Chapter
XLI.—The Woe Pronounced on the Traitor a Judicial Act, Which
Disproves Christ to Be Such as Marcion Would Have Him to Be.
Christ’s Conduct Before the Council Explained. Christ Even Then
Directs the Minds of His Judges to the Prophetic Evidences of His Own
Mission. The Moral Responsibility of These Men Asserted.
“Woe,” says He, “to that man by
whom the Son of man is betrayed!”
5094
Now it is certain that in this
woe
must be understood the
imprecation and threat of an angry and incensed Master, unless Judas
was to escape with impunity after so vast a sin. If he were meant to
escape with impunity, the
“woe”
was an idle word; if
not, he was of course to be punished by Him against whom he had
committed the sin of treachery. Now, if He knowingly permitted
the man, whom He
5095
deliberately
elected to be one of His companions, to plunge into so great a crime,
you must no longer use an argument against the Creator in Adam’s
case, which may now recoil on your own God:
5096
either that he was
ignorant
, and had no foresight to hinder the
future sinner;
5097
or that he was
unable
to hinder him, even if he was ignorant;
5098
or else that he was
unwilling
, even
if he had the foreknowledge and the ability; and so deserved the stigma
of maliciousness, in having permitted the man of his own choice to
perish in his sin. I advise you therefore (willingly) to acknowledge
the Creator in that god of yours, rather than against your will to be
assimilating your excellent god to Him. For in the case of
Peter,
5099
too, he gives you
proof that he is a jealous God, when he destined the apostle, after his
presumptuous protestations of zeal, to a flat denial of him, rather
than
prevent his fall
.
5100
The Christ of the
prophets was destined, moreover, to be betrayed with a kiss,
5101
for He was the Son indeed of Him who was
“honoured
with the lips
” by the people.
5102
When led before the council, He is asked
whether He is the Christ.
5103
Of what Christ
could the Jews have inquired
5104
but their own? Why,
therefore, did He not, even at that moment, declare to them the rival
(Christ)? You reply, In order that He might be able to suffer. In other
words, that this most excellent god might plunge men into crime, whom
he was still keeping in ignorance. But even if he had told them, he
would yet have to suffer. For he said, “If I tell you, ye will
not believe.”
5105
And refusing to
believe, they would have continued to insist on his death. And would he
not even more probably still have had to suffer, if had announced
himself as sent by the rival god, and as being, therefore, the enemy of
the Creator? It was not, then, in order that He might suffer, that He
at that critical moment refrained from proclaiming
5106
Himself the other
Christ
, but because
they wanted to extort a confession from His mouth, which they did not
mean to believe even if He had given it to them, whereas it was their
bounden duty to have acknowledged Him in consequence of His works,
which were fulfilling their Scriptures. It was thus plainly His course
to keep Himself at that moment unrevealed,
5107
because a spontaneous recognition was due to Him. But yet for all this,
He with a solemn gesture
5108
says,
“Hereafter shall the Son of man sit on the right hand of the
power of God.”
5109
For it was on the
authority of the prophecy of Daniel that He intimated to them that He
was “the Son of man,”
5110
and of
David’s Psalm, that He would “sit at the right hand of
God.”
5111
Accordingly, after
He had said this, and so suggested a comparison of the Scripture, a ray
of light did seem to show them whom He would have them understand Him
to be; for they say: “Art thou then the Son of
God?”
5112
Of what God, but of
Him whom alone they knew? Of what God but of Him whom they remembered
in the Psalm as having said to
His Son, “Sit Thou on my right
hand?” Then He answered, “Ye say that I am;”
5113
as if He meant: It is
ye
who say
this—not I. But at the same time He allowed Himself to be all
that they had said, in this their second question.
5114
By what means, however, are you going to
prove to us that they pronounced the sentence “
Ergo tu
filius Dei es
” interrogatively, and not
affirmatively?
5115
Just as, (on the
one hand,) because He had shown them in an indirect manner,
5116
by passages of Scripture, that they ought to
regard Him as the Son of God, they therefore meant their own words,
“Thou art then the Son of God,” to be taken in a like
(indirect) sense,
5117
as much as to say,
“You do not wish to say this of yourself plainly,”
5118
so, (on the other hand,) He likewise
answered them, “Ye say that I am,” in a sense equally free
from doubt, even affirmatively;
5119
and so
completely was His statement to this effect, that they insisted on
accepting that sense which His statement indicated.
5120
5094
Luke xxii. 22
.
5095
Ipse.
5096
This is an
argumentum ad hominem
against Marcion for his cavil, which was
considered above in book ii. chap. v.–viii. p. 300.
5097
Obstitit
peccaturo.
5098
Si ignorabat. One
would have expected “si
non
ignorabat,”
like the “si sciebat” of the next step in the argument.
5099
The original of this
not very clear sentence is: “Nam et Petrum præsumptorie
aliquid elocutum negationi potius destinando zeloten deum tibi
ostendit.”
5100
Luke
xxii. 34 and 54–62
.
5101
Luke xxii. 47–49
.
5102
Isa. xxix. 13
.
5103
Luke xxii. 66, 67
.
5104
Oehler’s
admirable edition is also carefully
printed
for the most part,
but surely his
quæsisset
must here be
quæsissent
.
5105
Luke xxii. 67
.
5106
Supersedit
ostendere.
5107
i.e., not to answer
that question of theirs. This seems to be the force of the perfect
tense, “
occultasse se
.”
5108
He makes Jesus stretch
forth His hand,
porrigens manum
inquit.
5109
Luke xxii. 69
.
5110
Dan. vii. 13
.
5111
Ps. cx. 1
.
5112
Luke xxii. 70
.
5113
Luke xxii. 70
.
5114
Or does he
suppose that they repeated this same question
twice
? His words
are, “dum rursus interrogant.”
5115
Either, “Art
thou,” or, “Thou art, then, the Son of God.”
5116
Oblique.
5117
Ut, quia…sic
senserunt.
5118
Aperte.
5119
Æque ita et ille
confirmative respondit.
5120
Ut perseveraverint in
eo quod pronuntiatio sapiebat.…See
Luke xxii. 71
.