concerning the wedding garment, in its place, and make the most of it: but to use it as the
support of other arguments, is to produce no additional proof. And thus, from time to time,
to produce the disputed hypothesis of one argument, for answer to the arguments of my
antagonist, instead of solving those arguments, is flying and hiding from arguments, instead
of answering them: instead of defending the fortress which is attacked, it is dodging and
flying from one refuge to another.
Mr. W. acts this part from time to time, in the use he makes of his great argument from
the Old-Testament church and its ordinances. Thus (in p. 8.) he takes this method to answer
my argument from the nature of visibility and profession, insisting that the Israelites
avouching and covenanting was a thing compatible with ungodliness; which he knows is a
disputed point in this controversy, and what I deny.—Again, he makes use of the same thing,
in answer to my argument from the nature of covenanting with God. (p. 23, 24.) And again
he brings it in, (p. 25. e. 26. a.) answering what I say, by confidently asserting that concerning
the church of Israel, which he knows is disputed, and I deny; viz. That the covenanting of
Israel did not imply a profession that they did already believe and repent: as in these words,
“This was never intended nor understood, in the profession which the Israelites made; but
that they would immediately and from thenceforth comply with the terms of the covenant;
and by the help of God, offered in it, would fulfil it. I am sure, this was what they professed;
and I am sure, God declared he took them into covenant with him.” And the same thing is
brought in again to answer the same argument, (p. 31. c.)—The same thing is thrown in,
once and again, as an answer to what I say of the unreasonableness of accepting such pro-
fessions as leave room to judge the greater part of the professors to be enemies of God. (p.
34. b. c.) The same thing is cast in as a sufficient block in the way of my arguing from the
unreasonableness of accepting such professions, as amount to nothing more than lukewarm-
ness. (p. 36. d. e.) The same is brought in, and greatly insisted on, to stop my mouth, in ar-
guing from the Epistles. (p. 56, 57.) The same is brought in again, to enervate my argument
concerning brotherly love. (p. 69. d.) And this is made use of as the support of other argu-
ments; as that from the name disciples, and about the church being the school of Christ; and
to confute what I say, in answer to that argument. (p. 84. a.) The same is brought in as a
support of the eleventh objection, and a confutation of my answer to that. (p. 125. c. d. e.)
And again, in reply to what I say in answer to the nineteenth objection. (p. 137. b. c.)
Another thing, near akin to begging the question, is resting the weight of arguments on
things asserted without proof; which, though they do not properly make a part of the con-
troversy, yet are things not allowed by those on the other side.—Thus does Mr. W. in his
arguing from the success of the Lord’s supper in the conversion of sinners, (p. 137,138.)
Supposing, not only that the Lord’s supper has been the occasion of the conversion of many,
but that their communicating was the means of it. This he offers nothing to prove, and it is
1993
SECTION VIII. Mr. W. begs the question.