is not the term of communion or admission into the visible church: which is perfectly foreign
to the business. For the argument respects the object of this love, viz. visible saints, that are
to be thus beloved; and not at all the qualifications of the inherent subject of it, or the person
that exercises this love. If they that are admitted, are to be loved as true saints, or for the
image of Christ appearing in them, or supposed to be in them, (as Mr. W. allows (p. 68. c.)
then it will follow, that none are to be admitted, but such as can reasonably be the objects
of christian love, or be loved as true saints, and as those who have the image of Christ appear-
ing in them. Whether the exercise of this love be the term of communion, or not; yet if we
are commanded to exercise this love to all that are admitted to communion, then it will
certainly follow, that some reasonable ground for being thus beloved, must be a term of
communion in such as a are admitted. To suppose it appointed, that we should love all that
are admitted as true saints, and yet that it is not appointed that such as are admitted should
exhibit any reasonable grounds for such a love, is certainly to suppose very inconsistent
appointments. 415
Mr. W.‘s second answer (p. 70. b.) is no less impertinent; viz. That men’s right to com-
munion in gospel-ordinances does not depend upon the corruptions of other men, in their
forbearing to love them. As if my argument were, that unless men are actually loved, as true
saints, they have no right to communion! Whereas, the argument was very diverse, viz. That
unless men have a right to be so loved, they have no right to communion. If men have an
appearance, to reason, of being true saints, they may have a right to be loved as true saints,
and to be admitted as such; however corrupt and void of love other men are: but without
such an appearance to reason, it is no corruption, not to love them as true saints; unless it
513
be corrupt, not to act without reason. 416 —As to Mr. W.’s third answer, and the misrepres-
entation it is built upon, it has already been taken notice of.
415 “The apostles looked on all those, whom they gathered into churches or christian congregations to eat
the Lord’s supper, as having the truth dwelling in them: and so they behoved, every one of them, to look upon
one another: seeing they could not love one another as brethren in the truth, without acknowledging that truth
as dwelling in them. And so we see the apostles, in their writings to the churches, supposing all their members
objects of this brotherly love.—Christ’s visible church then is the congregation of those whom the apostle could
call the saints and faithful in Christ Jesus.”—Glass’s Notes on Scripture Texts, Numb. 5. p. 32.
416 A good argument might also be drawn from the corruption of unsanctified men; for that they are all
sounder the power of corruption, that they are not able to love saints, or any one else, with truly christian love.
Agreeable to what Mr. Stoddard says in his three sermons, (p. 40 ) “Men are obliged to love their neighbours as
themselves. But no natural men do in any measure live up to this rule; but men are great enemies one to another,
hateful and hating one another. They do but little good one to another: they do a great deal of hurt one to another.”
1977
SECTION III. Irrelevant arguments.