OBJECT. II.
Visible saintship in the scripture sense cannot be the same with that which has been
supposed and insisted on, because Israel of old were called God’s people, when it is certain
the greater part of them were far from having any such visible holiness as this. Thus the ten
tribes were called God’s people, Hos. iv. 6.. after they had revolted from the true worship of
God, and had obstinately continued in their idolatrous worship at Bethel and Dan for about
two hundred and fifty years, and were at that time, a little before their captivity especially,
in the height of their wickedness. So the Jews are called God’s people, in Ezek. xxxvi. 20.. and
other places, at the time of their captivity in Babylon, a time when most of them were
abandoned to all kinds of the most horrid and open impieties, as the prophets frequently
represent. Now it is certain, that the people at that time were not called God’s people because
of any visibility of true piety to the eye of reason or of a rational charity, because most of
them were grossly wicked, and declared their sin as Sodom. And in the same manner wherein
the Jews of old were God’s people, are the members of the visible christian Gentile church
God’s people; for they are spoken of as graffed into the same olive-tree, from whence the
former were broken off by unbelief.
Answ. 1. The argument proves too much, and therefore nothing at all. Those whom I
oppose in this controversy, will in effect as much oppose themselves in it, as me. The objec-
tion, if it has any force, equally militates against their and my notion of visible saintship.
For those Jews, which it is alleged were called God’s people, and yet were so notoriously,
openly, and obstinately wicked, had neither any visibility of true piety, nor yet of that moral
sincerity in the profession and duties of the true religion, which the opponents themselves
suppose to be requisite in order to a proper visible holiness, and a due admission to the
privileges and ordinances of the church of God. None will pretend, that these obstinate id-
olaters and impious wretches had those qualifications which are now requisite in order to
an admission to the christian sacraments. And therefore to what purpose can they bring
this objection? which, if it proves any thing, overthrows my scheme and their own both to-
462
gether, and both in an equally effectual manner. And not only so, but will thoroughly destroy
the schemes of all protestants through the world, concerning the qualifications of the subjects
of christian ordinances. And therefore the support of what I have laid down against those
whom I oppose in this controversy, requires no further answer to this objection. Nevertheless,
for greater satisfaction, I would here observe further:
2. That such appellations as God’s people, God’s Israel, and some other like phrases, are
used and applied in Scripture with considerable diversity of intention. Thus, we have a plain
distinction between the house of Israel and the house of Israel, in Ezek. xx. 38-40.. By the
house of Israel in the 39th verse is meant literally the nation or family of Israel; but by the
house of Israel in the 40th verse seems to be intended the spiritual house, the body of God’s
visible saints, that should attend the ordinances of his public worship in gospel—times. So
OBJ. II. Israel was God's people.
1825
OBJ. II. Israel was God's people.