not to us who labour." In regard to
punishments, I reply, that they are justly inflicted on us, from
whom the guilt of sin proceeds. For of what importance is it,
whether sin be committed with a judgment free or enslaved,
so it be committed with the voluntary bias of the passions
;
especially as man is proved to be a sinner, because he is sub-
ject to the servitude of sin? With respect to rewards of
righteousness, where is the great absurdity, if we confess that
they depend rather on the Divine benignity than on our own
merits ? How often does this recur in Augustine, " that God
crowns not our merits, but his own gifts ; and that they are
called rewards, not as though they were due to our merits, but
because they are retributions to the graces already conferred on
us !
'• They discover great acuteness in this observation, that
>